136 replies to this topic

[Namikaze Clan]

Who would you guys say is the worst dad? Naruto or Sasuke?

Edited by Namikaze Clan, 14 September 2015 - 02:21 AM.

[Nostradamus]

Both.

[Namikaze Clan]

I'd say sasuke is slightly worse than Naruto. At least Naruto never tried to kill his children

[Catra]

sasuke without a single shroud of doubt.

 

naruto meanwhile is a close second.

[RedFaction]

Of course Sasuke is a worse father than Naruto, but that's not saying much. I always knew Sasuke would be a terrible father, but we should have expected far more from Naruto. He's a failure in everything a father should be, and it's still surprising how bad he is considering his past and development before the ending.

Edited by RedFaction, 14 September 2015 - 03:49 AM.

[BlackBird19]

A neglectful father is bad, but a completely absent father sucks.

[Tiller]

It's Sasuke. Never was around his kid, tried to kill her, and then left soon again. But hey Salad loves him now because Sasuke is just "that cool" according to the Narutoverse.

[nikki1314]

Its a close race.

 

We all never expected Naruto To be like this tho.

[NaruSaku fan in Kentucky]

I never expected to be this close. If you asked me threel years ago that who would be a worse Father, I would have said Sasuke in a heartbeat. But ever since this ending it's still Sasuke but barely.

[Bryon_Konoha_Ninja]

Sasuke if you ask me. Naruto may be just as terrible, but he's never tried to kill his kids, just neglected them.

[TheFirstEvil100]

Both.

I agree with you as well both are bad fathers.

[Nate River]

Sasuke and I don't think it's close.

Naruto works too much and is neglectful, but at least he saw his kids before they turned 12. Sarada didn't meet hers until SHE sought him out.

[Narufan85]

Sasuke and I don't think it's close.

Naruto works too much and is neglectful, but at least he saw his kids before they turned 12. Sarada didn't meet hers until SHE sought him out.

 

Pretty much this.

[harry4e]

Sasuke is the worse of the two, Not even seeing his daughter once in 12 years is unfogivable, (Though I lost respect for SS fans even more when one panel of showing he cares, had some declaring he was the best father ever.) This is dispite him knowing what it is like growing up wondering if his own father even cared for him.

 

Naruto is a lousy father, who dispite knowing the pains his son is going through does nothing to help his son, instead tells him to deal with it. Though atleast he spends some time with him,.

 

Now who is the worst mother? Hinata who seems to ignore his sons trouble, or Sakura who is teaching her daughter it's fine to have a neglecting partner, for kittens sake they've never even kissed.

[Nar123]

I think it's a close call but Sasuke takes this one

[Bryon_Konoha_Ninja]

Sasuke is the worse of the two, Not even seeing his daughter once in 12 years is unfogivable, (Though I lost respect for SS fans even more when one panel of showing he cares, had some declaring he was the best father ever.) This is dispite him knowing what it is like growing up wondering if his own father even cared for him.

 

Naruto is a lousy father, who dispite knowing the pains his son is going through does nothing to help his son, instead tells him to deal with it. Though atleast he spends some time with him,.

 

Now who is the worst mother? Hinata who seems to ignore his sons trouble, or Sakura who is teaching her daughter it's fine to have a neglecting partner, for kittens sake they've never even kissed.

 

 

I'd say Hinata, Harry, since she doesn't seem to care about anything but Naruto. Sakura at least has helped take care of Sarada, whether she's the biological mom or not (I still say it's Karin, even if Gaiden says otherwise, mostly due to her keeping Sarada's umbilical cord instead of Sakura, who should if she's the real mom of Sarada).

Edited by Bryon_Konoha_Ninja, 14 September 2015 - 09:57 PM.

[Fyuria'sLeo]

The Sauce is terrible.

 

For females, probably Hinata.

[Namikaze Clan]

In regards to mothers, I don't honestly think that Sakura and Hinata are bad moms. Aside from the part were Sakura destroyed her house over nothing, they haven't really done anything to warrant being called bad parents

[Nate River]

I'd say Hinata, Harry, since she doesn't seem to care about anything but Naruto. Sakura at least has helped take care of Sarada, whether she's the biological mom or not (I still say it's Karin, even if Gaiden says otherwise, mostly due to her keeping Sarada's umbilical cord instead of Sakura, who should if she's the real mom of Sarada).

I don't think we have enough information to. We know Sasuke was absent and Naruto works too much because the manga tells us. The manga tells us next to nothing about Hinata and Sakura as mothers. All we know is (1) what we saw in Gaiden and (2) that the kids seems to like and get alone with their mothers. Of course, I am not sure how much to run with number (2) in a series that ret-cons a bunch while also being plagued with internal consistency issues. So, it's never impossible for Kishimoto to suddent create new material that dumps all over that assumption.

As to (1) Gaiden makes Sakura look terrible; not that anyone in the series cares. Much of Sarada's existenial crisis is created because Sakura tells her nothing and then when she finds out cannot be straight with her for reasons that are a total mystery. She destroyed their house over it. At the same time, Sarada loves and respects her, except this one issue.

What do we know about Hinata the mom? Virtually nothing.

So, I couldn't tell you who is worse or even if they are bad overall.

[Namikaze Clan]

What did Sakura keep from her? She already told Sarada about Sasuke's mission when she was younger