8493 replies to this topic

[CloudMountainJuror]

A filler chapter...?... Sorry, but that's a huge stretch. Sure, we can think of it ourselves, but we should definitely avoid bringing that into any debates. It just...sounds outrageous. The definition of "filler" is stuff that isn't in the manga, right? Well, whether Kishi drew it or not, Hinata's "stunt" is in the manga.

[Sakamaki Izayoi]

A filler chapter...?... Sorry, but that's a huge stretch. Sure, we can think of it ourselves, but we should definitely avoid bringing that into any debates. It just...sounds outrageous. The definition of "filler" is stuff that isn't in the manga, right? Well, whether Kishi drew it or not, Hinata's "stunt" is in the manga.

i'm taking filler as an example .
i think u can think about this, i'm not talking about hinata's stunt but about the entire chapter

[CloudMountainJuror]

i'm taking filler as an example .
i think u can think about this, i'm not talking about hinata's stunt but about the entire chapter

Oh, an example. Alright, that makes more sense. And I know you're not just referring to the Hinata part, I was talking to the people that were focusing on it. All I know is that I really hope that Kishi at least planned the entire chapter before someone else illustrated it...

[ciardha]

Eh, even if Kishi was letting an editor draw one or two of his chapters, I'm pretty sure he'd give whoever the specifics of what he wants, and then he'd look over it for himself. I doubt there is any material that he doesn't personally want or approve of.

Just saying. =/

Exactly. I've been reading manga for 30 years now and I've never heard of such a thing as this rumor happening. A mangaka approves what is done in chapter, even if he doesn't draw it. If the mangaka is not availible to approve it because they are in the hospital the chapter just doesn't come out that week, or weeks, period. That's happened in many, many manga, even very popular ones. If it's an extended period of hospitalization- like Yuu Watase (twice), during Genbu Kaidden, the title is suspanded until the mangaka recovers.

Give me the mesage image as proof or I'm treating it as a false rumor. Seriously, I'm a major narusaku shipper, but I'm not buying this rumor without concrete proof.

[Sakamaki Izayoi]

Exactly. I've been reading manga for 30 years now and I've never heard of such a thing as this rumor happening. A mangaka approves what is done in chapter, even if he doesn't draw it. If the mangaka is not availible to approve it because they are in the hospital the chapter just doesn't come out that week, or weeks, period. That's happened in many, many manga, even very popular ones. If it's an extended period of hospitalization- like Yuu Watase (twice), during Genbu Kaidden, the title is suspanded until the mangaka recovers.

Give me the mesage image as proof or I'm treating it as a false rumor. Seriously, I'm a major narusaku shipper, but I'm not buying this rumor without concrete proof.

You are not obligated to accept what i'm sayin , and this is not a rumour .
i agree with u he should approve but his injury was not serious enough to suspend it's publication, but like i said before ofc he approved it not cuz of hinata's stunt and all of the things but because it didnt changed the story he could not continue what he wanted to because he could not draw.

i'm expecting the volume 60 to be realesed cuz he will change some panels in that manga i think

i think we should end this conversation because we should talk about the movie 6.
so it officially end here

Edited by dovahkiin, 30 April 2012 - 07:08 PM.

[AzureWaters]

i'm taking filler as an example .
i think u can think about this, i'm not talking about hinata's stunt but about the entire chapter

Yes, but I'm sure that even if Kishi was injured and couldn't write, the manga chapter (in this case 573) would still be legit because Kishi would approve of the material that his editors did. So even if this thing about kishi being out of commison is true, the idea that the actions or words of the characters within the chapter doesn't count would still be faulty.

[Sakamaki Izayoi]

Yes, but I'm sure that even if Kishi was injured and couldn't write, the manga chapter (in this case 573) would still be legit because Kishi would approve of the material that his editors did. So even if this thing about kishi being out of commison is true, the idea that the actions or words of the characters within the chapter doesn't count would still be faulty.

i dont think so cuz it's like it is as if you had a work to do and ask someone else to do then u look at the result and approves and then handle it to ur teacher

[Naty]

Are u talking about this community?

http://www.orkut.com...ity?cmm=4118275

Yep. That's NSL, the biggest NaruSaku community in the world i think (ten thousand members) <3
Anyway, Drew said that the note about Kishi's injured hand is true and he is the one with the WSJ, we trust him. I'll try to get some scans to show here.

