Azula is special, but I honestly believe the ability Toph has to tell if someone is lying is similar to being able to tell if someone is lying via heartbeat, and again, it can be tricked and while no one else is really like Azula, that doesn't mean they can't be great at lying too. And you do have a point about metal bending. It may just be that her foot was still being covered.

The Legend of Korra: Avatar Korra
#381
Posted 09 June 2012 - 08:53 PM
Azula is special, but I honestly believe the ability Toph has to tell if someone is lying is similar to being able to tell if someone is lying via heartbeat, and again, it can be tricked and while no one else is really like Azula, that doesn't mean they can't be great at lying too. And you do have a point about metal bending. It may just be that her foot was still being covered.
#382
Posted 10 June 2012 - 01:18 AM
#384
Posted 10 June 2012 - 07:41 AM
And noww....
EDIT:
Preview for SEASON FINALE! Airs on April 23
Edited by Fliss, 10 June 2012 - 07:47 AM.
❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀
#387
Posted 10 June 2012 - 06:54 PM
#388
Posted 10 June 2012 - 11:49 PM
you know, if you intentionally included Aang into your "aftermath of decisions" senario, I'd like to prod you to help me out here, chou-chou!
in terms of consequential factors in societal ethics and with Aang's punishment for Ozai in mind, do you think that the death sentence even exists in the Avatar-verse? I'm thinking that it either does and is assigned just as usual (like in ours) with spiritbending being the absolute above-all-authority last resort OR it doesn't exist and spiritbending is the alternative as the capital punishment.
some people have mentioned that Aang's ability wasn't known by the general public, so that would debase my theory that Aang used it as aforementioned - however I'm having trouble buying that. Aang doesn't seem the type to acknowledge the precaution in hiding the fact. Not to mention Zuko himself might have been so concentrated (and desperate) on saving the Fire Nation that he didn't even humor hiding it from his people, despite the potential complications it promised being public knowledge (as demonstrated by Amon).
and I say this because I feel like Aang's decision to spiritbend - instead of kill - Ozai may have caused a heavy undercurrent of conflict in the bending vs. non-bending populace, which may even be treated as a consequential factor that lead to this inequality we see now in Republic City. I can't help but to treat spiritbending as some kind of inhumane and dangerous punishment, something that caused more harm than good. Am I being bias in suggesting that Aang shouldn't have spiritbent Ozai because he inadvertedly acknowledged the existence of a Bending Evil? I'm not positive on what I'm insinuating, but I can't shake the feeling: if Aang had killed Ozai, we may have avoided the creation of two evils (i.e., instead of a sole all-encompassing Human Evil, we now have a Non-Bending Evil and a Bending Evil). Someone blow holes in my theory pls.
I'll take a stab in the dark here and say that the death penalty doesn't exist in the Avatar-verse as a form of capital punishment, because crime such as we know doesn't exist. What I mean by that is that in our society we follow a general eye-for-an-eye justice system. In Avatar world, crime is so rare (or at least it was prior to Republic City) that the Avatar was usually Judge, Juror, and Executioner for the rare criminal that couldn't be handled by say the Firelord, or Earth King. Rather than an eye-for-an-eye, it's more of a restoration of balance. The Avatar doesn't act out of vengeance. Obviously, we know that previous Avatars had no qualms about doting out a "death penalty" in such instances. Following the 100 year war, I have every confidence in saying that Aang had no intention of ever taking away another person's bending. Right up until Yakone demonstrated his terrifying, mind-blowing, out of this world ability to bloodbend at will, and nearly killed Aang. He knew that spirit bending was older than dirt, from what the lion turtle said, and it was something he did not understand. Therefore, he wouldn't have used it unless desperate.
We can agree on one thing. Aang didn't have a sense of precaution and probably told the story of his battle against Ozai without any embellishment or lack of detail. However, I don't think his act of spirit bending revealed a latent evil in element bending. Perhaps it's my own bias, but bending itself isn't evil. It's the decision of the bender to use his abilities for evil that creates the problem. I.E not all benders are bad, and not all non-benders are good. Isn't Tarlok "evil" for using his powers of charm and persuasion for his self interests? Isn't Amon evil for imposing his will upon people with his powers? Although, the arguement could still be made that Aang's decisions led to Korra's turmoil, much like Avatar Roku's decisions led to Aang's plight. But it's not just because Aang didn't kill Ozai.
We could bring a lesson from Naruto to consider the other outcome; If Aang had killed Ozai what would have happened? Perhaps the war wouldn't have ended. The fire nation could have rejected Zuko's claim to power. He was a banished prince after all, and rebanished after he set out to join the avatar. The cycle of hatred would have continued. Uniting the world under one leadership in order to bring about peace isn't a unique idea. Ozai could have been replaced with a popular Zhao type general, while at the same time being elevated to martyrdom as the fire nation continued it's pursuit of conquering the world with renewed fervor.
