Jump to content

Close

Bail o' Lies

Member Since 06 Apr 2015
Offline Last Active Today, 04:06 AM

Posts I've Made

In Topic: Bail o' Lies issues with Boruto.

11 November 2026 - 07:31 AM

"What was the point of Naruto only becoming hokage after Kakashi? Why not continue Tsunade as 5th kage, Naruto as 6th, and Konohamaru as 7th (as he told at the beginning of shippuden? Or was that just filler?)."

 

Literally. Promotion for the Last. Kakashi is the most popular Naruto character in Japan. So Kakashi as Hokage was a hype moment to get them interested in the movie along with intentionally hiding the pairing till the manga ended making most fans that would buy a ticket thinking it was NS. Yes it ruined Konohamaru, Tsunade, Kakashi and Naruto's arcs but the Anime staff didn't care they wanted to get everyone wanting to see Hinata's big movie.

 

"Okay, I've read a bit more about Yahagi, who basically after Naruto rose up to be one of main people in Shueisha, and Kishimoto, who couldn't land Samurai 8 and (which he didn't even draw himself!), and boruto situation really feels artificial."

 

Yahagi was also the editor of Hunter X Hunter at the same time. When he left it was the start of the endless hiatus mode it went into...well besides the mangaka Togashi's health issues. He is still the Editor-in-Chief of one of their magazines. Wait no, he stepped down from that and was promoted to an executive in Shueisha in 2017. They know that a lot of Naruto's success is due to him being the editor for ten years. It's not like Kishimoto has ever hidden that information. It was just behind the language & translation barrier.

 

Kishimoto, while a better artist, was known for his storytelling. He found it exhausting to do both. So he got another old assistant to draw the art while he did the writing. This is an increasingly popular arrangement in the Japanese mangaka scene, as it lowers the pressure and burnout that leaving it to one person causes.

 

Boruto's existence is entirely artificial. It exists to keep the Naruto IP going and it would have ended by its first year if not for that. They won't end it because they fear how much that would affects the IP since Kishimoto refuses to get rid of Ikemoto and allow someone else to take over.

 

"What surprised me, is that after gaiden (Sakura/Karin punchbag) I tunde out, years later to comeback, read the descriptions of novels and Sasuke basicly been running around 10+ years assasinationg "dangerous" people? In what world is that a "save" that was done by Naruto to him? Because he's not an Orochimaru level maniac and is on "good guys" side? Thats exactly what Danzo was with his black ops anbu squads, damn."

 

They don't want you to think about it too deeply. Sasuke is cool and successful to the point that Boruto wants his role.

 

"And about shadow rising, when I think about it, contextually, if he wanted to take IP away from boruto and in other direction, at least rewriting 699/700 would be needed, or "canon retelling" of Naruto and Sasuke fight in VoE for changing characterization for whatever he feels is better. And without retconing boruto, what would this add? There is no major deaths that occured in "blank" period, so it'll be just padding for NH and SS with slice of life and depending if its before the last, it can add another nasty nail into NS?"

 

Like I said in other posts, Kishimoto does not want to betray Ikemoto. He is not trying to take away Boruto from Ikemoto. He thought he could do this manga without affecting Boruto. He wanted to fix the final fight because it was rushed; anyone who has read it should agree with that though. Kishimoto does not like nH/SS but going against those would be a retcon and screw over Ikemoto, something Kishimoto refuses to do, so they stay despite his likely personal distaste for them. He honestly thought he could fix a few things in a side manga without affecting Boruto because he doesn't understand just how much Boruto is disliked. The remaining fans want Boruto overturned and replaced even if they want the pairings to remain. Him doing a new manga before the Boruto timeline is the perfect way to retcon Boruto, which he is the only one to not realize that, and so they are looking at the situation and letting their desires create reality. Ignoring anything Kishimoto says to the contrary.

 

"I thought back then, it was just an add-on/extended part to the story (though there were so many changes, such as Konohamaru calling out to Sakura before Naruto came back home and how the NaruSaku reunion doesn't have Tsunade in the scene) but after The Last/Boruto, it is now filler."

 

It was assumed at the start of Part Two of the anime, Naruto would follow Tsunade and then Konohamaru would follow after Naruto. It wasn't till they needed something big to hype up The Last movie that they decided to make Kakashi Hokage. Tsunade informed Sakura that Naruto was back in the manga. They changed it to remove Tsunade and focus more on Konohamaru. In the manga, Tsunade and Jiraiya both noted that the other student became more like the teacher. Tsunade noted Naruto had picked up Jiraiya's perversion, while Jiraiya noticed Sakura had picked up Tsunade's strength, beauty, and temper. 

In Topic: Bail o' Lies issues with Boruto.

11 November 2026 - 12:56 AM

I have a good memory if prompted, particularly for storylines. Most of this has been written on that recall, I did not look through old chapters at any point. Well, besides looking up character names through google because I cannot bring myself to care to remember them. I do not do the summaries to hate read, but to basically to inform this site what is happening in a manga they refuse to read. If they are interested at how bad it is. Its poor quality over the past decade however has given me a burning hatred for it though. As at the start I didn't think it was possible to be this bad. 

