19964 replies to this topic

[PhenixElite]

So what exactly has a VA to do with the manga? Why should she know such an information? Anime chapters are released much later then the manga so i cant see how such an info would be relevant for her. The anine team works after what wa released in the mana, they dont seem to get the inoformation ehats going to happen.

Besides: You dont just kill a main character in the middle of a manga. Thats bullsh**.

Edited by PhenixElite, 11 February 2013 - 11:28 PM.

[六道仙人]

If that's true it would explain the infamous "Sakura?Well, she slipped through my mind..." in the Jump Festa of 2 years ago...

But I don't believe that it was a true statement. This guy who talked with Nakamura could be reliable, but I doubt strongly that Chie Nakamura is familiar with the author.. As someone already told before, VA's don't meet authors so much and I know that Kishimoto don't have a much time for studdio pierrot (i remember a scan where there was an interview with an insider of Studio Pierrot about Naruto's fillers and episodes making. He told that Kishimoto doesn't have much time for them).

Maybe Chie Nakamura just expresses her thought to this guy...

[Arachnia]

I hope you haven't gotten the impression that I am blaming you for something, I know that you just brought the information you got to be discussed here.

... It's just .. hard to believe that Kishi would consider kill her off .. or more like painful to believe.

doubt she will die i mean thats just Rin all over again and i say it in advance i dont want too see hinata die eighter she is pretty cool but not for Naruhina.

[narusaku4ver]

Guys, this would have been an option he was considering before her confession arc. As in, over three years ago. Maybe he had something completely different planned out then, but has changed his mind about it. This has nothing to do with Road to Ninja, which was started only a year ago. It has nothing to do with what's going on in the series now. It's something that he may have been considering a few years ago, but changed his mind.

Maybe he was going to have all of Team Seven die so that they could be happy together in the next life, like Naruto says during his confrontation with Sasuke? Who knows. Fact is, he didn't choose to take that route, so stop fretting. I just mentioned it to spark some conversation about the confession. I didn't mean to cause a sh*tstorm and get attacked for leaving the comment. *cough*narusaku4ever*cough*

Atheck, that's a great idea. I've asked for a screenshot.

You take it as an attack?
You say something with no proof "because a friend told me".

[TouKen4Life3g]

Good point.
The only reason why I brought it up in the first place was to spark some discussion about Kishimoto's intention regard her confession. I wasn't trying to get everyone all riled up about his plans for the manga.

It's ok. I admit, I got a little heat up but not because of you but I want to hear it from the horse's mouth (yeah I said it). Look at this way, you brought up topic more alive.

OMG death note pure awsomeness but i hated the near guy and evangelion lets just say i am happy it gets a remake in movies the wtf factor of the series was too much

Lol well nobody can win. I still love it. I even reviewed it. I love it that much. Evangelion, yeah, talk about acid trip. My mind wasn't the same after that. Oh well, at least they're remaking it, though I didn't see it yet.

[sushi.]

You take it as an attack?
You say something with no proof "because a friend told me".

You shouldn't say what people say so literally. Of course it's not an attack. XD

She didn't even say this was a fact, just something interesting she wanted to share with us. Therefore she doesn't need a reliable source to make you satisfied.

Don't attack me..

Oh, Death Note. Loved it. It was sad when you know what happened in the middle. D:
The ending basically left me thinking "Who is the good person?", "Who did the right thing?"

Edited by sushi., 11 February 2013 - 11:33 PM.

[六道仙人]

anyone can link me chie nakamura's facebook profile?

[Slextrem]

I don't know, I'm under the impression that the VA's only know what's going on with the anime. After all, the anime is handled by a separate entity, they base their content on Kishi's work that is released. Why would he reveal that information to a VA? I don't know, if she's willing to spill something like that, she seems too loose lipped.

If this were the truth, then it's not too bad I guess. Kishi said he knows how the manga will end pretty much, but not how he'll get there. He has a skeleton I assume, but doesn't have the juciy bits in-between. I assume NS was actually not set in stone until part 2 (or a little before) began. Sadly, this indicates that he hasn't been planning for Sakura very well at all if he intended her to die in some of his juicy bits (not the skeleton), but changed his mind later.

With that, I think I'm going to give up any special hopes that he'll do right with her in terms of her abilities.

But anyway, any pairings/romance was no doubt originally part of the juicy bits, but now he's been working the romance more and more into the skeleton. I think NS is pretty skeleton now a days, but a few years back, it was definitely juicy bits.

Bolded: That's my conflict with it. Although the possibility of her being told about it is believable as it pertains to her career. I need to infiltrate Studio Pierrot and investigate how the relationship between the anime and the manga work. I haven't seen the conversation yet, but the impression that my friend gave me was that Chie was told this information later on. Not while Kishimoto was contemplating it.

I agree with you about NaruSaku being a part of the skeleton of the series. I have no doubt about it being the canon couple. It's all a matter of how Kishimoto gets there.

[TouKen4Life3g]

You shouldn't say what people say so literally. Of course it's not an attack. XD

She didn't even say this was a fact, just something interesting she wanted to share with us. Therefore she doesn't need a reliable source to make you satisfied.

Don't attack me..

Oh, Death Note. Loved it. It was sad when you know what happened in the middle. D:
The ending basically left me thinking "Who is the good person?", "Who did the right thing?"

Yeah...I was upset at that moment. The ending is what you said. It's the reality of life and well, I don't want to go deep but it's really damn good. The anime somewhat tweak it to make it saying how life could have been if a person don't play with god.

