Why are they trying to erase someone who was integral to the story, self-empowered and supportive of the hero, no matter what? It makes no sense. And if you love the story, then you would have to recognize her importance to the plot.
It takes so much greater effort to wipe her from relevancy than it does just to give her a happy ending. So, why are they doing it? (I know, it's a bit of a rhetorical question there. For Hinata, obviously.)
It seems to me that the decisions that were made -- to pair SS and NH against the grain of the rest of the story -- left them with little choice. In order to make NH happen, everything else had to be subject to corruption.
It's really not possible to give Sakura a happy ending. In order to reposition Hinata as the most important person in Naruto's life and his love interest, Sakura has to be removed as Naruto's closest confidante and go-to person for his feelings and interest.
Likewise, Sakura can't be super confident and capable or succeed at a lot because she will outshine Hinata who is useless -- and remains so even in the movie that focuses solely on her. Hinata is weak, pitiful, and incompetent. Sakura cannot be better in any way or Hinata's image will suffer.
And then there's the fact that in order to give Naruto to Hinata, it meant that Sakura -- despite her growth and maturity and tangible closeness with Naruto in the story -- was stuck with Sasuke. There was no love between Sakura and Sasuke in the original story, and no development of Sasuke as a person with really any feelings at all. Sasuke and Gaara sort of switched places, and Sasuke ended up the character with love only for himself.
The truth is, all the characters are ruined. It's not just Sakura. Naruto is completely destroyed as well. And Sasuke? He's clearly not important to the story anymore either, with the possible exception of assisting Naruto in some kind of fight. He's got nothing to add to the domestic subplots, so fights and warrior activity are all he's good for -- and that's only if such a situation is contrived. How is that going to happen a lot in an era of peace?
See, it wasn't a simple decision to go with NH and reward Hinata. To make it happen in both the short and long term requires the deconstruction of everything that went before -- precisely because Hinata was never meant to be Naruto's mate or the most important character of the franchise.
