#389
Posted 11 June 2012 - 06:34 AM
❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀
#390
Posted 11 June 2012 - 06:47 AM
Edited by merryGOflava, 11 June 2012 - 06:48 AM.
#392
Posted 11 June 2012 - 03:07 PM

Not at all, I'm tired of it too. The series is almost perfect, but the pairings really feel disposable for me. Episode 5 already annoying, but this week episode was the nail in the coffin. Some times I go lurking on tumblr for spoilers, but I also find some good points about the episodes that people post. I'm going to show here an post directly from tumblr that tells perfectly how I feel about the whole Korra Mako Asami deal.
#393
Posted 11 June 2012 - 03:19 PM
Wow, that took all of the words out of my mouth completely. When watching this stuff, it makes me grateful that the NaruSaku moments we get are far and between. Too much romance really takes away from the action. I really see why Oda especially doesn't put any in One Piece.
Check out my story, Chain Reaction: Iron Revolution here
#394
Posted 11 June 2012 - 07:43 PM
I was hoping someone would call me out on my blatant disregard for that "Team Avatar" display in EP08.
okay look, you and I both know it's solely up to the audience to respond to how the narrative is being presented. No matter how weak or strong the foundation for characterization is, it's up to the audience to decide if they like it or not, buy it or not. That said, your countering my statement tells me you've accepted what Bryke has given us, but I personally cannot.
when Bolin said "Team Avatar," I was confused. When Mako agreed, I was disappointed. When they all took off together to play vigilantes, I was like meh whatever. This is how they want me to believe that Korra's team exists? They decide that it's time to go "take down some equalists" and do it themselves, being self-appointed superheroes, with their own Avatarmobile?
give me a break. They were playing make-believe upon a foundation that's purely fantastical. I didn't feel what made them a team, I was just merely told that they were - which is probably the worst way to convince your audience of anything. From what I've seen so far, the characters by themselves lack the sufficient amount of believable conviction to be appropriately perceived as the new Team Avatar. They can't really be a team without first believing in what the team is there to do, what makes the team, and what it takes to make up each piece of it.
don't get me wrong, I love that they comforted Korra on her insecurities and the belief that she's a failure (she's not, but when the standards are set so high by the previous Avatar, she's allowed to think that) - but that was only then. They had NO idea she's been feeling this the whole time, and it was only because she outright TOLD them what she was feeling did they show support. If Bryke wanted me to believe that they actually had her back, that they've been there with her from the beginning (what makes Team Avatar) - if not, were truly aware of what Korra's going through - they would have built the foundation less on unresolved in-group conflict and more on lasting in-group progress.
I admit, sure, Mako and Bolin have shown sympathy but they just don't have the stake of the total conflict like Tenzin and Lin do. They're there for her, not for The Avatar (she wants to be the Avatar she's meant to be, and they need to realize this). For them to be an actual entity within the Team, they have to (Mako is showing a higher stake, I guess) recognize Korra as a bigger piece in the game, not just "their friend." That said, I'll give you friends - but when I said "alone" I meant in the bigger scheme of life, in her destiny, so I can't give you team. (hell, now that I think about it, Korra's more of a friend to them than they are to her - sucks)
oh and haha, sure I'll admit defeat and agree that Tenzin and Lin are there and help make up what Team Avatar should be. Tenzin, Lin, Korra (and Asami if she wasn't dating Mako) would make up Team Avatar, this time around. The probending bros need some serious work in character arcs - especially Bolin. If I were to compare their roles to those that are similiar, I'd say they're like what the airbabies are to Korra - there for Korra, just there and not for The Avatar, and for The Avatar's fight.
Team Avatar with adults (yeah I know, baaaw where's my peermance!) doesn't have that same umph, but I'll take what I can get, by this point.
So much truth in all you said. Korra and Asami are just too good

hm, well after watching EP09, Makorra isn't looking as COMPLETELY abysmal as it was prior to this ep, but it's not looking too hot either. It's tainted as long as Masami stays afloat, and that's bad news for an endgame romance. It'll taste ... wrong, you know?
regardless, Korrasami is truth and I shall dump pictures.