 

Story/Narrative section is barely about the plot because there barely is any in the manga and more about how Ikemoto's pacing make their entire plan untenable and fell apart pretty much before it could even get started. I am always of the opinion that they can always just reset it and it would be better. Simply because Ikemoto has written so little it would only take another writer about 3 years to make a better manga story.

 

Character's is explained in the first part of it, mostly. The only character's the matter are Ikemoto's as those are the only group he cares about. He doesn't want the rest of the cast so he doesn't use them unless order to. At the end I breakdown Boruto himself just to show how much of a mess that Character is and why he doesn't work. Shikamaru is the worse case because he is one of the few used that the audience generally know his personality and role. A lazy bum that is the World's Smartest Man. While in Boruto, it is amazing if he could count to ten. Sakura has appeared maybe 3 times in the manga: Inform her daughter that her seal was based off the Karma seal (not really what she said but what they manga wanted you to get out of it,) her taking care of Sasuke and Sarada after a fight, and her speech to her daughter. She has never interacted with Naruto in the manga. Anime? I do not know and do not care about.

 

Kishimoto is not doing anything in Boruto besides giving Ikemoto advice if he is asked. He sees it as ikemoto's manga and only wants to help out if possible due to him seeing it as Ikemoto taking that burden for him. But also means he often isn't really doing anything for Boruto or his original work. In fact, he lets ikemoto do what ever he wants because he feels he owes him. So, again, Boruto is largely all Ikemoto. There really isn't malice on Kishimoto's part. He had distance himself from Naruto for years both due to exhaustion and to give Ikemoto room; until the Minato one shot and his new manga. Which he does because he thought he could do something he wanted to do in the franchise that wouldn't negatively affect Ikemoto's work. Of course Ikemoto's work is so dislike even its supporters are begging anyone else to take over. As they are fans of the franchise not Ikemoto.

 

Boruto exist to continue the IP. Naruto was ended in a way to make Boruto happen. That said because Naruto's end goal was so underdeveloped it only makes the story unsatisfying. The Shadow Enforcer was to give Sasuke and Boruto an end goal beside Hokage that make them "equal" to Naruto/Sarada. Granted that pretty much means they are the New Danzo. Though the franchise doesn't like that comparison.

 

"Also read comment about fake jiraiya having some type of jutsu that potentially opens case for parallel universes/timelines? But you didn't mention anything like that, so I guess thats not really a case?" What. He has nothing like that. He has "Prescience" a fancy way of saying, "he can see the future. He has a future sight." He can see possible futures and is trying to direct their world to the best one he can manage through narrow margins. Which causes Boruto to have constant hissy fits.

 

Shadow Rising is Kishimoto finally trying to fix the unsatisfying final battle due to the original being rushed and the issues of Naruto becoming Hokage. He can fix the first one no problem. The issue is the second one is where the problem come from. For one, Naruto being Hokage for longer does not fix any of the issues. The problem there is that he seems to have done nothing in the role. The two, because it was establish that Naruto only became Hokage recently during the time of Boruto and his inauguration was treated as a joke. The Boruto have run with that for the past ten years. It is canon to Boruto as far as everyone but Kishimoto is concern. So, by trying to fix that, it makes it seem like he is planning on retconning Boruto out of the IP. Which everyone wants, but him.

In Topic: The Great Naruto Discussion Thread

04 November 2026 - 01:49 AM

They need to do Kushina=Naruto and Minato=Hinata because Kushina is too much like Sakura. So when people years ago tried to do Kushina=Hinata it was picked apart pretty quickly.

 

Both of them have long hair...ok so did Sakura at one point, and Kushina has her long hair due to the fact Minato likes her hair. Hinata has it just as a shorthand to make clear she is from a noble family.

They were both abducted by the Cloud(Black) Ninjas. Due to the race the Cloud ninja are often depicted as it is not allowed to depict them as evil. So this parallel is buried. Also Minato rescued her, Naruto didn't.

Minato complimented Kushina's red hair just like Naruto complimented Sakura's forehead...with he never really complimented Hinata beyond a "you are all right" once. 

 

So they had to switched to Minato=Hinata as they are both the calm one, and Naruto=Kushina as they are the energetic one. No matter how shallow that is compared to NS=MK.

 

Tsunade also concluded that speech by saying Naruto likes big breast as the final ultimate conclusion of why they wouldn't work out.

 

Again, the switched was a last minute thing because he was told "fans wanted it" and it would help out Ikemoto's manga sales.

 

He is not going to do anything that stabs Ikemoto in the back. At least not intentionally.

In Topic: After 10 years, Naruto is officially getting a revival in 2027

28 October 2026 - 06:08 AM

Why does it seem like Therece only comments when I am not here for a few days? Oh and she didn't reply to any of my posts on her, "Did NaruSaku only have a chance because Sasuke was away?" Again, why not? Can she not answer them? Can she not find any way to counter them?

