

The Great NaruSaku Debate Thread!
#981
Posted 09 September 2007 - 09:27 PM


work through the pain

#982
Posted 10 September 2007 - 04:28 PM
*sighs* why does Sakura come up a discussion about Hinata?
Btw this is some people's thoughts on how hinata dealt with naruto's lonliness.

#983
Posted 10 September 2007 - 05:15 PM
Btw this is some people's thoughts on how hinata dealt with naruto's lonliness.
It's why people should just avoid debating about pairings from now on out. It's senseless to argue with people who don't even want to understand why we think Naruto and Sakura should be together.
For example, "People assume Naruto would be with Sakura because she's the leading lady and her BUNCH of screentime."
Really, that's not what we've been arguing; however, the amount of screentime the two have together, and the fact that Sakura is one of Naruto's first friends plays a lot into their relationship.
"People assume that Hinata should be with Naruto because she idolizes him and was one of the first people to see him in a positive light."
Yeah

#984
Posted 10 September 2007 - 05:49 PM
1. No, she doesn't. Like Mizura said in her essay, she thought he was fine.
Hinata has plenty of family. And I would bet despite his coldness and disappointment in her, her dad does love her.
2. She is not paralzing shy. Give her some credit.
Naruto was on the brink when Iruka saved him and admitted during the Gaara battle that he almost became like Gaara. Actually, that he would have if not for Iruka and Team 7.
If she realized he was this bad, why did she do nothing? Again, she is not crippling shy. Otherwise she would not be able to come out of her house.
3. If by lots of times, they mean 3, then yeah.
4. Where do they get that she's not allowed outside of the house? She's no longer 3. If they were that worried about her, then they wouldn't allow her to go missions.
"Hinata, you can't go to the Ramen stand because you might get knapped. Now go alseep early tonight because you got that life-threatening mission tommorrow."
5. Well, Sakura didn't know about the Kyuubi, and saw Sasuke perform a techique that broke through Gaara's unbreakable defense.
So, when you think about it, with her knowledge, she accepted that Naruto saved her pretty quickly.
6. It's called charcter development. Just because a character believes something about someone doesn't mean they'll always believe.
Otherwise, show where Sakura thinks Naruto is a pest or weak in the last hundred chapters.
7. Unless the fanfic is written by Kishimoto, then it's imaginary.
8. Hinata had plenty of people. Her clan. Her mom (possibly). Her sister (despite fan fictions, there's no hint that Hanabi has a bad relationship with her). Even her dad (twice when her safety is threaten, he's the one there to protect her, the only time he was during the Chunin pliminaries).
Sasuke's whole family was murdered by his brother.
There's a reason Kishimoto paints Naruto and Sasuke's bond as one of lonliness and not Naruto and Hinata's.
1. No. It's Kishimoto's fault since he has repeatedly refused to delop NaruHina when he's got the chance.
2. It's the bunch of development that counts.
3. Actually, if this person paid attention to the Chunin Exams, they would have realized that only her dad (and the Branch family, but she realized it wasn't personal) looked down upon her while Sakura was made fun of by all the girls except Ino.
There was no hint people outside of the clan gave Hinata any trouble.
4. He used the loser background. Not the lonliness background.
#985
Posted 10 September 2007 - 06:09 PM
1. Find a common-ish theme with Naruto.
2. Create character from that theme (and not the other way around!)
3. Character gets converted to Naruto's POV on the theme.
4. The end. The character eventually wins a few fights (or not).
In order to avoid overlapping and thus repetition of theme, Kishimoto always makes sure that the resulting characters don't ever have any influence on Naruto's Other aspects:
- Neji and Konohamaru won't even think about jinchuurikis
- Gaara won't influence Naruto's views on the Sasuke aspect, and he's one of the people thematically closest to Naruto!
- and yes, this means Hinata won't have any impact on the loneliness aspect.
At best they'll do the shounen thing and fight a bit. They won't sit down and talk to Naruto on things they know nothing about.
For loneliness, Naruto made it pretty clear who did have an impact: Iruka and team 7. People who made him not so lonely by you know, sticking around and interacting with him.
Geez. >_<
#986
Posted 10 September 2007 - 08:03 PM
it is more than one type of loneliness one type having know friends
other types are having no mom or dad. having body to care about you. not to listen to you troubles. having no one to talk too having no one to accept you for you. having no one believe in you. have no one to love and to love you back like boyfriend and girlfriend.

