882 replies to this topic

[T XD]

Just her family and the only besides her is levi, beside the 9th titain shifter will on the side of marley and the only way Mikasa can get a titan sfhiter power is if she eats annie right now

Maybe she can be a titan shifter then. It's much less possible since one of the main characters is already a titan shifter.

Edited by T XD, 30 April 2017 - 03:50 PM.

[sushi.]

Maybe she can be a titan shifter then. It's much less possible since one of the main characters is already a titan shifter.

Mikasa already has Ackerman superpowers, if she becomes a titan she won't be able to fight in both ways. In battles she'd have to transform and we'd never see her soldier skills again, that's why I don't want it.

[rocci]

Maybe she can be a titan shifter then. It's much less possible since one of the main characters is already a titan shifter.

I don't think her become a Titan will contribute anyhing to the story. It's like asking sakura to have a kekkei genkai when in naruto kekkei genkai isn't everything, except uchiha.

And like sushi said we will not see her acrobatics skill.

[T XD]

I don't think her become a Titan will contribute anyhing to the story. It's like asking sakura to have a kekkei genkai when in naruto kekkei genkai isn't everything, except uchiha.

And like sushi said we will not see her acrobatics skill.

Mikasa already has Ackerman superpowers, if she becomes a titan she won't be able to fight in both ways. In battles she'd have to transform and we'd never see her soldier skills again, that's why I don't want it.

She can be fighting in human form then to a titan form. Titan shifters should have the three options of choosing on whether to fight in their titan form, in human form or being in human form then transforming to a titan.
 
Anyway, it's not that much of a likely possibility for her.

Edited by T XD, 30 April 2017 - 04:55 PM.

[AHK]

Aside from the anime producers confirming them being a couple and Histotia blushing most of the time Ymir flirts, Ymir sent to Historia a love letter that one of the things it includes on them not being able to get married.
 
Come on. They were canon XD

None of which actually confirms that they were ever a couple, and last I checked the producers words don't actually mean anything since they're not the author, and it hasn't been shown or implied that they were a couple in the manga.

[LuckyChi7]

None of which actually confirms that they were ever a couple, and last I checked the producers words don't actually mean anything since they're not the author, and it hasn't been shown or implied that they were a couple in the manga.

I've been trying to say the same thing!

[sushi.]

I want to marry all my friends.

[AHK]

I've been trying to say the same thing!

  
Lol great minds and all

I want to marry all my friends.

Great, but if your friends don't want to marry you, it doesn't mean anything.

[T XD]

None of which actually confirms that they were ever a couple, and last I checked the producers words don't actually mean anything since they're not the author, and it hasn't been shown or implied that they were a couple in the manga.

Forget about the producers. It's not about them being literally a couple shown or implied. It's that there was romance going on between them is canon.

Edited by T XD, 30 April 2017 - 07:22 PM.

[AHK]

Forget about the producers. It's not about them being literally a couple shown or implied. It's that there was romance going on between them is canon.

If it wasn't shown or implied, then there wasn't romance going on, and it wasn't canon. You had one character that liked another. That does not make it canon.

[sushi.]

But it was shown/implied. You're just repeating the only argument you have over again.

 

Also they were talking about marriage, not their first date. I think they're beyond the step of not knowing how the other feels.

Edited by sushi., 30 April 2017 - 10:10 PM.

[T XD]

If it wasn't shown or implied, then there wasn't romance going on, and it wasn't canon. You had one character that liked another. That does not make it canon.

There are obviously two characters who like each other in many manga / anime and are not a couple.

The two of them liked each other. In the love letter, Ymir said ' What I'm trying to say... Sincerely... I cannot marry you yet '. One can't say to the other such thing without the other reciprocating.

Edited by T XD, 30 April 2017 - 10:56 PM.

[BlueStarSaber]

Even if they were a couple ymir only had a few years left to live anyway so a long term relationship wouldn't have worked

[AHK]

But it was shown/implied. You're just repeating the only argument you have over again.
 
Also they were talking about marriage, not their first date. I think they're beyond the step of not knowing how the other feels.

Except it wasn't. Because it's the only argument I need.

No, they weren't talking about anything, Ymir was. Again, nothing points to them being a couple within the story. It's a headcannon.

There are obviously two characters who like each other in many manga / anime and are not a couple.
The two of them liked each other. In the love letter, Ymir said ' What I'm trying to say... Sincerely... I cannot marry you yet '. One can't say to the other such thing without the other reciprocating.

Which means those two characters aren't a cannon couple.

Yes, you can. It was never reciprocated, ever. Honestly, it came off to me the entire time like they were friends and that Ymir was trying to force herself on Historia. Either way you look at it, there is nothing in the manga that implied that Historia liked Ymir beyond friendship, nor that they were a couple.

[FoolishYoungling]

Stop spoiling the manga!

 

Manga

Ymir not ending up with Christa is alright with me. Never was against or for it. Ymir saved Christa's life in so many ways, but as a relationship, it wouldn't of worked. Ymir isn't really the type who you could settle down and live happily ever after with. Ymir dying off is the best for the pairing. Obviously Ymir was in love with Christa, and I'm sure Christa more than likely felt something back at her; however, Ymir would make one crappy wife.

 

I wonder how many chapters we have left. 20? 30? Can't be much more left.

 

Things we need sorted out:

 

1. War problems. Nobody likes Marley. Rip Marley.

2. Let Annie free. She dindu nuffin. Innocent and pure.

3. Eren and Mikasa need to have kids.

[rocci]

@ahk
When a couple of characters has mutual feeling, they're pretty much canon. In this case the story itself recognize them as couple and this is much more stronger than recognizing a couple through chemistry.

Since in any manga when you see a two girl going together and one of them has a masculine tendency while the other have a feminine quality on top of that it's a guardian and princess interaction. Most of the time you instantly recognize there's "something" going on between them. It reveal that Ymir is in love with her and the next question is does historia feel the same?

I think it already imply that historia too has a thing for her hence her tear when she read the letter.
So until the author himself change it to a new revelation in the future chapters that historia is just kind girl who see Ymir as sister, than they're pretty much canon yuri couple in a shonen manga.

[AHK]

Except that's not how it works. The story does not recognize them as a couple, because they're not. Ymir likes historia, but there was no reciprocation and there was no confirmation on historia's part either. There was nothing that was implied or shown that suggests that they were a couple at any point.

[sushi.]

The only way that letter makes sense is if they've talked about marrying before.

"I can't marry you yet" is not, "Will you marry me? I like you".

It means Historia once said they should get married, and Ymir answers 'not yet' in the letter.

[AHK]

The only way that letter makes sense is if they've talked about marrying before.
"I can't marry you yet" is not, "Will you marry me? I like you".
It means Historia once said they should get married, and Ymir answers 'not yet' in the letter.

No it doesn't mean that at all. You can say that you're going to marry someone, it doesn't mean hat person had ever agreed to it. That letter makes plenty of sense if they've never talked about it, because that's how it always has been with Ymir. She's always said something like that, and historia had never responded. Saying it must have happened doesn't mean it did. Again, it's a headcannon.

[LuckyChi7]

The Masssive Revelation in Attack on Titan has finally occured in the anime and holy kitten!:

 

http://watchsnk.net/...isode-6-subbed/

 

 

 

My Review: