142 replies to this topic

[TouKen4Life3g]

Funny to see the supposedly new Team 7. It's like half way to war arc, it's all about the original and no mention to next gen ever again. This is why the story got harmed along the way.

[rikakim94]

 

I think the one who manged to create such a good story in Naruto was the manga original editor, Yahagi.

Basically he came up with the ideas and kishimoto kept drawing ,  this is supported by the fact that the story began its downfall after Sasuke obtained his MS and that was around the time Yahagi left Kishimoto 

 

 

The interview Kishi had after the end with Naruto in which Yahagi participates with him is a big proof too, over there it was stated by kishi himself that he always followed his editor words. Yahagi even said to him that this was a bad thing in the same interview.

 

Is that true that kishi relied on his first editor too much? did the editor criticized him for that? can i see the interview?

Edited by rikakim94, 12 February 2015 - 04:57 PM.

[TouKen4Life3g]

 
Is that true that kishi relied on his first editor too much? did the editor criticized him for that? can i see the interview?

It's very true.

[Chatte]

kakashi novel

[Popuri]

Yup, I know what you mean... 

Well, as I understood from here and there, Kaguya wasn't even his idea, it was SJ's idea and also he wanted to introduce Toneri as a villain for a future movie (Boruto I think?) but he wasn't allowed and thus...we get the Last.

Idk who the hell came with this idea in the end but it's basically so so bad...

Sorry, Kaguya is SJ's idea? 

[Chatte]

Sorry, Kaguya is SJ's idea? 

Yup. For Kishi, Madara was his final villain but apparently he had to introduce Kaguya or Kaguya was introduced in order to take Madara out, idk the exact details. I just remember that the overall idea was that yeah, Kaguya is SJ's idea to bring back Byakugan and also Kishi was pressured to end the manga faster because it had to be ready for the movie for SP. So yeah, if you;re wondering why this weird ending, do the math. We've got enough loads of crap to sum it up to a pile of kitten, excuse my language please.

[Popuri]

 

I think the one who manged to create such a good story in Naruto was the manga original editor, Yahagi.

Basically he came up with the ideas and kishimoto kept drawing ,  this is supported by the fact that the story began its downfall after Sasuke obtained his MS and that was around the time Yahagi left Kishimoto 

 

 

The interview Kishi had after the end with Naruto in which Yahagi participates with him is a big proof too, over there it was stated by kishi himself that he always followed his editor words. Yahagi even said to him that this was a bad thing in the same interview.

1. So Yahagi left Naruto first then Sasuke gets MS then downfall or Sasuke gets MS first then since Yahagi disagree so it comes to downfall? 

2. This interview, where can I read it? I ever read an interview about Yahagi and Naruto (or something like that) but I felt I didn't read about bad thing.

3. What bad thing? The ending?

[Chatte]

1. So Yahagi left Naruto first then Sasuke gets MS then downfall or Sasuke gets MS first then since Yahagi disagree so it comes to downfall? 

2. This interview, where can I read it? I ever read an interview about Yahagi and Naruto (or something like that) but I felt I didn't read about bad thing.

3. What bad thing? The ending?

1. Yagahi left after Sasuke acquired his Magekyo Sharingan. Ergo from there you can see the downfall of the series starts to begin.

2. Gimmie a sec.

3. A bad thing for Kishi to keep listening to his editors and Yagahi criticizes him for it. :)

 

interview

Edited by Chatte, 13 February 2015 - 10:24 AM.

[Popuri]

Yup. For Kishi, Madara was his final villain but apparently he had to introduce Kaguya or Kaguya was introduced in order to take Madara out, idk the exact details. I just remember that the overall idea was that yeah, Kaguya is SJ's idea to bring back Byakugan and also Kishi was pressured to end the manga faster because it had to be ready for the movie for SP. So yeah, if you;re wondering why this weird ending, do the math. We've got enough loads of crap to sum it up to a pile of kitten, excuse my language please.

That's alright. I understand   Then if he wasn't pressured there's chance the ending would be "the logical"?

 

Wait, you remember about Shaman King mangaka who had pressured also working in SJ? Do you think the situation is the same with Kishi? If not, which part? If yes, would SJ allow Kishi to publish his "true ending"? (Shaman King mangaka also do that -but still- in Shounen Jump mag, right?)