#987
Posted 10 September 2007 - 09:57 PM

Bunny: Sasuke, join me.
Sasuke: What will I receive if I join you?
Bunny: POWER! UNLIMITED POWER!
Sasuke: Sweet! what do I do?
Orochimaru: Sssssssssssssaaaaaaasssssssssukkkkkkeeeeeee-kkkuuuuuunnnn!
Sasuke: oh f***
Sono nantomo ienai sekushii na oshiri wo ore no kokan ni okittensukete rizumu ni awasete kosurinasai = Back that ass up.

#988
Posted 10 September 2007 - 10:24 PM
Lolz! Tell me about it!
Is it my eyes burning or does it say the two people Sakura has liked is Sai and Sasuke?

#989
Posted 10 September 2007 - 11:41 PM
it is more than one type of loneliness one type having know friends
other types are having no mom or dad. having body to care about you. not to listen to you troubles. having no one to talk too having no one to accept you for you. having no one believe in you. have no one to love and to love you back like boyfriend and girlfriend.
1. Really? Hinata was despised as a monster by the entire village? She could see herself becoming a psychipathic monster like Gaara? I must have missed that. Chapter number please.
2. What is this person reading? Sakura was cheering the whole match for Naruto and getting really into. So into it she felt a thrill by him winning. Nor can I find anywhere Sakura doesn't believe Kakashi saying Naruto beat Haku.
3. Naruto made the Promise of a Lifetime out of his own free will. Sakura did ask him to get Sasuke back, but she never asked him to promise.
4. The grammar is so bad I don't know what they're talking about in the sentence with Sasuke and killed.
5. Again, are they reading the same manga as us? When has she shown romantic inclinations towards Sai? Kohanamaru's jutsu? Sexual attraction doesn't equal romance. Nor does it mean someone can't have romantic inclinations towards someone else.
Also, there may be no sexual attraction towards Sai. It simply could be the hotness of the yaoi scene. Maybe more affective could mean she wants NaruSasu or SasuShika.
6. He also had thought his feelings for Naruto were making him weak. Does that mean he loves Naruto too (Team 7 triad fans getting their dream)?
Or could it be he sees Sakura as a sister or through the Team 7 bond (he thought of her and Naruto during the good-bye scene, so I think we can rule out a special connection with Sakura).
7. How many times does it show Shino hanging out with his friends? He must know the pain of a junchuuriki too.
For the record, one time (hanging out with Kiba before and during the Chunin match). Which when you take into consideration how minor of a charcter she is, is pretty good.
8. Naruto knew all of those. Hinata knew none.
Does Hinata even say lonliness at all?
#990
Posted 10 September 2007 - 11:48 PM
Oh, and be careful not to get carried away here, remember not to insult the poster and don't bash.
How does any of that prove she knows his lonliness? I She admired him and the reasons she kept pinning after him were all related to her desire to be like him. Everything I saw, says that, I can't think of a single even where she identifies with that lonliness or where she empathizes with it. If this poster thinks otherwise, they can site it. Otherwise, this doesn't proven anything regarding his loneliness.
That she talked to him before the Neji fight doesn't prove it either. Sakura had already started treating him better well before the fight against Gaara. Check out the rest of the chuunin exams, there are a whole host of examples of Sakura treating Naruto as something more than a pest. Her thanking Sasuke says more about what she wished for and believed about Sasuke than it does about her opinion of Naruto's weakness.
Except one of the hall marks of Naruto's character is that he doesn't give up. Sasuke did not always have someone there for him, at least in a meaningful sense. Fangirls wanted him because of apperance and ability, they new nothing of him personally and weren't there for him in any meaningful sense.This was his own doing to a degree, but he did not always have someone.
There is no proof that she had no one. That her father and sister looked down on her doesn't prove that everyone else did or that she had no one. Would I be surprised to learn she didn't? No, not really. But there is no evidence she was lonely. Her pain was that of a loser not loneliness. That she was lonely too is conjecture.
One Magus is right, and this statement mischaracterizes what we are actually saying. Moreover, poster says that like it's irrelevant. Screen time is essential for meaningful interaction. If Hinata never has any screentime then she won't have any additional interactions with anyone, let alone meaningful ones with Naruto.
You're assuming she does, not proving it. Cite chapters, scenes and the like where she actually complains of that loneliness or identifies with it.
it is more than one type of loneliness one type having know friends
other types are having no mom or dad. having body to care about you. not to listen to you troubles. having no one to talk too having no one to accept you for you. having no one believe in you. have no one to love and to love you back like boyfriend and girlfriend.
That she gave him cream doesn't prove loneliness, it's concern and says nothing of loneliness.
What do they mean "likes"? Crush of Friendship. I presume the former because it's very evident in Part 2 she has more than two friends. But in the latter case, since when has she ever liked Sai like that?
That they haven't shown her hanging out with her team doesn't prove loneliness. If fact from what we've seen so far it appears they all care about her. Your misconstruing her absence as proof of loneliness, when what it really speaks to is her (and Team 8's) relevance in the story. Such scene's aren't shown because that aren't important and there is no need to do so.
Next, Sasuke's feeling for Naruto were as much, if not more so, the reason he left. There is no evidence that he was returning her feelings in the romantic sense. He cared for her, sure, but I can't recall seeing anything that he was returning those feelings in the way she wanted him too.
As I said before, prove she doesn't have any of that and I'd be willing to accept that point, otherwise I will not.
#991
Posted 11 September 2007 - 12:06 AM
Oh let me take a shot at this:
Ok... how on earth can Sakura ask Naruto if he was ok after he WON the match with Kiba? During that time, she was cheering him on. It makes NO sense for Sakura to ask him if he's okay... the only way she can say this IF Naruto actually lost... And when the hell did Hinata had talked to Naruto for 2 hours? All she did was "watching" him... and talk to him to regain his confidence for the match with Neji.
...This absolutely make no sense...

