Without getting detailed, feel free to reference prior posts, its simple, really, it's quite informed that they both are, Kishimoto also says they both were. The counter question is, if you believe he was lying, why would he lie, and prove he is lying.
I don't read posts that arent adressed to me not to get involved in others' discussions and because I'm lazy af.
Please, I just came back, how many posts would I have to read? I like to answer point for point, so asking me to go back it's too much, I would never finish answering! Also i'm on my cellphone which makes it way more complicated, beware my little hands :'(
I think you shouldnt have any problem writing down a short essay about your facts and analysis. You talk a lot about reasoning and logic, so I rather read all that you have to say in the same text.
Let's begin for this: (Refering to me saying why you think NH and SS were the ending game) "Kishimoto said they both were." I don't have to answer the following questions to that affirmation since I'll cut it up from this discussion right now and forever.
I don't care and it doesn't matter if Kishimoto says so. It also doesn't matter if he lied or not. My question, and what it matters, is if it's makes sense (and since you seem to rely on logic as much as me I think you would agree) story-wise and story-telling-wise. So my question, again, what are your arguments to defend the ending as a correct way to finish Naruto. Of course, I'm not only refering to the romantic couples, but also every detail about any of the characters and their after-story. I've read you think it has its issues, but you still think it was a good ending. Please, enlight me on how it is good.
Edited by Khaleesi, 28 July 2017 - 09:42 PM.