749 replies to this topic

[rocci]

@touken
Well, I always feel like it just waste potential, but yeah I agree with you.

Lol. The clan disappear from earth. This's the clan that suppose to have "strong body" and win the "war". It's like a plot hole.

[TouKen4Life3g]

@touken
Well, I always feel like it just waste potential, but yeah I agree with you.

Lol. The clan disappear from earth. This's the clan that suppose to have "strong body" and win the "war". It's like a plot hole.

I don't blame them. I mean once they hear about Uchiha discovery of love, they couldn't handle anymore bs.

[rocci]

I don't blame them. I mean once they hear about Uchiha discovery of love, they couldn't handle anymore bs.

What about uzumaki? We barely know them and only sasuke who got the latest info about it.
At least hyuga become a god lol.

But yeah, where's senju clan? Don't tell me it finished with tsunade.
And why I don't see other child of other clan.
Do they only have one child per clan? I mean we never see shikamaru cousin or something like that? Just like the rest of senju clan.

[Namikaze Clan]

Statement: Kabuto has said that Uzumaki have red hair, thus making Karin as one. In hindsight, it's practically meaningless and asspull.

Agree or disagree?

Disagree. There was nothing wrong with Karin being an Uzumaki. Sure it was a missed opportunity since she and Naruto were related, but nothing bad came from it as well. Even if it was pointless it was still some interesting backstory on Karin's family history.

[TouKen4Life3g]

What about uzumaki? We barely know them and only sasuke who got the latest info about it.
At least hyuga become a god lol.

But yeah, where's senju clan? Don't tell me it finished with tsunade.
And why I don't see other child of other clan.
Do they only have one child per clan? I mean we never see shikamaru cousin or something like that? Just like the rest of senju clan.

I don't know. They only there to give plot device without being alive. Not dying after extraction, mask to bring back the dead from a seal, etc.

 

I guess it did. No one gives a damn to Senju. If they die, they die.

 

 

The clan system wasn't explored enough.

[catsi563]

Disagree with it being an asspull but agreed about it being meaningless.

 

As an uzumaki karin was in a unique position to end the manga with Sasuke as a bridge to end the uchiha senju rivalry via the uzumaki bloodline.

 

but as with all things the last and th ending rendered it meaningless

[Nate River]

Statement: Kabuto has said that Uzumaki have red hair, thus making Karin as one. In hindsight, it's practically meaningless and asspull.

Agree or disagree?

Disagree with it being an asspull as it doesn't do any damage to established canon and given the stories beginning any of Naruto's extended family was going to come from the blue to at least some degree.

Agree that it was meaningless. No idea why she was made one as it had no impact on any character in the story. Naruto never meets her and nothing about it has any sway on Sasuke. He just notes it and then it dies. It's probably a dropped plot thread where he may have wanted to do something with it only to abandon it because it wouldn't work or wouldn't do anything for the story.

[Namikaze Clan]

With Gaara, I just dont understand how two brunettes could have a red and blonde haired child?

[Advaith]

Statement: Kabuto has said that Uzumaki have red hair, thus making Karin as one. In hindsight, it's practically meaningless and asspull.

Agree or disagree?

Disagree

 

Nate River has explained everything well.

[rocci]

@nate river
They met in iron country after sasuke fiasco, but they don't interact.

Atleast it's better than suddenly sakura & Karin are friend or in the last she's best friend with Hinata because we said so.

Edited by rocci, 08 March 2016 - 03:20 AM.

[TouKen4Life3g]

I guess I can't call it an asspull, though perhaps I'm being generous. I say asspull because it felt like a reason just to have Karin do something extraordinary. I mean it ended up being a chain as well, so yeah. Wonder how she knows what to do.

Oh well, another wasted potential. So agree in certain extent.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Statement: Sakura's role Kage Summit Arc should have never happen at all. Arguably the final nail to the coffin.

Agree or disagree?

[Yyubie]

Statement: Sakura's role Kage Summit Arc should have never happen at all. Arguably the final nail to the coffin.

Agree or disagree?

Disagree .

 

In my opinion this arc show that she rather kill sasuke and be hated forever by naruto rather than let him lived and keep naruto suffer. But sadly many people misunderstood her action and said she playing with naruto feelings and killed sasuke because she loved him soo much she cannot bear to see him keep doing criminal things.

 

In my opinion the death nail for her character happen when the fodder ninja confess and give her a love letter and the image of sasuke appear in her mind. If its not there then and the double kill when she begging and desperately confess before naruto vs sasuke fight at the end.

[rocci]

@yubei
Actually it's both. She want to kill sasuke because she love him and to make sure that naruto live and take the hate to her.

Sakura love sasuke is not the problem, so I personally don't think the fodder ninja and her begging in naruto vs sasuke are problem.

The true problem happen when no naruto movement and or interaction that will lead to no naruto confession. In war arc there are no meaningful NS interaction as if kishi seperate naruto & sakura.

[VanitasDS76491]

Statement: Sakura's role Kage Summit Arc should have never happen at all. Arguably the final nail to the coffin.

Agree or disagree?

 

Disagree cause she was willing to kill Sasuke and knew the threat he posed and knew what was important Naruto and saving the world, and if she had gotten over the stupid crush and killed sasuke it would be fine.

 

I read a fanfic where she does kill Sasuke and Naruto hates her and she says she'd do it again and that's how that event should have gone. 
 

[Namikaze Clan]

To this day I still have no idea what to make of the Summit arc.

[Yyubie]

@yubei
Actually it's both. She want to kill sasuke because she love him and to make sure that naruto live and take the hate to her.

Sakura love sasuke is not the problem, so I personally don't think the fodder ninja and her begging in naruto vs sasuke are problem.

The true problem happen when no naruto movement and or interaction that will lead to no naruto confession. In war arc there are no meaningful NS interaction as if kishi seperate naruto & sakura.

She didn't love him, its just an obsession or false/fake loves, she just need someone to wake her up from that toxic feelings. You do not kill the person you love, just the fact that the intention of killing him cross her mind is bad enough.

[rocci]

She didn't love him, its just an obsession or false/fake loves, she just need someone to wake her up from that toxic feelings. You do not kill the person you love, just the fact that the intention of killing him cross her mind is bad enough.

It's love, whether it's a positive or not.

[Nostradamus]

It's love, whether it's a positive or not.

No it isn't.

[rocci]

No it isn't.

Yes, it's. Sakura romantically love sasuke. It's what make the love triangle happen in the first place.

Even if it degrading her character, it's still love.