Now... I gonna rant about this.

1) Yes Sakura still likes Sasuke (we still not sure her feelings for him now) but when did she has romantic feelings for Sai? Sakura only views Sai as a teammate/friend (recently and she kick his ass 2 times and she said he's an unemotional person.. and I can't remember what she said to Ino when they were talking about Sai) and if this guy/girl said this based on the scene when Konohamaru used the Double Knock-out Sexy Guy Version Jutsu on her to reveal her perverted side... :rolleyes:
2) Now on Sasuke's side...
Sasuke views Sakura as a friend. He didn't have romantic feelings for Sakura because she was interfering with his quest on revenge and power (also the fact that he STILL knows that she was one of the fangirls, too). Thats why he called her annoying. And on top of that, there was no such thing for Sasuke left because his feelings for her made him weak. Seeing Naruto getting stronger and better (look at the hospital fight scene), plus getting pwned by Itachi, gave him the option to leave. And 2 years later, Sasuke STILL have no interest in her... One interaction from the manga, recent:
(at the destruction site of Orochimaru's lair)
Sasuke: "Oi, its Sakura."
Sakura: (turn her head and has a surprise look on her face) "S..Sasu..ke.. -kun!"
That was it. No more interaction between the two. Plus he was about to attack her. And he had said he will kill Naruto and others if they interfere with his plan of vengence.
3) Is this person for real?

What's Happening with the Naruto series as of now!
#992
Posted 11 September 2007 - 03:59 PM
Here are some replies.
Most NaruHina who find it "cute" isn't as different as some NaruSaku fans like the couple because Hinata isn't a major character. There are more NaruSaku moments than NaruHina, therefore, people think NaruSaku will automatically happen. But it has an equal chance since Sakura is still in love with Sasuke. But compared to Sasuke, Sakura, and Hinata, Hinata is the only one who can relate to Naruto best. She does have a family, but not a very close one.