---
Now that you mention it, no one other than Tenzin (and probably the cast from series one) seemed to know about this technique. Aang seems to be a very forthcoming person and probably did tell the adults (Katara’s father/ the White Lotus gang) about this and it may have been them who deemed the subject too controversial to make public. But also keep in mind, I don't think Aang felt the need to say "We won! I defeated the fire lord. Oh, BTW I spirit-bended him if anyone even wants to know how I did it." Honestly, I don't think there was a need to explain how, people were probably okay with the fact that he was defeated and started the process of healing and rebuilding. If anyone other than those close to Aang found out it was probably simply through word of mouth if Ozai didn't have enough pride left to hide the fact that he was emasculated. I’ll have to go back and see if there are hints that anyone other than Tenzin and the Anti-Benders knew that sprit-bending existed.
---
Again, based on the fact that the general populace had no previous knowledge of spirit-bending I’m doubtful that the anti-bending movement came as a result of Aang’s decision to spirit-bend Ozai instead of killing him.
While I can see how spirit-bending could lead to greater unrest between benders and non-benders, I believe that it is only now adding fuel to the fire, as a tool for equality in the eyes of non-benders and as a reason to hate non-benders on the side of bender extremists. And though we didn’t see any hints of it in series one, I’m sure the superiority complex that the bad benders had, as well as the fear/hatred of said benders on the anti-bender side was already present. But the anti-benders probably pointed most of their attention and hatred towards the fire nation who seemed to impose their superiority on everything; they were busy fighting and being oppressed by a common enemy.
It is interesting to note though that while many of the prejudices that exist in our society came or come from something new, different or not frequently experienced, that the prejudice in the series comes from something that has always been. Throughout it's history, in all locations of the world, it seems there have always been benders and non-benders living together. For this reason I believe that the folks of the anti-bending sentiment were in the minority, and it was actually the war against the fire nation, compounded on top of all the previous wars and not the discovery of spirit-bending by Aang that spread the prejudice. This is further exacerbated now when Amon appears and gives it focus, a weapon and a means to spread. Even Amon mentions that they are going to spread from Republic city, so it seems that we’re more seeing a beginning to the movement with Amon preying on the fears of non-benders to increase his army than something that came to a fever-pitch as a result of Aang's spirit-bending.
There is so much to discuss on this topic. Especially since I just remembered that there seemed to be a district for non-benders. Was this something that was declared by the council? Were they forced to live in this area or is this just something that naturally happened? If it naturally happened, was it because of an anti-bender mentality? It’s the scene where non-benders are being round up after they turn off the power in one of the districts that houses non-benders.
On the subject of the severity of spirit-bending as compared to death… It is a difficult subject. The first thing I could think of that parallels such an act would be if a serial rapist was turned into a eunuch. You would take away the source of his ability to harm another through the means he has done so repeatedly but even then this is not a direct comparison to spirit-bending as nothing was done to Ozai’s physical body. The subject is as tough to discern the morales and ethics of the death penalty. Which begs the question: who has the right to do it? But it seems in the world of the Avatar, the Avatar is given carte blanche to be the judge. I’m surprised there isn’t a movement against the Avatar itself. I myself believe it was justified and was the best possible solution given the situation and short time to accomplish the defeat of the fire nation.
---
I don’t believe that Korra is alone, but I believe she has a smaller supporting cast and a foe that has no physical body nor clear path to defeating, but currently Aang’s friends were miles closer to one another than Korra is with team phoenix. She barely knows them and because of the baggage that comes with their age they’re less open with one another.
I do agree that Korra’s action for curing the prejudice should not be a physical one. And though it won’t be the main antagonist, there probably will be a physical nemesis that she has to Avatar state out of the way.
---
I am optimistic of this outcome as the writers of the show so far have never missed the mark, and I’d actually be glad if they took the second series to help Korra develop into the great person she’ll have to be in order to overcome prejudice. I’d be a little perplexed and agitated if her character growth was near completion by the first season’s end.
---
Lol. You got a lot of info out of my general last sentence there.

I’m a little confused by what you mean in Korra applying Amon’s values where needed. I think the general idea of Amon, that of change and equality, which he uses to mask his agenda of revenge and ignorant generalization of benders, is what Korra needs to administer not Amon’s specific idealisms, values or judgment.
---
I hadn’t even thought of Koh! I do believe if they went this route it wouldn’t be all that jarring. Especially in a linear plot format. We all know from season one that the Avatar has ties to the spiritual world. And they’d have a lot of next season to explore this concept. It may be more jarring if this were a lone series onto itself, but it has the backdrop of the first series and the established laws of the Avatar to allow for the spirit-world to play a role in the story. And since the society/time period is based off of a Chinese one, I don’t see it being so much of a stretch since spirituality is usually portrayed as being a part of Chinese culture.
---
LOL. I can’t tell if that was sarcasm as even without the blood-bending playing a role in it they’re already a bunch of loser in being a bunch of yes-men. So I wouldn’t put it passed them to be so terrified of Tarrlok’s blood-bending abilities that they decided to go with what he wants. Which begs the question… are these elected officials? Dear god, I hope they weren’t appointed by Aang. If so, bad Aang! Bad! You know what you did. But I agree. Tarrlok’s character would be diminished of he weren’t just partially right in everything that he said.
