277 replies to this topic

[Phantom_999]

you really think Sasuke's gonna live? He SHOULD die! He's a traitor to his village!

I'm just saying YOU'E the one saying that NS may not happen because We can't count on the manga to foreshadow definite future events so DON'T go doing a switcheroo and Say Sasuke should die because He been a cold blooded M*****F***ING B****** in the manga YOU EITHER STICK TO WHAT YOUR'E SAYING OR ADMIT to being a hypocrite on previous things Sorry to sound harsh but it is what it is

Firstly, wrong thread... direct that kind of thought process to the other thread...

Secondly, what I'm doing now is predicting, hence the reason why I said the word SHOULD and not WILL...

And I'm using the manga to give my opinion on why it SHOULD happen and not why it WILL happen, because I cannot predict the future...

I think you get it, but just to make sure... "SHOULD"... not "WILL", yo ne?

response: Then That's the same reason why NS SHOULD HAPPEN THEN. If you're sticking to predicting about how things SHOULD be happening then don't use that statement: Kishi MAKES EVERYTHING HOW HE WANTS AND SO EVERYTHING WE PREDICT IS WORTH NOTHING AND SHOULD NOT ASSUME ANYTHING AT ALL. because then you are contradicting yourself. STICK with Your words is what I'm trying to say

You got the quote and you still protest that I'm being hypocritical? Um... wow...

Anywho I might as well defend my actions again, I seem to have so much repercussions for defending the other side though... It's like I'm on my own...

>.>

<.<

Oh wait... But I digress, in the thread I stated that "You cannot use the manga as evidence to suggest what will happen, because the story could change direction at any given time..." or something along those lines...

What I'm doing, is I'm giving my opinion (using scenes from the manga) as to why an event SHOULD take place... Not claiming that it will definitely happen

Still think I'm acting like a hypocrite? Good fight

When it hasn't happened yet, SHOULD is the same as WILL because they both mean I WISH. OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!

Edited by Phantom_999, 22 October 2011 - 10:48 PM.

[LegendaryArcanine42]

I'm just saying YOU'E the one saying that NS may not happen because We can't count on the manga to foreshadow definite future events so DON'T go doing a switcheroo and Say Sasuke should die because He been a cold blooded M*****F***ING B****** in the manga YOU EITHER STICK TO WHAT YOUR'E SAYING OR ADMIT to being a hypocrite on previous things Sorry to sound harsh but it is what it is

Firstly, wrong thread... direct that kind of thought process to the other thread...

Secondly, what I'm doing now is predicting, hence the reason why I said the word SHOULD and not WILL...

And I'm using the manga to give my opinion on why it SHOULD happen and not why it WILL happen, because I cannot predict the future...

I think you get it, but just to make sure... "SHOULD"... not "WILL", yo ne?

[FoolishYoungling]

Firstly, wrong thread... direct that kind of thought process to the other thread...
Secondly, what I'm doing now is predicting, hence the reason why I said the word SHOULD and not WILL...

And I'm using the manga to give my opinion on why it SHOULD happen and not why it WILL happen, because I cannot predict the future...

I think you get it, but just to make sure... "SHOULD"... not "WILL", yo ne?

Doesn't matter what thread you post something in, your still switching what you think, and your reasons are still too easy to counter...

[LegendaryArcanine42]

Doesn't matter what thread you post something in, your still switching what you think, and your reasons are still too easy to counter...

You got the quote and you still protest that I'm being hypocritical? Um... wow...

Anywho I might as well defend my actions again, I seem to have so much repercussions for defending the other side though... It's like I'm on my own...

>.>

<.<

Oh wait... But I digress, in the thread I stated that "You cannot use the manga as evidence to suggest what will happen, because the story could change direction at any given time..." or something along those lines...

What I'm doing, is I'm giving my opinion (using scenes from the manga) as to why an event SHOULD take place... Not claiming that it will definitely happen

Still think I'm acting like a hypocrite? Good fight

[FoolishYoungling]

You got the quote and you still protest that I'm being hypocritical? Um... wow...

Anywho I might as well defend my actions again, I seem to have so much repercussions for defending the other side though... It's like I'm on my own...

>.>

<.<

Oh wait... But I digress, in the thread I stated that "You cannot use the manga as evidence to suggest what will happen, because the story could change direction at any given time..." or something along those lines...

What I'm doing, is I'm giving my opinion (using scenes from the manga) as to why an event SHOULD take place... Not claiming that it will definitely happen

Still think I'm acting like a hypocrite? Good fight

It just sounds like your here to troll, and anyway, you saying something can change is like saying Naruto is trying to make itself make no sense...

[LegendaryArcanine42]

@NaruSaku1 Seriously, it actually hurts my feelings when you guys keep calling me a troll, it ain't very nice y'know... ¬_¬

And have you ever watched a GAINAX anime? Yeah... it's possible for Naruto to want to make itself, make no sense...

@Phantom_999 I wish... That can be related to as, "giving my opinion", right?

And yeah, what we predict IS worth nothing, but it makes one heck of a pastime, which is why do it... And my prediction is that Sasuke will die... because of the deeds he's done... You haven't really given me a couner-argument here to suggest why you think he should live, so until you do I'm just gonna keep telling you that I'm giving my opinion and not stating it as fact, until you get it...

Now then... If anyone wishes to debate with me about Sasuke's chances of living, as opposed to my views on why predictions =/= canon, then please reply... otherwise just step aside, got it?

[Phantom_999]

@Phantom_999 I wish... That can be related to as, "giving my opinion", right?