[Sakura Blossoms]

Did you guys really need a Mod to come in here and say stay on topic? There are at least 3 pages of completely off-topic chatter here. Please take the current conversation that does not pertain to the current movie topic to a relevant thread.

[Strangelove]

Yeah listen to the


Uhmm

TehNinjaPanda1

...O.o 7506 gamer score?

Edited by Strangelove, 01 May 2012 - 02:04 AM.

[Derock]

To backup Sakura Blossoms' post:

Refer to that Chapter 573 discussion here: http://www.narusaku....showtopic=12041

This thread is for the new movie. Any discussion other than that must be moved to that relevant topic or it will be deleted.

[Dragunov]

One thing I really enjoyed from the movie was the music though. I dare say it was quite good ^-^

[choco2]

you know there are some jerk NaruSaku haters change the original script on Wiki LoooL
http://naruto.wikia....:_Road_to_Ninja
From
Naruto and Sakura are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.
To
Naruto and his friends are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.

So I edited that page back to normal but they still try to change it to his friends

it's clear on original script
it said Naruto and Sakura are just attaked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu

Edited by choco2, 03 May 2012 - 01:26 AM.

[MangaReader]

you know there are some jerk NaruSaku haters change the original script on Wiki LoooL
http://naruto.wikia....:_Road_to_Ninja
From
Naruto and Sakura are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.
To
Naruto and his friends are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.

So I edited that page back to normal but they still try to change it to his friends

it's clear on original script
it said Naruto and Sakura are just attaked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu

For a wiki that's suppose to be unbiased...it sure is pretty biased towards NaruSaku in a negative way

[TouKen4Life3g]

For a wiki that's suppose to be unbiased...it sure is pretty biased towards NaruSaku in a negative way

Irony...

Man, how long until a new info for the movie? It felt like there was no new chapter this week or even anime (even though it's tomorrow). Probably the final exam is taking energy out of me.

[MangaReader]

Irony...

Man, how long until a new info for the movie? It felt like there was no new chapter this week or even anime (even though it's tomorrow). Probably the final exam is taking energy out of me.

It is Ironic...they should just call it the NaruHina Wiki with very little factual support

IKR, though in my case, finals are next week

[choco2]

For a wiki that's suppose to be unbiased...it sure is pretty biased towards NaruSaku in a negative way

I will edit to Sakura instead of his friends

you know fans can edit Wiki but they can't edit the official source (TVTokyo) LooL

Edited by choco2, 03 May 2012 - 01:46 AM.

[ciardha]

you know there are some jerk NaruSaku haters change the original script on Wiki LoooL
http://naruto.wikia....:_Road_to_Ninja
From
Naruto and Sakura are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.
To
Naruto and his friends are both attacked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu.

So I edited that page back to normal but they still try to change it to his friends

it's clear on original script
it said Naruto and Sakura are just attaked by the man's mysterious new dōjutsu

Plus their edit is ungrammatical. Both refers to two people, not one person and a group of people. I swear that is one of the most pathetic deliberate misdirections on Narutopedia- all one has to do is go to the TV Tokyo page, and see that Naruto and Sakura's names alone are listed in that spot. Plus, even for folks that can't read Japanese the page has been accurately translated on several Naruto related places.

[MangaReader]

I will edit to Sakura instead of his friends

you know fans can edit Wiki but they can't edit the official source (TVTokyo) LooL

You just can't keep a good fan down...but yes, they need to follow exactly what the information gives us

[Verilance]

You just can't keep a good fan down...but yes, they need to follow exactly what the information gives us

This is hilarious because someone has changed it back to "and friends" again lol

interestingly enough her comment on the edit says "show us proof" which is readily available on the Japanese poster haha

Edited by Verilance, 03 May 2012 - 03:05 AM.