---
This could also work towards him going down the path of Zuko too… where he realizes he was wrong. This would help with the Avatar’s task of alleviating anti-bender sentiments. In cases of prejudice, the best way of winning is to get them to see that their extreme way of thinking is wrong and making an ally out of said enemy.
---
As far as shipping goes, I was actually hoping to have a strong female character that isn’t attached to any form of romance, girl or boy alike. I want it to pass the Bechdel test. And while I do think that Mako is an asshat I can understand his difficulty in deciding between the two. Korra for me anyday, but I can see Asami's allure. But I mean... COME ON! That's not fair! And while Mako's a jerk let's not forget that he grows up to voice uncle Iroh!



seismic sense is the detection of earth particles in metals, among other things, whereas lie-detection is Toph's ability and hers alone. In fact, it's completely unrelated to what seismic sense is supposed to do and it more correlates with Toph's special lifestyle - her knowing people lie is just an off-shoot plus to her "seeing". Being blind is a giant crutch on a fighter, so I don't really fault Bryke for instilling it in their character.
The only two people that MAY be able to learn this is Bumi and Lin - but like I previously mentioned, it wouldn't be a good idea for them to have it; they're too badass already. In more narrative terms, Lin wouldn't have not thought to use it when they were talking with that Equalist defector. If she had the ability, I'd put money on her definitely using it to see if whether or not the dude was lying.
She's the Chief of Police, she's naturally distrustful - if she had the means, she'd make sure her lead was legit before taking it. But in this case she couldn't, so she had no other choice than to follow the bad lead, however shady it seemed.
I like that you brought this up! She is still scared of him, she's terrified. And I'm so friggin glad they didn't forget this. EP04 would have been lost forever if she outright tried to fight him after she escaped that weird cabin (btw wtf Tarrlok, a creepy cabin in the woods woaaaah)
Can we be okay with having some complicated characters? Can Mako NOT be perfect? (Let's be honest, if he was we would have people crying 'GARY STU' rather than 'JERK'). I'm not saying we can't be like "Mako WHY ARE YOU DOING THAT" but calling him a bad character or anything like that seems a bit extreme.
Mako's just damned if he does and damned if he doesn't in this series. Cut the guy some slack.
I'd have to agree with you Fliss. I know I gave him flak for what he did in EP07 (which I disagree with being justified; I'll expand below why) but him reacting the way he did IS consistent with the foundation of his character - regardless of Asami being there or not. Idk what it is, but I think people are jumping on the bandwagon and forgetting just what they should be pretending to hate in the first place.
re: Mako in EP07
I gotta disagree with him having any justification for acting the way he did. For one, Korra is the goddamn Avatar (her business is bigger than him) and she, despite showing brash tendencies, learned from her mistake in EP05 - Mako completely disregarded that fact. He agreed to her request to stay friends but he showed no inclination that he did so, in EP07. He accused her of something that is born from his insecurity and took it out on Korra for doing her job.
He didn't believe her when she said it wasn't about ~them~ and he didn't give her the time of day to explain herself. I get that he has obligation to his girlfriend and her father, but he is also supposed to be Korra's friend. That's the key word here, and he wasn't an ounce close to it when he brought up their ~history against her for his own gain. In fact, he was so insecure, so scared that she was actually being a grown-up (something that he reasoned was a factor as to why he shouldn't be with her) that he jumped to fight against her. I sympathize with his fear, but he really had to grow-up himself, put aside feelings (like Korra did) and help her or at least do a better job of handling the situation. The way he did it was poor and disappointing and utterly inexcusable.
(but like you said, he's learning, which ultimately I'm glad for)
re: Mako in EP09
that brings me to his redeeming moment. I agree with you, fliss. People are damning him for something that shouldn't be surprising and/or demonized in the first place.
Mako has always shown tendencies to protect first, think later and the way he treated Korra being kidnapped was utterly him and frankly, I'll take it. I'm not apologizing for him being in the Masami-or-Makorra situation, but only upon what was happening right at that moment. His reaction, his anger, his desperation rang true to his "mama bear" side and I quite enjoyed seeing him display that much emotion.
