I'm not a scoring guy, but I do review them. Personally, I don't like the score, because it seems rather heavily focused. I like to talk about it and call it a day. I know people today run by looking at the score and dismiss. I do like pros and cons, but preferably to read it to find out the depth view on why.
That said I may share some of the materials of mine here. I go by a system that breaks down into four parts. That way you can understand the pros and cons. I also don't let my judgement clouded by the original source like "manga covered this, but anime skipped it." I say it as it is. So in the future, I look forward sharing some of that.
I perfectly agree with you! I personally believe that too many people solely focus on the score without ever having read the analysis. That being said, I do believe that a cleverly created scoring system (which is usually divided into story, character, animation, and... something else, lol) helps you to focus better on the analysis. Datanimesnob really, really is annoying, lol, but I do like to listen to him and read his reviews. That dude has more credibility than some of the fanboys on youtube.