Dub Warning :excl: for those who can't stand it.
Also I believe this person has missed the point.

#993
Posted 11 September 2007 - 04:48 PM
*twitch*
Last I checked, Hinata's background was not "to love Naruto," but to prove that "people can change if they stand up for themselves," which she did just fine against Neji. >_>
Ugh. Besides missing the point, that wasn't even canon!

And we have no idea how old she was. We just know that she didn't do anything to help him. From what I can tell:
- first she perceived him as a kindred spirit that didn't get acknowledged (whereas she sought to be acknowledged by her father)
- then she was busy admiring how good he is at getting back up on his own
So much so that she didn't even Think of reaching out to him, because she thought her help not needed (when in fact, he Did need someone to reach to him). Some say she was just too shy. But her shyness isn't That crippling, and has no reason to when it comes to oh... helping someone else, and she has never even showed that she Wanted to reach to his pain of loneliness. In fact, she didn't even realize that he was Suffering from the pain of loneliness.
This just isn't part of her character design. The loneliness aspect got covered by Gaara and Sasuke instead.
#994
Posted 11 September 2007 - 05:25 PM
The rest of her speech was basically, even if you lose, you'll be fine because you have confidence in yourself.
So, while it's nice she gave him a pick up, she wasn't quite so sure of his ability either.
EDIT:
Most NaruHina who find it "cute" isn't as different as some NaruSaku fans like the couple because Hinata isn't a major character. There are more NaruSaku moments than NaruHina, therefore, people think NaruSaku will automatically happen. But it has an equal chance since Sakura is still in love with Sasuke. But compared to Sasuke, Sakura, and Hinata, Hinata is the only one who can relate to Naruto best. She does have a family, but not a very close one.
1. Argueable. Torment from your peers can mess you just as bad as coldness fron your father (again, we don't know the mom relationship or even the Hanabi relationship).
2. What good does it do to realize something and not do anything?
If Hinata noticed Naruto was suffering so much that he admits later on he could have easily into a pyschopathic monster like Gaara was if not for Iruka and Team 7, then does that make her?
If people want to argue that, then ask them why do they think she deserves him? In this scenerio, she was worse than Sakura. Much worse.
Sakura was an ignorant twelve year old who thought Naruto had it good having no parents to boss him around and that he picked on her.
In this scenerio, Hinata saw the true sufferings of a boy being pushed to madness by the hatefullness of the entire village and did nothing. Is shyness really an excuse to let the one you "love" go mad in the pain of lonliness? Especially when Sakura can't be forgiven for her actions to Naruto in the begining of the manga?
3. How is Kishimoto being unfair? Mizura said it perfectly. Hinata's theme is to change oneself. Not to be Naruto's girlfriend.
4. So, Naruto should go with a girl he's had less development with? That makes alot of sense.
5. Can this person prove that Sakura is still in love with Sasuke? Show any kind of evidence?
6. Not having a family and having a father who is distant from you are two VERY different things.
And so far, we can only say it's Hinata's father. I don't recall any scene or mention that implies a bad relationship with Hanabi. There is mention of their dad favoring Hanabi, but that wouldn't cause a bad relationship unless Hinata is jealous (doubtful), or their dad tries to turn her against Hinata (also doubtful since he is shown being cold, not hateful towards Hinata).
As for her mom, Kishimoto doesn't introduce alot of characters parents like Sakura's a main character who we both know are still alive at the start of the series (and likely still are since there is no mention of death). I don't see a reason for her to attend the Chunnin Exam (Haishi only went to watch Neji and brought Hanabi along so she could watch him). She could have stayed home for any number of reasons. She could be dead, but there is no proof either way.
#995
Posted 11 September 2007 - 05:29 PM

work through the pain

#996
Posted 11 September 2007 - 05:31 PM
The rest of her speech was basically, even if you lose, you'll be fine because you have confidence in yourself.
So, while it's nice she gave him a pick up, she wasn't quite so sure of his ability either.
Oh yeah.
that's true, that completely slipped my mind.
Thank you.