The way he acted was purely to vent out his frustration and inability to protect something he needed to protect. I know people are damning him being so crazy, but what do you expect? Korra was kidnapped. If I were dating a dude but was freaking out about a friend of mine being possibly dead, I'd be losing all my kitten and more. I'm not sure why Bolin wasn't acting the way Mako was (didn't he "love" her?), to be honest. And Asami - she wasn't so bad as to be insecure in the wrong moment, and I'd be so disappointed if she confronted Mako on the way he was acting DURING the search. (She didn't, so that was perfect.) It's fine that she was insecure, and it was in the realm of belief (however I expected more from her too, regarding Korra). I feel so kittening bad for her though, and hopefully in EP10, she'll get a fair deal in the end of Masami.
overall, I'm in agreement with you. He's a flawed character and he's suffered from the lack of screentime because of some convoluted need of the creators for "drama." Frankly, people shouldn't be mad at Mako - they should be mad at what Masami represents and mad at Bryke for stirring kitten for no good reason.
I'll reply to some complaints justcuz.
re: Mako "loving" another while dating someone else
no, there's nothing wrong with this. You can't help who you love-like-lust no matter the situation you're in. Someone who isn't in control of their emotions 24/7 and is struggling to deal with an inner-conflict as old as time (brain vs. heart) shouldn't be demonized.
Mako is a sensible guy, he prefers things straight and narrow. He values security (this as the goal for his brother's well-being, first and foremost) and safety - a road that he knows how to navigate. This all makes sense - Asami represents this, he said it himself.
But then comes Korra. All kinds of scary, a bigger piece of something he can't comprehend (just yet) and a future that isn't mapped out in the confines of his comfort zone. She's chaos incarnate and he's afraid.
I know people "hate" him for not doing what's right, but I think he's so afraid that he can't find it in himself to take the leap. However as we've seen in EP09, his brain is losing the fight and he's starting to tunnel out what he feels through action alone.
I gotta step back from officially giving him kitten, and join back in the group that's hopeful he'll do what is right. Although I am hoping he gets seven levels of hell from Asami for doing that to her, despite his inability and difficulty to do what we all know is the right thing. It's his turn to learn his lesson, and I'm hoping it sticks with him when he does.
re: Mako's reunion with Asami / Mako's reunion with Korra
He's getting flak for kissing Asami in the former, but I don't see the point in making this out to be more than it is. He has reason to display his relief in being reunited with her and show her that he cares for her. They're d a t i n g. Despite him being the failure in not breaking up with her right away, he shouldn't completely ostracize her. I figure he has feelings for her still, however badly produced they are, so he has ground to act on them.
buuut that's about as far as my sympathy goes for him in the latter. Bro, your girlfriend is RIGHT THERE and you're brushing Korra's HAIR from her FACE. As I stated previously, he's acting on pure emotion right now, but goddamn he should restrain himself. I'm okay with him lifting her off Naga and away from the interrogation (Lin is at fault here, as sad am I to say, but it fits her character [gotta catch The Perp] so it's not as bad as it seems) but he should have really come back to Republic City, off Korra-Cloud-9 and been aware that he's still got to set his kitten straight before he gives Korra the lovins she (and he) wants.
sorta rant
re: Masami en général
I mentioned before that the romance is rocky as hell, and I'm disappointed that they didn't take another opportunity to redeem it in EP09. Bryke have damned themselves by inserting uneeded romantic-conflict (i.e., Masami) as a means to flesh out Mako and Asami.
They could have done this more effeciently without harming the rest of the overall romantic narration. Real talk, Masami is unequivocally a mistake. They could have presented Mako's feelings for Korra on a more personal level, completely untained by his motivation for a "more sensible" relationship than a "feels right" one: instead of having Masami and Makorra as the comparison factors, he could have used his character traits to decipher what to do. They could have had him reason on-screen that despite Korra representing what he shouldn't want, he can't help feeling selfish in actually wanting what he feels is right.
And Asami omg. She's bogged down by the trait of Mako's Girlfriend so badly her characterization is suffering to hell and back. She could have been presented in Team Avatar with a different stake, pro-bending perhaps, Bolin's fan-girl perhaps, an interest in the Avatar perhaps - something other than Mako as boyfriend material. It's childish and lame and completely shallow. I'd even take the cliche approach of her performing a Heel-Face-Turn, defecting from the Equalist, than being shipper fodder. I admit she has some characterization now, but that's all STILL being overshadowed by MC romantic-conflict.
These characters don't deserve the hate they're getting because of bad writing, and I hope Bryke knows they suck at this.
Hm, out of sight, out of mind then? I'd have to disagree, since I'm giving the Avatarverse more room to do what the shows themselves cannot present to it's target audience.