And yeah, what we predict IS worth nothing, but it makes one heck of a pastime, which is why do it... And my prediction is that Sasuke will die... because of the deeds he's done... You haven't really given me a couner-argument here to suggest why you think he should live, so until you do I'm just gonna keep telling you that I'm giving my opinion and not stating it as fact, until you get it...

Now then... If anyone wishes to debate with me about Sasuke's chances of living, as opposed to my views on why predictions =/= canon, then please reply... otherwise just step aside, got it?

Fine. Well I don't have evidence to argue that Sasuke will live BUT I WILL NOT resort to using Kishi's creative freedom as an excuse for It I just Have a feeling Sasuke might live and if he doesn't then whatever it was not my call and I wouldn't be surprised either

[merryGOflava]

evidence ???

how bout the evidence sasuke hasnt killed anyone innocent!!!!?

hes either a LAME villain!!!! or an okay anti-hero!!

[FoolishYoungling]

evidence ???

how bout the evidence sasuke hasnt killed anyone innocent!!!!?

hes either a LAME villain!!!! or an okay anti-hero!!

Me: killing/trying either way its enough to kill the guy with force of the law...
Killer Bee: ye-ye-ye doggg!

[merryGOflava]

Me: killing/trying either way its enough to kill the guy with force of the law...
Killer Bee: ye-ye-ye doggg!

oh COMEON then gaara would be in...what? ninja jail

this is a manga, the logic of "threatening" isnt enough.

[Nee-sama]

Sasuke will live cuz Kishi can't kill off a main character. Discuss!

[merryGOflava]

Sasuke will live cuz Kishi can't kill off a main character. Discuss!

i wish i could use that argument.

[Fenris]

i wish i could use that argument.

He killed off Jiriya (sp?) no problem, and Orochimaru and Itachi no problem. And even Asuma no problem. Why not Sasuke?

[Madz]

I dislike it when people said "If Kishi does not do yada yada yada, then he is bad story teller."
I find this statement to be completely ... err...lame (I can't find the proper word right now.)
NH fans use this statement.
Anti-Sasuke people use this statement.

What the heck? If I say that Kishi would be a bad storyteller by going against what he himself had lead to if he kills off Sasuke, where does this advance us?

We all have our opinions, different and opposing, very often, but why accusing the man to be a bad story writer when there are as many, if not MORE people who thinks different than you? (not pinpointing anyone, but those who like to use the statement in general.)

Edited by Madz, 23 October 2011 - 11:32 AM.

[Fyuria'sLeo]

I dislike it when people said "If Kishi does not do yada yada yada, then he is bad story teller."
I find this statement to be completely ... err...lame (I can't find the proper word right now.)
NH fans use this statement.
Anti-Sasuke people use this statement.

What the heck? If I say that Kishi would be a bad storyteller by going against what he himself had lead to if he kills off Sasuke, where does this advance us?

We all have our opinions, different and opposing, very often, but why accusing the man to be a bad story writer when there are as many, if not MORE people who thinks different than you? (not pinpointing anyone, but those who like to use the statement in general.)

Ummm im anti-Sasuke and ive never used that statement......(wtf I promised myself Id never come back to this thread and look at the one thing that brought me back)

[LegendaryArcanine42]

oh COMEON then gaara would be in...what? ninja jail

this is a manga, the logic of "threatening" isnt enough.

Sasuke's killed plenty of town people and samurai, defected from his village and is a missing-nin...

Missing-nin are either killed on sight or brought back and then killed, depending on who is capturing them or who IS the Missing-nin...

Good Game ¬_¬

[Madz]

Ummm im anti-Sasuke and ive never used that statement......(wtf I promised myself Id never come back to this thread and look at the one thing that brought me back)

I'm sorry, I should have said MANY NH or anti-sasuke
Ad I said, I was NOT pinpointing to any one in particular, just generally when people use this statement.

The poor man (Kishi) must have so many negative vibes going his way!

[LegendaryArcanine42]

Everyone! Let's calm down and have some cookies *hands out cookies*. No need to fight!
Anywho, I was never "Anti-sasuke" actually he's my third favourite character. I don't want him dead, but death is the only choice. It's not like the Kishimoto we all know and love is a 10 year old girl who is scared of the dark. I think he is capable of killing off Sasuke. Someone here (can't remeber who) said "Sasuke is kishi's favourite character" So your saying Kishi will not kill off Sasuke because it's his favourite character? Favourtism? I don't think so! For some reason, I can't shake off this feeling that Sasuke will come back. I had this daydream where Naruto brought Sasule back and Sakura ran into Narutos arms completely ignoring Sasuke! XD The best argument for Sasuke living is probably the whole "Team 7" thing. Hope I'm making sense D:

Can I have some muffins instead? I'm allergic to cookies

[LegendaryArcanine42]

Sure, why not! *Hands over muffins* Isnt there already a thread like this? Well, what's been brought up has already been discussed over and over again. So, I think it's safe to say that this thread needs to be closed down.

Well just in case there isn't one, I think it should be left as is

Oh, and thanks for the muffins! OM NOM NOM NOM NOM!!!

Edited by Densetsu-Kun, 23 October 2011 - 05:08 PM.

[Phantom_999]

evidence ???

how bout the evidence sasuke hasnt killed anyone innocent!!!!?

hes either a LAME villain!!!! or an okay anti-hero!!

UHHHH? didn't he kill some INNOCENT samurai? not that I'm going against you just remembering a fact

Sasuke will live cuz Kishi can't kill off a main character. Discuss!

Main characters HAVE died before just pointing that I DO want Sasuke to live don't get me wrong

Oh, and thanks for the muffins! OM NOM NOM NOM NOM!!!

I'll be taking one, THANK YOU!!

Edited by Phantom_999, 23 October 2011 - 05:13 PM.