#997
Posted 11 September 2007 - 05:43 PM
By golly... thats is why they ARE fillers. And plus, Kishimoto said that Hinata (her theme and purpose in the series) is for the theme of believing yourself, to gain confidence. And what about Naruto's view of the matter of loneliness? From him, only Iruka, Team 7 (and the Sandaime Hokage who wasn't mentioned) acknowledged him... Hinata TRIED but didn't make a move...
And the word "Unfair"...
Last I checked, Hinata's background was not "to love Naruto," but to prove that "people can change if they stand up for themselves," which she did just fine against Neji. >_>
Ugh. Besides missing the point, that wasn't even canon!

And we have no idea how old she was. We just know that she didn't do anything to help him. From what I can tell:
- first she perceived him as a kindred spirit that didn't get acknowledged (whereas she sought to be acknowledged by her father)
- then she was busy admiring how good he is at getting back up on his own
So much so that she didn't even Think of reaching out to him, because she thought her help not needed (when in fact, he Did need someone to reach to him). Some say she was just too shy. But her shyness isn't That crippling, and has no reason to when it comes to oh... helping someone else, and she has never even showed that she Wanted to reach to his pain of loneliness. In fact, she didn't even realize that he was Suffering from the pain of loneliness.
This just isn't part of her character design. The loneliness aspect got covered by Gaara and Sasuke instead.
Agree with that. All of the scenes that this guy/girl pointed out ARE fillers and expansions for time of the episode. And as I said before, Iruka, the 3rd, Kakashi, Sakura and Sasuke DID the work of acknowledging Naruto, Hinata however, did it verbally but did physically nothing to help Naruto.
What's Happening with the Naruto series as of now!
#998
Posted 11 September 2007 - 06:47 PM

I said:
I agree that Hinata may tell Naruto her feelings.
How is it stupid to think that he would reject her? :stare:
OBVIOUSLY, we are not saying that Naruto would harshly reject her. I believe he would say something that would result in Hinata not being too upset by it and it would not stop her from focusing on her goal if he did.
I don't know what this STRANGE belief is that hinata would go belly up if naruto doesn't pair up with her.
Er....so what if hinata is his age and saw passed his pranks?
Age doesn't come into this. Naruto is looking to be achknowledged by his Village, he was not limiting it to his age group.
LOL, Whatever.

#999
Posted 11 September 2007 - 11:20 PM
Well, in fairness to Sakura and Sasuke, Sakura thought he was picking on her and he was agressive towards Sasuke (which he admits he handled his feelings of inferoirty wrong during the VotE fight).
Anyways, great response.
And she did nothing about it. So she gets no credit.
Naruto needed more than someone to "acknowledge" him. He needed someone to let him know they acknowledge him. Seriously, what good did it do Naruto.
Not to mention that false idea that just because someone acknowledged him first means she deserves him alone. If anything it gave her an advantage at first. Which she squandarded.
#1000
Posted 11 September 2007 - 11:26 PM
One the first point: why? Seriously, why are they going to have to do that? Hinata isn't very important to the overall story, especially now. Kishimoto can easily rap up all the major plot points without even touching this, let alone resolving it. So my question is, why must this happen and why would it be bad if they just forgot all about it?
What makes them think Naruto will return those feelings if he doesn't actually possess them? To return without possessing is actually rather cruel as it just gives a false hope. What has Naruto done or said to even suggest he might return them? I cannot think of a single thing. So I'm really not sure why it's stupid to think he won't return them.
And on the last point, who are those fans and why does that matter?
On this...I'm not sure what the point is. That Hinata deserves him because she came first so to speak? If that's it...then I only have one thing to say. I try to avoid the "deserves argument" especially in the context this poster appears to be making it because it's a never ending argument. If for those reasons, she deserves Naruto...then does Naruto not deserve Sakura for the same kind of reasons? It might also be Sakura deserves Sasuke for those reasons. If so the only resolution that doesn't leave someone being without the person they deserve is a foursome. Seriously, I'm not joking. But let's remove Sasuke, then the only solution is a threesome. What about Naruto's dedication and support of Sakura, does that not mean anything?
Why can't they show that stuff? I don't think Kishimoto left it out of the manga because he couldn't show it.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users