I'm sorry, I hope this isn't rude, but there are parts of this debate that are pointless.
I'm sorry but none of the ships made sense in the end. This includes NaruSaku.
If NaruSaku had remotely made sense, why is the fandom so split then? Why are are we so widely divided between NaruSaku vs. NaruHina and SasuSaku?
I agree with Analyzer, in a sense.
For me, Kishi's biggest mistake was the love triangle. It was prolonged to the point where every ship had a chance for credible endgame.
At the top of my head, I can recall three points where NaruSaku had the opportunity to be "endgame" without actually being endgame.
Both NaruHina and SasuSaku aren't some loud minority; there is a reason why the NaruHina fandom suddenly grew in size after 436 and 615, and why SasuSaku remained dominate even with Part 2. Kishi gave them ammo just like he gave us ammo with NaruSaku.
I'm sorry but you're wrong.
I don't like defending Kishi at all, but he has absolutely no blame for the love triangle. Why?
Because it does not exist. There is no real love triangle present in the Naruto story.
The love triangle or triangles were created by the fans, not by the writer whether you believe the writer is Kishi or Yahagi.
In order to have a love triangle, you need to show some romantic interest from all the parties. In Naruto we have two love triangles created by fans that are incapable of comprehending what is shown to them, thus making their own head canon and going by it. This is why we have the fandom so split as you called it. Cause we have people who understood what was given to them, while the other group made up their own stuff. Problem is the latter one decided to start spewing their misunderstandings as facts.
So we have the love triangles created by the fans, love triangle number 1 - Hinata><Naruto>Sakura and number 2 Sasuke><Sakura<Naruto
But in reality the so called love triangles never existed in the first place since in both of them one of characters never showed any romantic or any sort of interest in the other character.
So we have Hinata>Naruto><Sakura and Sasuke<Sakura><Naruto, which means instead of a love triangle we just have this Naruto><Sakura.
Kishimoto or Yahagi made it very clear, but he/they can't do anything about people who aren't bright enough to understand left from right and decide that left is right, and right is left.
Kishi's fault is in other places. Like having Kakashi being the worst teacher ever for Naruto and Sakura, only showing favoritism towards Sasuke. Even going so far to teach Sasuke an assassination technique and criticizing Jiraiya for teaching Naruto a move to protect himself.
Edited by Nostradamus, 22 October 2017 - 01:36 AM.