Anyway, what you said about Sakura being in love with Sasuke and Naruto at the same time, well I do agree essentially - she loves both Naruto and Sasuke, so much so that they dominate her life (or maybe that's just the way Kishi writes it ).
I agreed that Sakura does love both boy
With Naruto, her love is hard to define. So many things about that confession seemed so wrong - especially the part where she said that Sasuke was distant whereas Naruto had always stuck by her. Made him sound like a consolation prize. But what a lot of people fail to aknowledge is that ultimately, had Naruto accepted her, they would have become a couple - Saskura must have been aware of that or she wouldn't have put it in that manner. And however unromantic a beginning the relationship would have had, it also has seem strong foundations to build on. That said, I'm still not buying that its romantic love at the moment - it clearly hadn't occured to Sakura to love anyone else but Sasuke in that way until recently and she's obviousle having a hard time letting him go. Until she does, Naruto doesn't stand a chance - especially if he wants all of her attention as opposed to something half-hearted.
To me, That part was the most sincere of the confession especially when she said that Naruto bring her peace. The smile that she gave when she hug him seem very sincere. However, I agreed that, when she was saying that Sasuke was distance and unrecognizable, it seem more like that she was trying to convince Naruto to stop chasing Sasuke. So yes, I partly agreed about the fact that this part was wrong.
With Sasuke, its not a s clear cut as a lot of the SS fans seem to think either. She was completely in love with Sasuke and her focus for the last 3 years or so has been bringing him back. I think that she's still in love with the boy that he was - regardless of the man that he's becoming (as 484 showed). Plus he was her comrade and her team mate and I think she feels a responsibility to him. She's still tied to him in many ways and I think he will always be deeply precious to her in a way that Naruto isn't (at the moment).
Completely in love is questionable. I could say that she love him but she seem to have gave up when we see her holding the handle of the hospital door when she hear Naruto saying that Sasuke got away. Of course, this could also mean that she was too shock to believe about the new and when she was saying to Naruto ' Why'd you apologizing?', she had the same fake smile as Naruto when he's trying to hide his pain but it was Naruto that gave her the motivation to not give up. So, to me, if she was really IN LOVE, surely she wouldn't have abandon that easily.
I agreed that Sasuke will be precious to her his a way that Naruto isn't because Sasuke is her first love. Even if she choose Naruto in the end, nothing will change that.
I think - just in terms of Sakura's feelings - Naruto and Sasuke won't compete properly for her affections until they are both back on the same side, on her team again, both with a fighting chance if that makes sense. Then its a case of the best man winning but until then I think it will be Sasuke (unless of course they decide to kill Sasuke but I can't see that happening - it would go against everything the manga has stood for!).
She said that Sakura love both boy in her first statement yet, if Sasuke come back, it will necessarily mean that Sasuke will be her final choice. I really have to disagreed with that because, in the time that Sasuke is redeem and come back, she could have all the time to reconsider her feeling for him. The fact that she couldn't kill him in both time mean that she wasn't ready to face him and take the responsibility to kill him because she did it only for Naruto, she wasn't thinking about her need at that time. The fact that she did it only for Naruto was, in a way, very touching and that prove that she care for him enough to take this burden herself but as soon as Sasuke ask her to kill Karin, we could clearly see her hesitation to kill him instead. In a way, I can agreed that she still love Sasuke but that doesn't mean that it will stay that way.
Either way, I don't like seeing Sakura this way either - I keep getting over the revelations that turn up each week, forgetting that for Sakura its only been a few minutes between chapters and she's still going to be going through turmoil. I just want this madness bit with the Sauce to be over. At least, I don't think Sasuke will be redeemed and decide to come home all in this fight with Naruto but I do hope that Naruto, Sakura and Kakashi are going to realise that killing him won't help - that they will have to save him some other way. Or something. I hate the idea of him as the main villain. Especially as whetver I do I can't hate him. He's just too cool and too sympathetic a character. It just sucks seeing him like this
I agreed that killing Sasuke is not the solution to help him but that doesn't mean that this possibility can't be consider. If there is no other solution then Naruto ( because I think that we can all agreed that it will be Naruto that will take that decision) will kill him to prevent Sasuke from destroying Konoha. Of course, Naruto will probably ( and I hope that he will) try one last attempt to redeem Sasuke without killing him but, like Gaara said, if Naruto want to take the role of Hokage, he'll have to learn to take hard decision and Sasuke's fate is the first one.
As for not deserving redemption - surely that harder and further he falls, the better the redemption (as long as Kishi can write it well enough). Over at SS they were wondering how guilty Sasuke will feel after he has seen the light or whatever. I think originally he was a person who had a great deal of integrity so he will feel it really badly. They were wondering how he will try to make it up to her - if he thinks that he can. Its a sweet thing to look forward to
I agreed that, if he can be redeem, he'll certainly feel guilty. However, it won't be only for Sakura but for Naruto, Kakashi as well. As far as I can tell, Sasuke never look at Sakura as a 'potential girlfrend' but as a teammate and the fact that he's back won't change just because he feel guilty for trying to kill her. Personnally, I woudn't want that and it not only because I'm a NS fan but because it would be very un-Sasuke-like to love her like that considering that I never saw any sign that could lead that he love her ( the only potential sign was the 'thank you' scene but even so, that doesn't proof 100% that it was because he accept her love, it could simply mean that he was grateful that she care for him). What bug me in that statement is that it's good that Sasuke decide to love Sakura out of guilt but it not when it Sakura do it toward Naruto when she confess to him. ( because, to me, that is the same kind of situation).
Edited by silverserenity, 27 February 2010 - 11:58 PM.