Apologies of the double post, I'm not supposed to do that.
I keep hearing there was a lot of stuff Ken Penders did that hurt the Archie Comics canon big time, as well as some ideas he had in mind but never got off the ground that just didnt sit well. Is it as bad as Ive heard?
Oh boy, there are tons. Recommend to head over ThanksKenPenders on tumblr for more detailed information. I'm going to bring the skimmed version:
1) All of this started when Archie hired a new editor. Around the time, the stories were getting ten-times worse (such as "Evil Sonic" had sex with Bunnie)
2) Because of Mobius: 25 Years Later was his pet project and wasn't going anywhere story-wise, the new editor suggested to bring Shadow into the storyline...
... that did not work for Penders and he legit quit.
3) Which brought Ian Flynn, who was a Sonic fan in the hay day, and started working and fixing the series to make it more enjoyable for Sonic fans.
4) Then came the Sonic and Knuckles Archives... well, Penders wasn't making anymore money, not getting any new gigs (he should had done that) so he started his legal journey to get royalties, fine and dandy...
5) but then, here comes Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood, for the Nintendo DS in 2008, developed by BioWare. So apparently, his fans thought the game outright "copyright infringed" his works, believing that Shade and the Nocturnus clan directly = Julie-Su and the Dark Legion (the best answer is that they're actually expies), they told him and he began to sue Sega, and BioWare (which now owned by EA, so we have to include the infamous gaming company) in 2010.
6) Then it got crazy in the courts because when the lawyers for Archie tried to do their defense, there were loopholes as Penders did not signed a contract and there were copies and the originals were destroyed in a fire years back in the late 90s. So, eventually, it was settled but with the cost:
7) Penders started to do The Lara-Su Chronicles in 2012... but wanted to demand Archie to create mandates for his characters he created (he made over 100 of these Archie Sonic exclusive cast), primarily for Julie-Su, Lara-Su and Locke (who sacrificed himself in Knuckles Enerjak arc, and that pissed off Penders because he did a personal story for Locke in M25YL).
8) So that made SEGA and Archie to deleted or get rid not only characters from Penders but also characters from other previous writers, such as Karl Bollers (he created Mina and Dr. Finitevus).
9) That screwed up Flynn's plans and also the storylines such as Endangered Species, which was ready to be printed at the time.
10) With Capcom's Megaman series making money, the crossover Worlds Collide had to come with another Genesis Wave, which after the crossover event, Nu252 reboot happened.
... that's the nutshell.