 

EDIT: If I'm not mistaken SK mangaka didn't published his "true ending" in SJ, but its branch. SJ-something.

Edited by xpopurix, 13 February 2015 - 10:27 AM.

[Popuri]

1. Yagahi left after Sasuke acquired his Magekyo Sharingan. Ergo from there you can see the downfall of the series starts to begin.

2. Gimmie a sec.

3. A bad thing for Kishi to keep listening to his editors and Yagahi criticizes him for it. :)

 

interview

 

I unconsciously hit the ctrl+F to search it 

 

It's the same interview that I read last year. I wasn't read it carefully, I think. The second pic, right? Oh, I thought it's about the ending.

[Otaru]

@otaru
He's just good at drama including drawing emotional scene.

 

Yes But I think it's not just that...  I don't know....

 

 

 

I think the one who manged to create such a good story in Naruto was the manga original editor, Yahagi.

Basically he came up with the ideas and kishimoto kept drawing ,  this is supported by the fact that the story began its downfall after Sasuke obtained his MS and that was around the time Yahagi left Kishimoto 

 

 

The interview Kishi had after the end with Naruto in which Yahagi participates with him is a big proof too, over there it was stated by kishi himself that he always followed his editor words. Yahagi even said to him that this was a bad thing in the same interview.

 

You think so ? Well... it's true Sasuke and Sakura weren't even Kishimoto's idea... at first he came up with only Naruto and Kakashi if I remember well...

I didn't notice the time the manga started to downfall was coinciding with the time Yahagi left. But why did he left ? I'm not aware about gossip...

I need to read that interview...
 

Edited by Otaru, 16 February 2015 - 09:35 PM.

[rocci]

@otaru
He's great at building hype, but failed to fulfill it.
I think I could understand what your feel.

Yahagi become chief editor( or something like that) in jump seinen magazine.

[Nar123]

 

 

NEWS about sakura novel...

 

 

 

 

 

 

NARUTO―ナルト―小櫻秘傳
（NARUTO ─ナルト─ サクラ秘伝）
作者：大崎 知仁
日本4月3日發售。

●內容介紹：
木ノ葉隠れの里の優秀な医療忍者として激務に追われるサクラ。一方で、胸に秘めた想いは打ち明けられぬまま…。
平和な里の影でうごめく闇が、サクラと木ノ葉の里を襲う。第7班メンバーにして、五代目火影の弟子、サクラのエピソードが小説で解禁!

＜翻譯＞
身為木葉忍者村裡優秀的醫療忍者，小櫻每天都有做不完的事情。另一方面，心裡隱藏的那份感情還是沒能傳達出去…。
…

 

 

"As the greatest medic in Konoha, Sakura is busy with work. 
The feelings yet to be spoken locked up in her heart…

 

 

 

The darkness in the peaceful village, stirring. Ready to attack Sakura and Konoha.

As the godaime’s apprentice, and a member of team 7; Sakura’s story is about to be unfold

 

 

Edited by Nar123, 19 February 2015 - 01:23 AM.

[ThroughWithLove]

 

 

 

NEWS about sakura novel...

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'd rather eat sand that read that.

[rikakim94]

@otaru
He's great at building hype, but failed to fulfill it.
I think I could understand what your feel.

Yahagi become chief editor( or something like that) in jump seinen magazine.

 

Is there an actual source that claims that yahagi became chief editor for the senin magazine? If kishi is planning the serialize the mario manga  i think he should bring back yahagi as an editor and he should stick with him until the very end.

[DeathGodMack]

 

 

 

NEWS about sakura novel...

 

"As the greatest medic in Konoha, Sakura is busy with work. 
The feelings yet to be spoken locked up in her heart…

 

 

 

 

Could be NaruSaku.

[RedFaction]

Could be NaruSaku.

Or more likely just another mislead and it's going to be SS.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Or more likely just another mislead and it's going to be SS.

Shhh. You're ruining their scheme!

[Nar123]

Or more likely just another mislead and it's going to be SS.

Most probably

[Phantom_999]

 

 

 

NEWS about sakura novel...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What feelings? She was reduced to her starting fan girl personality. There's nothing to talk about regarding her feelings cause it is all nothing but just an excuse now. And a pretty pathetic one at that

Edited by Phantom_999, 20 February 2015 - 12:51 PM.