3357 replies to this topic

[TouKen4Life3g]

 
 
Hmm Well as long as it's not the editor calling the shots for this series thus far it should be fine.

Editor: Have Soma yelled at Azami and others at Erina's forced wedding with Eizan that they're friends and make sure it is easily noted that Megumi is the winner.
Mangaka: That sounds like a cliche bland writing and something that people will ultimately hate me and Soma...
Editor: DO IT NOW!

Edited by TouKen4Life3g, 19 October 2015 - 06:06 PM.

[harry4e]

Ao I wonder if these rapid cliffhangers were because the editor suggested them, or the mangaka was worried the editor would tr to change the manga direction and the mangaka rushed the story ahead so the editor could not force the direction of the manga?

[Gaara's hair]

Editors don't have much power anyway. The author can take his his advice or not. Only morons do everything the editor says.

[Gaara's hair]

Yes !!! You were hired to be Kishimoto's editor for his new manga and you'll also have the privilege to take care of Garra's Hair . 

New characters, new story, but still Gaara's Hair is there. Watch Gaara's Hair grow to become beautiful long flowing hair!!!

[harry4e]

Editors don't have much power anyway. The author can take his his advice or not. Only morons do everything the editor says.

 

Not sure about that, Editors can pretty much reject scripts if they don't feel like the manga is going in the right direction, specially for the newer mangaka, it's why we see so many similar plots and tropes getting used by manga published by the same magazine.

 

I think Bakuman gave some insight in how editors can push mangaka in the wrong direction if they have certain preferences.

 

It's a two way street, if the mangaka doesn't listen to their editor and the editor has genuine concerns about the direction, the manga could be pulled from the magazine, editors are basically the mouthpiece for the magazine and what it represents, if the editor says no to any of the content, it's basically the magazine saying no. So it really depends on how well the two can work together.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Well once I see they dropped the obvious path by Joichiro chapter 1 and Soma determined to change her mind, I'll start thinking that.

[FireFox]

New characters, new story, but still Gaara's Hair is there. Watch Gaara's Hair grow to become beautiful long flowing hair!!!

His Hitler stylish hair will be gone for good then   .

 

 

I think I just found him though   .

Edited by NarutoFireFoxUzumaki, 19 October 2015 - 09:40 PM.

[Phantom_999]

Editor: Have Soma yelled at Azami and others at Erina's forced wedding with Eizan that they're friends and make sure it is easily noted that Megumi is the winner.
Mangaka: That sounds like a cliche bland writing and something that people will ultimately hate me and Soma...
Editor: DO IT NOW!

 

Exactly something like that. Well in this case The Megumi thing is actually good since they have development. but yeah calling crap like that that the mangaka is actually undignified enough to actually do that is what pisses me off. Now I' am never saying don't listen to your editors advice cause it is important nor am I saying don't listen to your fans but you are the author, the creator of your world and while you should listen to advice you should never compromise what you have set up no  matter the reason unless you have genuine reason to believe it will make your story better not sell out to a vocal fan faction. this is what truly makes or breaks a great writer.

[Gaara's hair]

 

 
Not sure about that, Editors can pretty much reject scripts if they don't feel like the manga is going in the right direction, specially for the newer mangaka, it's why we see so many similar plots and tropes getting used by manga published by the same magazine.
 
I think Bakuman gave some insight in how editors can push mangaka in the wrong direction if they have certain preferences.
 
It's a two way street, if the mangaka doesn't listen to their editor and the editor has genuine concerns about the direction, the manga could be pulled from the magazine, editors are basically the mouthpiece for the magazine and what it represents, if the editor says no to any of the content, it's basically the magazine saying no. So it really depends on how well the two can work together.

But I always see authors drop editors. Some go through multiple editors. And I think mangas have the same plot and stuff, because they were inspired by others. Also the fact that everything's already been done before and it's just how you write or draw it.

[Phantom_999]

True but who's to say it wasn't because their editor was moving or was promoted?

[RyohkiFan]

GH is an editor, you question his hair?

Edited by RyohkiFan, 19 October 2015 - 10:36 PM.

[Phantom_999]

No I'm not questioning him. It's just that the reasons for plowing through editors man not be be just cause the author doesn't want to work with them.

 

why are you grouchy?  Hungry?

 

[RyohkiFan]

No I'm not questioning him. It's just that the reasons for plowing through editors man not be be just cause the author doesn't want to work with them.
 
why are you grouchy?  Hungry?
 

I was kidding though...

[Phantom_999]

Ah sorry the emoticon confused me. Take the fettuccine anyway.

Edited by Phantom_999, 21 October 2015 - 11:35 AM.

[RyohkiFan]

Ah sorry the emoticon confused me. Tale the fettuccine anyway.

I thought when I said GH and hair gave away the joke...

[Phantom_999]

I didn't get it, sorry.

 

side note* I could say i'm pumped but kinda at the same time am a little indifferent to how this development turns out cause it feels............ a little predictable but I DO want to see some character development.   

Edited by Phantom_999, 21 October 2015 - 11:37 AM.

[Mixer]

Need to catch up  Don't think I read the last 3 chapters T-T

Bc its funny   . How could you not know what PSD is !?  . You're no fan  .

 

.

 

You did not just say that !!?   . I dare you !!!  Throw food  at me and see who's really scared !?   .

 

No food for you , go away !!!   .

 

P.S Steals Ryo's Hamburger     .

Don't laugh, Granny . I'm no fan? Comes from the Baka that said he wasn't gonna watch this series

 

FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD   

 

  *Takes all the food here*

 

Share  

[FireFox]

Need to catch up  Don't think I read the last 3 chapters T-T

Don't laugh, Granny . I'm no fan? Comes from the Baka that said he wasn't gonna watch this series

 

FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD   

 

  *Takes all the food here*

 

Share   

 Read it now !!!  . That school is really destroying you    .

 

    . No I said I'll think about it    .

 

Yes Fooooooood !!! Give me !!!     .

 

I'll share some if you share some too !?  .

[harry4e]

Aizen appears to be following in the footsteps of another more famous Aizen from the spoilers and sounds like there is going to be a battle royale coming up. Which I find really surprising if true, The manga is really moving at a worringly rapid pace. Is the Mangaka aiming to have the manga end by the end of the year, is he planning a time skip? it just feels strange to see a manga move at such a rapid pace, from one cliffhanger to the next.

[Mixer]

 Read it now !!!  . That school is really destroying you    .

 

    . No I said I'll think about it    .

 

Yes Fooooooood !!! Give me !!!     .

 

I'll share some if you share some too !?  .

I'll read it when next chapter comes out.  That's why I told you to take my place in school

 

. Liar

 

Noo It's my food

 

You must give me first >.<