Posted 10 January 2013 - 05:47 AM
Unexpected wall of text ahead... I didn't mean to type so much.
I didn't start Naruto for the pairings and I don't read it for the pairings, but it's obvious that some of the romance stuff has been taking center stage lately and it worries me.
I've said it before, I don't generally ship any pairings unless the author is obviously trying to tie 2 characters together or if romance is the point of the manga (as are many shoujos) After a long time trying to remember, there's only 1 obvious main pairing that I don't like, not because it wasn't built up, but because one of the characters are boring and one dimensional compared to the other option. (That would be Katekyo Hitman Reborn. When I was reading it, I was rooting for Haru, Kyoko has always been so boring. She's like a cardboard prize with no personality, or at least she was at the point I was reading)
Throughout Naruto, or mostly part 2 (I didn't care about romance in part 1 because until near the end because before, it all seemed like kiddie love until you see Naruto's hurt face when Sakura hugs Sasuke, Sakura's heartfelt confession, and lastly, POAL) When part 2 arrived, it seemed to my 15 year old self that Naruto and Sakura were getting closer, not romantically at first though. I'm not sure when I started seeing them romantically, but it was slow and it started somewhere in part 2.
If I reread Naruto from start to finish (which I have a few times) I feel that Kishi was definitely leading Naruto and Sakura into a relationship. It was painstakingly slow, but in my eyes, it was going in that direction. My opinion didn't come out of nowhere, I was reading long completed manga at about the same time I started reading Naruto (Tokyo Crazy Paradise, Fruit Baskets, Rurouni Kenshin, Flame of Recca, YuYu Hakusho -which I haven't finished-, etc) Not all of these really relate to Naruto that much, but how the romance progressed did. They formed my view on how main pairings are formed and how progression generally goes in manga.
Back then, Kishi was going in a similar slow paced direction with Sakura and Naruto, both having occasional moments of recognizing each other and their strengths (not always romantic after first mind you) Kishi built them up so close, it wasn't my imagination or the imagination of many fans. Whether people agree with that development is not my problem or Kishi's problem. Whatever pairing you support, it's common sense to recognize the common tropes that fit Naruto and Sakura to a tee and realize they were definitely heading in a romantic direction.
Back to the point, in general, the romance doesn't bother me as long as he's consistent. Hey, if Kishi had been developing Naruto and Hinata all this time, maybe I would have been an NH fan. If Kishi were going in that direction, who am I to fight against it? Maybe I wouldn't have liked it and I would have liked Naruto with Sakura still, just like I like Haru with Tsuna in Katekyo Hitman Reborn. But no way would I ever argue that my pairing is going to be canon in the end if the evidence suggests otherwise. I've complained about how I dislike the obvious pairing in KHR, but I already know the pairing I like is never to be, the author is going in a different direction, I'm honestly fine with that.
What I don't like is if after he has developed Naruto and Sakura so far, Kishi suddenly decides to do some off panel development and give a character who didn't even show up in part 1 or part 2 ages after they started and who has only 10-20 chapters where they appear. That is obviously not where development was going before, and it is too late in game to change it now. I don't know how anyone who supports any pairing can be happy with NH being canon as of now. What development and dedication has Kishi given to them together or Hinata's character? Where is their foundation up until this point? What makes their pairing endearing at all other than a shy girl who couldn't even fill Naruto's lonely existence when he needed it most stepping up and accomplishing her own selfish wishes rather than the hopes and dreams one she supposedly loves so much? (getting Sasuke back and becoming Hokage)
Maybe if Kishi had made me want to support their pairing, I would, but he hasn't. The pairing is flat, it has no juice. "Quality is better than Quantity" Maybe that applies to some things, but it certainly doesn't apply to love, friendship, or relationships in general. You don't have a relationship if you can't even have a normal conversation on a normal basis. Does Naruto have to be near death for Hinata to ask him on a date? Will Naruto have to be in extreme pain for her to ask him for his hand? The last time I recall them ever having a conversation is during the chuunin exams, 4-5 years ago in the Naruto world.