 

Anyways:

 

"Kishimoto got bored and wanted to start a new manga series."

 

Ok. Problem is it goes against the establish canon of Boruto and rumors that he considers Boruto non canon have been accepted by the wider internet.

 
"Naruto remains a goldmine with a vast, unexplored big period in its lore. Creating a new Naruto story is far easier than attempting a brand-new original series (like Samurai 8 was)."
 
It once was a goldmine over a decade ago. But he did a few things that have made the franchise lose that prestige and value. The years of continual "mining" while not fixing the issues has let it "gone dry." Also, if an artist cannot create something new and can only cling to past glories. He is by definition a has-been.
 
"He grew tired of seeing his original characters ruined and watching the overall popularity of the franchise decline due to Ikemoto, which prompted him to step back in."
 
How dare you! He respects Ikemoto's work and would be insulted if you suggested he thought lesser of Ikemoto's manga! Or that he even thinks the decline of IP is due to Ikemoto and not other factors. And you call yourself a fan of Kishimoto? The fact that you claim to be a fan of his work while pretending we were not once. Is just proof of how far the fandom has sunken.
 
I think Ikemoto on some level resent Kishimoto, thinks he was just lucky, and could do better than him. As that is the feel I get from the manga. But as far as I can recount I have never said the reverse. At best I make clear he has washed his hands of the franchise and has to come back due to its failing.
 
"Shueisha, along with everyone else involved, was actively begging him to return."
 
They want him back because Boruto is a complete flop. But he doesn't want to stab Ikemoto in the back when he has been taking those hits for him. If Ikemoto didn't volunteered to become the mangaka for Boruto. Kishimoto would have been pressured to take it up on his own. When Boruto exist because he didn't want to write Naruto anymore. He doesn't see the failings of Boruto as Ikemoto's fault. I do. If the failure of Boruto is due to things like the parings of nH and SS he doesn't blame Ikemoto for that he blames himself. Which is why he is trying to do some fixes to the mess of a pairing in the new manga. 
 
His new manga was what he thought was a safe middle ground. He can fix some of the issues with Naruto; a poor final fight he was never satisfied with as well as the issue of Naruto only recently becoming Hokage in Boruto. While not going against anything in Ikemoto's manga, in his mind. Problem is he does go against it, due to his new manga going against was has been established as canon in Boruto and he has stuck his foot in his mouth once again.
 
By the why you should probably read the twitter post again Therece. He hopes that this new manga would get people interest in Boruto. This manga exist to help out Ikemoto.
 
"It's time to accept NaruSaku as fanon.   Kishimoto will never retcon his own manga's ending just to pair Sakura with Naruto."
 
Oh we already know that. He won't stab Ikemoto in the back. Though you clearly want him to. If it ever happen is when the company has had enough and is willing to undo the pairings that NS could happen. But IP would probably be cancelled long before then.
 
Lets deal with the three "copes," at the same time. People hopes the Infinite Tsukuyomi as it could be a quick fix to the mess that was the ending. It wouldn't fix everything. There were more problems than just the pairings. Look at my problems with Boruto topic, I eventually do go into what problems it inherited from Naruto. Kishimoto is not going to do anything that could damage Ikemoto's manga or his reputation. At least not intentionally. Unintentionally, that is all he is doing.
 
"First Blow from the Live-Action Movie: The movie will completely erase Naruto's feelings for Sakura while pushing SasuSaku and Sasuke's feelings right from the start. It will likely do the same for Hinata and NaruHina when she appears in the second movie to avoid useless love triangles, ship wars, and Sakura hate for rejecting Naruto."
 
The leaks make it very clear she is going to be a girl boss. Which is the opposite of Sakura and her appeal. People long have gotten sick of those due to Hollywood drowning their audience in them for well over the past dacade. They are going to have Sasuke chase her while she is disinterested, so she can be a strong independent woman, which is not the appeal of that pairing. If Naruto does not love Sakura then "the promise of a lifetime," does not work. He is apparently a pathetic nerdy simp that is too cowardly to even think of having feelings for her. That going to turn off old fans of the story and going to repeal casual audiences. 
 
"Second Blow: In Kishimoto’s blank period manga, the first thing Kishimoto shows is Sakura carrying a black-haired newborn baby. Sakura and Sasuke's child."
 
Kishimoto has always seen SS as a toxic cliché mess of a pairing he doesn't like. He went through with it because Ikemoto thought its fans would support his manga. They didn't as your actions prove or there were not enough of them. However, he has entrusted the anime staff to handle nH, which is the pairing he doesn't get the appeal of. So his job is to address the issues of SS. As most of the manga makes clear that Sasuke does not love her, but now he does. So Ikemoto's manga can have a love interest for his main character. 

In Topic: The Great Naruto Discussion Thread

28 October 2026 - 05:17 AM

Oh while I am thinking of it how are people my problems with Boruto topic? No one commented on it so far. Which I hope is because they want to not interrupt the flow of my post and not disinterest.