ATLA definitely could not have shown capital crimes and the corresponding capital punishment, they probably alluded to it (e.g., Jet's terrorism) but overall they did a bad job of presenting what they did. Also keep in mind that the warring nations weren't so much occupied with keeping peace within the confines of their own terrorities - they had the Fire Nation's rapid expansion, and thereafter invasion to worry about. If anything, the Fire Nation had already occupied the majority of the nations and were invoking their own punishment, unjustly (aside from the Earth Kingdom and the Dai Lee, but they were already corrupt prior to Azula's rule). However despite all this, I'm still giving ATLA the benefit of doubt, and allowing it the background room to imply that capital punishment existed (if anything, outside the Fire Nation's influence, before the Fire Nation's expansion and following the defeat of Ozai sans the public knowledge that the Avatar has a new toy). It's realistic, something that, I admit ATLA is less obvious about, but it kind of comes with the package of a universe that reflects reality.
That said, we can only utilize what we have - the time post-war to decide from, and Republic City is it (which has a Council, police-force, and gangs). Thus LoK is probably the thing we can use to decipher the presence of a death penality or not, and I since it reflects more closely to our reality, I firmly believe it exists still. I mean there was even a trial for Yakone - they needed proof, and waited appropriately before passing judgment. It's quite accurate to what we have irl, and the death penalty would fit just fine.
And I also disagree with Aang's penchant for spiritbending. I'm basing my stance solely on how Aang approached his decision to spiritbend Yakone, which is just enough for me. Aang reacted swiftly by going after Yakone, stopping him from leaving and defending himself from being killed - however, he was too brash in taking away Yakone's bending. He's the Avatar - he should have taken precaution (i.e., Sifu Katara) to learn how to counteract bloodbending. Also he'd already subdued him in earth, why take away his bending? If not that, why not have chi-blockers on hand if things got rough in the trial? Yakone showed signs of preemptively escaping - why not prepare? The Gaang handled this poorly, and I'm disappointed in how they resolved this conflict.
Again, I'm not stating that it was solely because of Aang spiritbending that Korra has this mess, I meant that it was just a very important part of the broken foundation that makes up the conflict.
Look, you're saying that there are two sides of two coins - benders (good/bad); non-bender (good/bad). But where/when exactly did that separation start corresponding with different punishments? What I meant was to analyze the overall ramifications of Aang introducing such a punishment unto the Avatarverse itself, which helped lead to these two coins being acknowledged from one - and thereafter criticize the need for it (if there even is).
Before spiritbending, a punishment meant solely for benders, we had the death penalty. It encompassed all evil, under the same judgment - death. Be you a bender or a non-bender, if you f**cked up bad enough, you got capital punishment (something that in no way differentiated the bender from non-bender; everyone was treated equally). But after it was introduced, applied to the appropriate evil and became public knowledge it was understood solely for evil benders - non-benders were taken out of the mix because it did not apply to them, and thus had no say.
They lost their voice, regardless of them being victims. We see it now in the Council, and as Amon runs around dishing out his own judgment. There is no clear cut representation. Hell, Amon might as well be the Anti-Avatar the way he's utilizing such a dangerous power (which partially is my point in the need for it)
Also, now that I think about it how exactly do non-benders feel about spiritbending? Perhaps I'm overstepping myself, but by spiritbending someone into an non-bending individual, is the bending community implying that living life as a non-bender is punishment in of itself? I don't know, it's like Chou mentioned; the severity of spiritbending is quite controversial and it seems impossible to just say it's good or bad and be done with it. It all depends on how you feel about spiritbending itself and your stance in the overall picture - which we can't have considering we don't "live" in the Avatarverse; we don't know what it's like.
may I ask exactly why wouldn't the war have ended if Ozai had been killed? It stops Ozai all the same.
Personally I think keeping Ozai in a cage, locked up stripped of his bending, is worse than keeping him alive. The state of Ozai, the implications of being locked away in the Palace, forcing him to live a life he'd probably view as the weakest form of existance - is no mercy, and may even be taken as something worse than death by Ozai sympathizers. Also if I were an Ozai apologist, who has been fed a mind-set that my firebending blood is my life, I'd sure as hell be ready to revolt after hearing that my leader was being held in a cage like a beaten animal, with his firebending ripped from him instead of given death like any other person would expect.
I'd tell my racist friends, they would tell their own friends and so on and so forth until we have a bonifide group of Ozai resurgents. Zuko has his hands full already, and a revolt of that magnitude is the last thing he needs. Death would have some finality to it, and if Ozai still lives so does an embodiment of traditional blood-soaked hope for redemption - Ozai being alive is more of an incentive than if he were dead.
Also the Fire Nation has no choice. They can't reject a monarchy, and I doubt they would be able to outright deny Zuko's claim to the throne. He's next in line, it's his birthright - the Fire Nation values this more than anything else. Also I mentioned a revolt - any kind of revolt would come after Zuko takes the throne (just the severity of it is inconclusive). There will always be those who held The Royal Family in high-esteem, and Zuko is the very first to rule against strong traditions, instilling a regime that will cause some people to react negatively - but he's still royalty.