As for SS, in part 1, I figured they could end up as a couple, even though my mind was still hypothesizing Sakura and Naruto would end up together. Again, I didn't care too much back then because most of it seemed like puppy love, Sakura was extremely annoying for a while with her Sasuke fangirling, and none of the pairings had much foundation. I had no problem with SS or Sasuke in the beginning. I didn't like his cold attitude, but it didn't seem like he was trying to be cool and impress girls back then, he was just a little emo boy who thought a lot about himself. He wasn't my favorite, but I didn't hate him. I also didn't mind if Sakura got with him. She was extremely shallow, I figure if they did get together, it would be like any other manga couple that gets together just for looks, Sasuke would dump her in a heartbeat if he found someone who he thought was more worthy of his time, and Sakura would mature. (That didn't happen obviously, or did it?) And although it was harsh and mean, I didn't mind Sasuke occasionally telling her that she was annoying. She needed to cut some of that fangirling sh** out. XD
But soon enough, Sasuke behaviour turned too cruel and cold hearted. She was only looking out for him, his "I'm superior, you better not pull me down" attitude towards Naruto and Sakura started to piss me off. Soon enough, I no longer support SS, and SS was done for me as soon as he knocked Sakura out and left her alone. It was further buried for me when they met up again and Sasuke was even worse off than when he left. I didn't feel sorry for him at all, he chose to leave Naruto and Sakura. I don't want to hear any excuses about "Oh, he was only using Orochimaru". If he was really using Oro, he would have returned to Konoha after he killed him or after he killed Itachi. From then on, I begged everyday that Naruto and Sakura would just leave him alone and continue on with their lives, not because I wanted Sasuke out of the way and for NS to happen, but because they were both being hurt for someone that didn't care about them. Such obsessive behavior of chasing someone who doesn't want to be chased should not be encouraged, Tsunade and Jiraiya should have stomped that out of Naruto while it was still fresh. Sakura would have gotten over it.
So, in my eyes, Kishi has not been heading in NH or SS's direction. He hasn't exactly stomped those pairings out, but just like in other mangas, NH and SS were not getting major positive attention whatsoever. It fit the flow, nothing seemed too out of place and there weren't any cringe worthly moments where I felt like "Where did this come from?" Of course, that's changed now. I won't say Kishi is changing his direction from just 1 chapter, but he is starting to lean into a more radical direction. Imagine a graph where everything is either flatline, steadly going up, or steadily going down. Kishi's more recent developments have disturbed the steady pace and has caused one of the lines to take a dramatic turn upwards. It's obvious that that particular line is out of place.
That is what I don't like. I don't like for any developments to happen too suddenly or out of nowhere. For example, I really love Minato and Kushina, but I would seriously questions Kishi's writing developments if they've suddenly been alive all this time and appear on the battlefield out of nowhere. When Kishi changes his graph of lines too much, it gets harder and harder for NS to seem valid (I'm not talking about confirmation here) I don't want NS to happen because Kishi drew them kissing on a page or because they're suddenly holding hands. When they finally get together, I want it to be the final piecing together of everything they've done for each other until this point. When they get together, I want it to finally be realized that everything they feel for each other is mutual and for that moment to actually mean something for them as characters.
NH won't do this for me. Maybe it will for Hinata fans, she's finally getting her wish, but what about Naruto? I'm not saying he won't be happy, that's silly, but will anyone who has been reading Naruto so long really feel that Naruto's development (in the romance sector) will finally be capped off and completed? Or whole? I can't imagine Sakura having grown at all if she manages to get with Sasuke, if Sasuke even cares about her that way, which I don't think he ever will (he screams asexual honestly).
For NS to be valid, not confirmed, Kishi really needs to step it up and stop playing around so much so close to end game.