21 replies to this topic

[melovechoco]

I know...im a bit late....because im so busy with schoolworks and everything....since january until now ..and decided to not surf internet during that time and right now, im taking a school break....not that long actually...so, i decided to watch some random anime reviews and stumbled on one of Codeprovider's videos(well , sometimes i do watches his videos...) and he just admitted that Kishi actually watched his videos about him hating the manga.This proves showed during kishi interviewed his favourite manga artist who is behind the work of 'blade of the immortal' ...and he also mentioned that he watches one of the naruto haters 'video from overseas and at the same time, realize that 'person ' also tends to love the same manga by just looking his wall which is full of 'blade of the immortal' covers...


Conclusion: Now, im really convinced that this why kishi destroys his manga overall...one of them is because of THE FANDOM!!!

Ps: im sorry if i dissapoints someone here...

Here the links :https://youtu.be/YD5u_GQLNI4

[Nar123]

If KIshi let himself be influenced by some pairing fandom's general opinion while writing the story he definitely is no good as an author

Edited by Nar123, 23 July 2015 - 02:56 AM.

[NaruSaku fan in Kentucky]

If KIshi let himself be influenced by some pairing fandom's general opinion while writing the story he definitely is no good as an author

Who the hell is that? 

Edited by NaruSaku fan in Kentucky, 23 July 2015 - 03:23 AM.

[NaruSaku fan in Kentucky]

Also if that's the case then I wonder what if he saw Luckychi7's reviews he would've done what he should've done. 

[Nar123]

Also if that's the case then I wonder what if he saw Luckychi7's reviews he would've done what he should've done. 

 

IMO he just had to stick to his own guts like many other authors do, if he really has no talent  then he just needed to stick with his first editor storyline

[soraandven]

 

IMO he just had to stick to his own guts like many other authors do, if he really has no talent  then he just needed to stick with his first editor storyline

the bastard has no talent at all i just hope some people at nycc criticise him i know i would if i was there 

[sushi.]

is this for real

 

Did Kishimoto say that? I cannot read link sry too toxic. And of all ppl.. that guy, is his fave? :V Dude is nuts. Both of them.

[Hanabi]

Wth am i watching??

[starlitestarbrite]

i think its a fanmade thing like the hitler reacts to vids'. fans just play with the subs' and make it say whatever they want.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Actually, it was in the interview. Just not sure it's him but it was definitely there.

[Narufan85]

This is why I admire guys like George R.R. Martin. He refuses to read fan blogs and websites because he doesn't want to get influenced by theories and fan attitudes.

[RedFaction]

This is why I admire guys like George R.R. Martin. He refuses to read fan blogs and websites because he doesn't want to get influenced by theories and fan attitudes.

It's the mark of a good author, and there are many authors who share that quality. We were just unfortunate that Kishimoto was one of the few who didn't have it in him to finish the story how it was suppose to go.

[TouKen4Life3g]

This is why I admire guys like George R.R. Martin. He refuses to read fan blogs and websites because he doesn't want to get influenced by theories and fan attitudes.

Agreed. Funny how he likes Ant-Man.

[Narufan85]

It's the mark of a good author, and there are many authors who share that quality. We were just unfortunate that Kishimoto was one of the few who didn't have it in him to finish the story how it was suppose to go.

 

It's definitely the mark of a good author, and an author who respects their work.

[TouKen4Life3g]

It's the mark of a good author, and there are many authors who share that quality. We were just unfortunate that Kishimoto was one of the few who didn't have it in him to finish the story how it was suppose to go.

I just hate the fact he did create a really potential world to explore yet underutilized it completely.

[RedFaction]

I just hate the fact he did create a really potential world to explore yet underutilized it completely.

Yeah, Naruto had a concept with potential and a good intital start, but when an author starts writing based on what the vocal part of the fandom's wants then it becomes a problem. That can happen to any story and just because Naruto is Naruto doesn't mean it was ever immune from that, even though they say this was all planned from the beginning we know that's a lie.

 

Kishimoto messed up big time and hopefully other future authors can look at his mistakes and avoid them, or more authors fail like he did in the future.

[starlitestarbrite]

waw...it's otaku like those NH/SS fanbrats at studio pierrot, shueishia, and kishimoto that give the anime/manga fanbase a bad name.

[harry4e]

OK I can't say how accurate the video is, but I am pretty sure Kishimoto's English is not that good that he would watch English review YouTube video's so unless they aare being translated or someone is translating for him, it's entiely possible that he was fed inaccurate information.

 

I've found this to be a problem with allot of people, where they consider criticism as a form of hate, you can be critical of a medium but still like it, I have been critical of Narutp's manga for years now, but I always loved the manga, it wasn't until the last chapter, that showed me that my reason to be critical of the manga should have been reason for me to drop the manga as they were signs to show how much of a mess the end would be.

 

Though even now I can't completely let myself beleive that Kishi was fully responsible for the end, because I know that Kishi probably doesn't have the same control over his manga than someone in the west. We don't know how much he was forced into the ending and how much it was his idea. I can't remember where I read it recently, but the creater of Megaman said something along the lines of if he was a game designer in the west he'd have made enough money to retire by now, but it's not the same in Japan and he needs to continue working and creating idea's.

 

That got me thinking how different things are in Japan, and I can't decide if I should be critical of Kishi or Shiesha or even SP for the ending. Because you look at his recent interviews and you can't help but wonder if he's taking his anger out on outside sources that dictated the direction of the manga near the end.

[rocci]

@harry
Sometimes I think, East Asian business system is inhuman. In this case the over competitive showbizz world.

Kishi is the one who responsible with the ending.

[soraandven]

is this for real

 

Did Kishimoto say that? I cannot read link sry too toxic. And of all ppl.. that guy, is his fave? :V Dude is nuts. Both of them.

of course that guy is nuts as well as a few others i know