I'm just saying, it'd be impossible to replace royalty, when all this time they've had no problem with the monarch in the first place. The line of succession is irrevocable, and just because the current is taking a different turn on things doesn't mean the whole Fire Nation would want to destroy a tradition that has been set in stone, in their history, for generations. The only problem I see that would cause unrest following the War is the fact that Ozai was taken out of the picture, and not the fact that now his son is.
Edited by krisk, 11 June 2012 - 08:05 PM.
#395
Posted 11 June 2012 - 08:00 PM
Sadly I have not had a chance yet to catch up on the goodness that is the last two episodes, but I am loving how much the interwebz is all in favour of KorrAsami

#396
Posted 11 June 2012 - 10:33 PM
BRILLIANT post krisk. I know I've said it before, but it's always a joy to read what you have to write. Even when I don't agree with you on something at first, you always manage to persuade me by the end of it all.
❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀❀
#397
Posted 11 June 2012 - 10:55 PM
okay look, you and I both know it's solely up to the audience to respond to how the narrative is being presented. No matter how weak or strong the foundation for characterization is, it's up to the audience to decide if they like it or not, buy it or not. That said, your countering my statement tells me you've accepted what Bryke has given us, but I personally cannot.
when Bolin said "Team Avatar," I was confused. When Mako agreed, I was disappointed. When they all took off together to play vigilantes, I was like meh whatever. This is how they want me to believe that Korra's team exists? They decide that it's time to go "take down some equalists" and do it themselves, being self-appointed superheroes, with their own Avatarmobile?
give me a break. They were playing make-believe upon a foundation that's purely fantastical. I didn't feel what made them a team, I was just merely told that they were - which is probably the worst way to convince your audience of anything. From what I've seen so far, the characters by themselves lack the sufficient amount of believable conviction to be appropriately perceived as the new Team Avatar. They can't really be a team without first believing in what the team is there to do, what makes the team, and what it takes to make up each piece of it.
don't get me wrong, I love that they comforted Korra on her insecurities and the belief that she's a failure (she's not, but when the standards are set so high by the previous Avatar, she's allowed to think that) - but that was only then. They had NO idea she's been feeling this the whole time, and it was only because she outright TOLD them what she was feeling did they show support. If Bryke wanted me to believe that they actually had her back, that they've been there with her from the beginning (what makes Team Avatar) - if not, were truly aware of what Korra's going through - they would have built the foundation less on unresolved in-group conflict and more on lasting in-group progress.
I admit, sure, Mako and Bolin have shown sympathy but they just don't have the stake of the total conflict like Tenzin and Lin do. They're there for her, not for The Avatar (she wants to be the Avatar she's meant to be, and they need to realize this). For them to be an actual entity within the Team, they have to (Mako is showing a higher stake, I guess) recognize Korra as a bigger piece in the game, not just "their friend." That said, I'll give you friends - but when I said "alone" I meant in the bigger scheme of life, in her destiny, so I can't give you team. (hell, now that I think about it, Korra's more of a friend to them than they are to her - sucks)
oh and haha, sure I'll admit defeat and agree that Tenzin and Lin are there and help make up what Team Avatar should be. Tenzin, Lin, Korra (and Asami if she wasn't dating Mako) would make up Team Avatar, this time around. The probending bros need some serious work in character arcs - especially Bolin. If I were to compare their roles to those that are similiar, I'd say they're like what the airbabies are to Korra - there for Korra, just there and not for The Avatar, and for The Avatar's fight.
Team Avatar with adults (yeah I know, baaaw where's my peermance!) doesn't have that same umph, but I'll take what I can get, by this point.
hm, well after watching EP09, Makorra isn't looking as COMPLETELY abysmal as it was prior to this ep, but it's not looking too hot either. It's tainted as long as Masami stays afloat, and that's bad news for an endgame romance. It'll taste ... wrong, you know?
regardless, Korrasami is truth and I shall dump pictures.
I know the feeling you refer to when you say that we're being told to accept them, rather than feeling it out ourselves. But I didn't get that when I watched Ep9. I thought it was nostalgic in the way that they dubbed themselves the "New Team Avatar" referring to ATLA, and quite frankly I was relieved to finally see them rallying to Korra's side. As you said before, ATLA was a deep story that built over time, and I just don't think they have had enough time together as a unit. Although their teamwork under Asami's guidance was pretty good when they were chasing down the chi blockers.
I think the rationalization that they think of Korra first as a friend, and only second as the avatar comes from the fact that she hasn't made much progression in becoming a self realized avatar. So far, she's just a multi-bender, not the link between the spirit world and the physical, so that's how they perceive her.
