9679 replies to this topic

[Miss Soupy]

I am a member there too. Her name doesn't appear to be on the SS fanclub member list either. I haven't seen anything about her not being a trustworthy translator, but you could always provide evidence of it. What is with all of this mistrust anyways?

[jason voorhees]

I am a member there too. Her name doesn't appear to be on the SS fanclub member list either. I haven't seen anything about her not being a trustworthy translator, but you could always provide evidence of it. What is with all of this mistrust anyways?

because i dont take anything at face value anymore

give me alittle i know its there ive ben a member for 3 years an its ben a year since i loged on. an mabe i herd,read wrong let me look k.

part one of my serch i saw some images that made my eyes bleed (not anything pairing related)

part two got thretend

SILENCE!!! I KILL YOU jk

Yeah Im not sure either. Inneras good people and a solid NaruSaku supporter.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

than theres a good chance i was mistaken my bad. i here to many things

dont know if ill find it ill look more tomarrow(tired now)

Edited by hypno toad, 02 October 2010 - 02:14 AM.

[catsi563]

Yeah Im not sure either. Inneras good people and a solid NaruSaku supporter.

[ShippudenGirl]

I was sure shes a legit NS fan- I love Innera! aisuru yooki wo tsunyosani kaero!

[Cloud]

than theres a good chance i was mistaken my bad. i here to many things

You "hear" too many things. Are you sure it was pictures making you bleed? I see other things that make me bleed.

A lot of spoilers we see are from Innera, with no bias. If she really was an SS supporter, translations might've been off.

[ShippudenGirl]

Maybe we should calm down a little. It was all just a mistake, yes?

[Toasty Warrior]

I agree Shippuden-chan, we just need to cool it, it was all a misunderstanding, let's not fight among ourselves guys.

[Cloud]

Maybe we should calm down a little. It was all just a mistake, yes?

Accusing Innera of being an unreliable translator, when she clearly gives Japanese lessons over at NF.

Yep. Simple mistake. While I'm at it. I'll just accuse Kishi of trolling.

Oh wait...

[Derock]

Ok, people.

Let's not make this into another topic. This is about NaruSaku debating. Other talks are reserved outside in another thread or PMs. Also ease the tension down before I get into serious mode.

[ciardha]

A lot of spoilers we see are from Innera, with no bias. If she really was an SS supporter, translations might've been off.

Huh? The spoilers we get come from Ohana not Innera.

Ohana is a Sasuke fan, and doesn't care for Sakura or Naruto much.

I know Innera likes Naruto a lot, used to like Sasuke, but stopped feeling that way last year, and has expressed strong dislike for Sakura at times. She does some nice narusaku fanart though.

But I agree with Derock, lets get back to narusaku. I'll throw out a much less explosive topic-

Not exactly a debate topic to start with, but what narusaku scene in the manga do you think the animators actually improved on, if any? It could be a debate topic if someone disagrees that the anime improved on it and undermined it instead. If you think the anime undermined it point out how.

Edited by ciardha, 02 October 2010 - 04:12 AM.

[X105]

Gotta say after listening to the crazy debate about the confession erupt again I decided to make some comments. First about the "a confession can't be a lie by definition". Sorry, that is a idealistic view of a confession. If you think people have not lied in confessions before ask a judge or catholic priest if it is possible to lie in a confession. It definately is. Second the confession in general does not seem to have any importance to the plot anyway. Naruto and Sakura appear to have moved on and don't dwell on it. Sounds like another confession in the manga too. Hmm. Third, I really agree that the interview should never be used to validate any paring. And rant is over.

[Cloud]

Hm.

But perjury is a crime. Therefore you can't lie in front of a judge during a court session. But priests? I'm pretty sure they get false confessions here or there, so yeah. I get what you're saying.

You can confess to something, but you can be lying about it. I mean look at the celebrities. They confess about not doing something, but when evidence comes out and smacks them in the face. Oh look. Confession changed.

[X105]

Yeah exactly. Great example cloud. That's also why perjury exists as a felony to help prevent avoid false information to a grand jury.

[Nate River]

Yeah exactly. Great example cloud. That's also why perjury exists as a felony to help prevent avoid false information to a grand jury.

Perjury isn't limited to Grand Juries and isn't always a felony. Perjury is meant tp punish lying under oath in general.


That said...

We've gotten several complaints about this thread, espeically over the last couple of pages. As Derock has already mentioned everyone needs to calm down and move on. I don't want to warn anyone or close the thread, but I'll do both if people don't calm down and move on.

[catsi563]

right now the hugs the best animated scene at this point. simple concise and sweet, no fuss no filler save a little background to emphasize it.

[maliousdei]

hey guys, you know what i hate? the whole 'sakura doesn't deserve naruto' argument NH and SS fans love to use. can someone please help me with an argument that can prove she does?

[ShippudenGirl]

Yeah, I never understood why they say Sakura doesn't deserve Naruto - I mean shes saved his life before, healed him and is a good friend. All Hinata ever did was jump in front of him and get beat-up. And as for Sasuke... PFFF- lets recap all the chapters he almost accidently/purposely killed her. :P

@Catsi

Oh yes, that scene was so sweet! I absolutely loved it!

edit: Spelling.

Edited by ShippudenGirl, 02 October 2010 - 09:00 PM.

[catsi563]

you dont bother with the ""character a deserves character b" argument. Its baseless and pointless.

Its an Argument based on personal opinion and worse its circular.

Sakura deserves Naruto because shes changes do much, she deserves Sasuke because shes stayed so loyal, Sasuke deserves Karin because she loves him, Sasuke deserves Sakura ebcause shes loyal, Naruto deserves Sakura becaue hes loved her always, Naruto deserves Hinata because she confessed, and so on and so forth I can find a deserves justification for any and every character in the series.

the say Sakura deosnt deserve Naruto but that Hinata does. but by that logic doesnt Naruto deserve Sakura since hes remained loyal to her?

its an argument with no end and nothing more then opinion to back it up. Sakura has done just as much for Naruto if not more then Hinata has done. And in point of fact even her actions during the confession can be viewed as questionable as they did not really make him safer in point of fact they endangered his life because as we learned the Kyubis cloak damages him and shortens his life.

So in conclusion she was actually worse for him then Sakuras ever been.

[Gravenimage]

you dont bother with the ""character a deserves character b" argument. Its baseless and pointless.

Its an Argument based on personal opinion and worse its circular.

Sakura deserves Naruto because shes changes do much, she deserves Sasuke because shes stayed so loyal, Sasuke deserves Karin because she loves him, Sasuke deserves Sakura ebcause shes loyal, Naruto deserves Sakura becaue hes loved her always, Naruto deserves Hinata because she confessed, and so on and so forth I can find a deserves justification for any and every character in the series.

the say Sakura deosnt deserve Naruto but that Hinata does. but by that logic doesnt Naruto deserve Sakura since hes remained loyal to her?

its an argument with no end and nothing more then opinion to back it up. Sakura has done just as much for Naruto if not more then Hinata has done. And in point of fact even her actions during the confession can be viewed as questionable as they did not really make him safer in point of fact they endangered his life because as we learned the Kyubis cloak damages him and shortens his life.

So in conclusion she was actually worse for him then Sakuras ever been.

We know that already catsi we know.

But try telling that to her obsesses crazed fandom.

[Toasty Warrior]

From what I've seen on other sites, Hinata's fans are pretty damn rabid especially on the Naruto Viz forums...