[Don-kun]

@Slextrem
Seeing the way he is being writing Sakura lately kind of lead me to believe that he did plan to kill her off, the problem is why? Is he such a bad writer that he will kill off the Main character of his story to open space to a side character for Naruto?

On the other hand there was an interview in 2012 where Kishi were asked by his Voice actors if seeing the flow of the story will he add any new changes to the Manga?
Kishi's reply was that he is not planning any changes and his story will stay the same way he planned, so if Sakura being saved by Naruto and Kakashi was his original plan then he seems that the killing her off could be a rumor who knows.

[narusaku4ver]

You shouldn't say what people say so literally. Of course it's not an attack. XD

She didn't even say this was a fact, just something interesting she wanted to share with us. Therefore she doesn't need a reliable source to make you satisfied.

Don't attack me..

Oh, Death Note. Loved it. It was sad when you know what happened in the middle. D:
The ending basically left me thinking "Who is the good person?", "Who did the right thing?"

That was the problem we were talking about another stuff based on the confession she comes and "guys i know this is a bit off topic but then..." comes with a information with no proof based on entirelly on speculation like Pain's arc, 573,Team taka, and so much more.
Killing off the previous subject, some people just freaked out and doing people discuss about something that didnt happened, and did not even was considered, we are just discussing speculations.

Edited by narusaku4ver, 11 February 2013 - 11:39 PM.

[FoolishYoungling]

https://www.facebook...d...=ts&fref=ts
We are back in the lead.. and now we are below again. The fact that we are this close when this is a western poll is amazing.

Edited by FoolishYoungling , 11 February 2013 - 11:44 PM.

[Slextrem]

You take it as an attack?
You say something with no proof "because a friend told me".

Yes, I took it as an attack. I'm just sharing information that I've acknowledged might not be true. As I've stated numerous times now, the only reason why I brought it up was to spark conversation regarding Kishimoto's intention for the confession (which was what everyone was talking about at the time I made my post.) My argument is not that this information is 100% fact. I know the rules of the road about sourcing. There's no need to treat me like I'm an imbecile for making my post. Thanks.

Edited by Slextrem, 11 February 2013 - 11:43 PM.

[neoshadow]

https://www.facebook...d...=ts&fref=ts
We are back in the lead! Only by 2 votes though!

By 1 now.
Talk about neck and neck, man the attempted murder must have severely crashed SasuSaku it used to be THE most popular of the 3.

[T XD]

That was the problem we were talking about another stuff based on the confession she comes and "guys i know this is a bit off topic but then..." comes with a information with no proof based on entirelly on speculation like Pain's arc, 573,Team taka, and so much more.
Killing off the previous subject, some people just freaked out and doing people discuss about something that didnt happened, and did not even was considered, we are just discussing speculations.

Just let it go.

Like you said, it didn't happen, so let's just all move on.

Guys, it didn't happen, and it won't happen. Period.

Edited by T XD, 11 February 2013 - 11:44 PM.

[kirabook]

Only by 1.

But I do wonder where all these NS fans are hiding. If I had to assume where, I'm guessing they are people who aren't interested in the anime or fandom except the movies (like I used to be) and have been watching/came across this page?

Ah, or maybe there are many among spanish speakers then. *read some comments*

Edited by kirabook, 11 February 2013 - 11:46 PM.

[Tsubaki]

doubt she will die i mean thats just Rin all over again and i say it in advance i dont want too see hinata die eighter she is pretty cool but not for Naruhina.

True! It would be ObiRin all over again .. kill her off far from the end would be such a terrible decision and wouldn't add anything to the story and how Sasuke could be forgiven after that?!

You take it as an attack?
You say something with no proof "because a friend told me".

she said she wasn't sure about the source. she just bought it here to discuss that possibility ... let's take it easy guys!

[Slextrem]

That was the problem we were talking about another stuff based on the confession she comes and "guys i know this is a bit off topic but then..." comes with a information with no proof based on entirelly on speculation like Pain's arc, 573,Team taka, and so much more.
Killing off the previous subject, some people just freaked out and doing people discuss about something that didnt happened, and did not even was considered, we are just discussing speculations.

How many times do I have to say that I wasn't trying to make this go off topic? It was slightly off topic, but the reason why I brought it up was to add some flavor to the conversation regarding Kishimoto's intention for the confession. If you continue to treat me like I'm an idiot by looking down on me, I'll contact the mods.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Honestly, I already drop the topic. True of not, let's not get heated up. I rather wait for the end and maybe Kishi will tell everything about it.

https://www.facebook...d...=ts&fref=ts
We are back in the lead.. and now we are below again. The fact that we are this close when this is a western poll is amazing.

I know I don't care so much, but wow, that's shocking to be honest. Hm, I should vote for the heck of it. I wonder if RtN will change many about NaruSaku, let alone Sakura.

[StriderC]

That was the problem we were talking about another stuff based on the confession she comes and "guys i know this is a bit off topic but then..." comes with a information with no proof based on entirelly on speculation like Pain's arc, 573,Team taka, and so much more.
Killing off the previous subject, some people just freaked out and doing people discuss about something that didnt happened, and did not even was considered, we are just discussing speculations.

I really don't know why you're going at her the way you are but she only brought information. You act as though she's the one who got the information from Kishi. She believes it could be true and it very well could be. It's possible that Chie got this information after the confession arc. Anyway, you really shouldn't get heated over this IMO given she isn't dead, and it's in the past. It's a nice topic for discussion but you seriously need to calm down dude.