Personally I think keeping Ozai in a cage, locked up stripped of his bending, is worse than keeping him alive. The state of Ozai, the implications of being locked away in the Palace, forcing him to live a life he'd probably view as the weakest form of existance - is no mercy, and may even be taken as something worse than death by Ozai sympathizers. Also if I were an Ozai apologist, who has been fed a mind-set that my firebending blood is my life, I'd sure as hell be ready to revolt after hearing that my leader was being held in a cage like a beaten animal, with his firebending ripped from him instead of given death like any other person would expect.
I'd tell my racist friends, they would tell their own friends and so on and so forth until we have a bonifide group of Ozai resurgents. Zuko has his hands full already, and a revolt of that magnitude is the last thing he needs. Death would have some finality to it, and if Ozai still lives so does an embodiment of traditional blood-soaked hope for redemption - Ozai being alive is more of an incentive than if he were dead.
Also the Fire Nation has no choice. They can't reject a monarchy, and I doubt they would be able to outright deny Zuko's claim to the throne. He's next in line, it's his birthright - the Fire Nation values this more than anything else. Also I mentioned a revolt - any kind of revolt would come after Zuko takes the throne (just the severity of it is inconclusive). There will always be those who held The Royal Family in high-esteem, and Zuko is the very first to rule against strong traditions, instilling a regime that will cause some people to react negatively - but he's still royalty.
I'm just saying, it'd be impossible to replace royalty, when all this time they've had no problem with the monarch in the first place. The line of succession is irrevocable, and just because the current is taking a different turn on things doesn't mean the whole Fire Nation would want to destroy a tradition that has been set in stone, in their history, for generations. The only problem I see that would cause unrest following the War is the fact that Ozai was taken out of the picture, and not the fact that now his son is.
TBH it was just a hypothetical plot line. I didn't really consider that Ozai supporters would think his punishment was worse than if he had been killed, but you're right it probably was.
But as for Zuko's birthright? How do you know the Fire Nation values the line of succession more than anything? Iroh was treated with respect, but he was never "the King that should have been" from anyone's POV. Anyway, I didn't mean Ozai could be replaced as a monarch but as a military leader pursuing a righteous goal with a clenched fist. His hypothetical replacement wouldn't come from a perceived problem with the monarchy but a collective agreement that his was the right course.
#398
Posted 12 June 2012 - 12:28 AM
Ok, that might not have been the best wording for this points, but I still agree with some core elements.
You are right, the show isn't trying to makes us empathize with Korra, it's trying to make us empathize with Makorra, aways pushing toward an pairing that on a moral point of view, it's very wrong. It might be subtle, but it's still there. And man, I absolutelly disagree, the show was trying to make the audience "squee" when Mako carried Korra away and carassed her face, that was obviously supposed to look romantic, just ask anyone, they would agree. I dare to say the whole freaking episode Mako was acting as an protective lover who was separated from his girl, I'm afraid he wouldn't get that mad if this happened to Asami. I understand that he gets worried, I understand that he gets mad, but what really annoy me is how seems so... possesive of Korra, I don't know, I get a really weird vibe when Mako is thinking about Korra in this episode, I think he wasn't this mad when Bolin got captured, and the guy is his only family left. At that time Mako at least managed to keep some of his cool during the pursuit for his brother.
You said that person was disregarding Mako feelings for Korra, but you are also disregarding that these said feelings are beseless and without origin, they were literally created out of thin air in episode 5 for the sake to further the romantic drama between the characters. Untill episode 4 Mako only saw Korra as an friend and nothing else, only to drastically change that a episode later, so I think his reaction to Korra being kidnapped is NOT justified, it's exagerated.
I'm not sure what kind of protection you mean, because to me, Asami is in more in need of support then protection at this point. And those two are different as far as I know.
Ok, you got that one right, indeed Asami gave up of a lot of thinks because of what she believed, and not because of Mako, I totally agree, her character goes beyond that.
#399
Posted 12 June 2012 - 02:20 AM
one side for: asami goes evil from jealousy
another side for:.....asami just takes it........
or or...lets make it interesting! maybe she gets bolin to make mako jealous!! i mean if korra can kiss mako while hes still dating asami i dont see why she cant fight back.
#400
Posted 12 June 2012 - 12:37 PM
one side for: asami goes evil from jealousy
another side for:.....asami just takes it........
or or...lets make it interesting! maybe she gets bolin to make mako jealous!! i mean if korra can kiss mako while hes still dating asami i dont see why she cant fight back.

Never thought of that before, after all this drama - why not. Well, I'm all for Bosami anyway.

ナルサク
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users