The thing that annoys me most about the Sakura hitting Naruto argument is that other Tsundere type characters are not held to that same standard. Kayko hitting Yusuke? Forgot about that. Kagome's sits? It's funny. Kaoru beating Kenshin with a boken? Luv. Some at least will attack other tusnderes, but for some reason Sakura is put up as the poster child of abusive tsunderes when there have been far worse.
Another argument that does them no favors is that if Hinata didn't get with Naruto, she would be lonely and might even kill herself.
Uh, that's not the trait of an endearing character. That is someone in need of serious psychotherapy.
Another: "Hinata loved him first, so Naruto HAS to return his feelings!"
So, wouldn't that mean Sakura had to return Naruto's feelings because he loved her first
Granted, they'd probably refer to that scene in the Last, but still it's a stupid reason.
Another one: Hinata is super strong! Imagine how powerful their children could become!
Yes, I remember as clear as day when Hinata whooped Neji's a-oh, wait a minute! Neji trounced her!
But still, Hiashi recognized her as a prodi-No, she wasn't! Hiashi was VERY disappointed with her!
Still, it was incredible when she held her own against Sasori...No wait, that was Sakura, never mind!
But how about the time she destroyed the training field...oh wait. Sakura again.
But she showed incredible strenght against Pain...No she didn't, She was one-hit KO'd.
But in the anime, she kept taking hits...Taking hits doesn't mean jack if you don't land a deciding blow.
Oh, but how about the time she figured out the abilities of the White Zet-Sakura again, keep trying.
But Boruto and Naruto how scary she gets when she's angry!...Okay...then why not get with Sakura?
Really, these "fans" treat these two like their cattle they need to breed. They wanted OP children, they got them, with asinine writing to boot. And how come Hinata is given credit for all these feats when canon did nothing to support them? Why are all these great achievements off-screen? It reminds me when Nostalgia Critic did that Lex Luthor scene from BvS:
(Lex Luthor describes all he did in the movie) And the best part of it all, is that I did it ALL OFF-SCREEN, SO NOT EVEN I KNOW HOW I DID ALL THIS IMPOSSIBLE kitten!
Edit: To add even more fuel to the fire...if Sakura always thinks Naruto is a loser in their eyes and pushed Hinata to be with Naruto...then does that mean she thought Hinata was a loser too?
"Losers should only marry losers."
-Proending fandom
Put it to print because proenders think Hinata and Naruto are losers and are pathetic.
I recall when all those other mangaka made their own illustrations to "celebrate" the end of Naruto, one had a picture of the Konoha Eleven running up triumphantly...while Naruto and Hinata tripped and fell over into the dirt.
Not only does this support your theory, but it's a perfect metaphor for how Naruto was NEVER the star of his own manga. He got left in the dust by everyone else (though I wouldn't say any of them came out good), and settled for someone at his level rather than getting back up.