To your rhetorical question (I take it): 'how come she knows about Naruto's feelings and still loves Sasuke' there's only one answer.
Where's the proof? As I already mentioned, in 539 she says that she already likes someone. Some people (including me) were sure about it being Naruto. That was WRONG. But, she is NOT sad or depressed in 539 and she also answers that stranger WITHOUT HESITATION. Only in 540 she STARTS thinking of Sasuke, AT ALL. The proof is the fact that her state of mind CHANGES INSTANTLY AFTER THAT STRANGER SAYS THOSE PAINFUL THINGS and she has a horrible picture of Sasuke in mind.
In short: 539 > main goal shaking the stranger off (she's surprised and doesn't give Sasuke OR Naruto any thought). 540 > She immediately SUFFERS from what she and that stranger (referring to Sasuke with 'Great Guy') BLURTED OUT.
Her expression conveys the feeling as if she were shackled by a thousand chains at once, not being able to move.
That stranger is NEUTRAL, he's not Naruto (confession, promise blablabla) BUT he reminds Sakura how painful it is to get rejected, knowing there's someone else your dear person likes, this only enhances Sakura's guilty conscience since Naruto's been in this situation for a long time.
MAIN PROOF: look at the panel where Sakura says: Thank you..but there's someone else I....(chapter 539 page 17)
She's smiling there. So that stranger KEEPS TALKING right after chapter 539 and leaves shortly after poking around in her already painful memories, FORCING her to associate Sasuke with a flame in the background.
That's definitely not the flame of LOVE lol
Last argument: Why should Naruto cross her mind if Sasuke (even if she doesn't love him anymore) is actually the one in DANGER. Naruto has a whole Nation supporting him, that tries to keep him OUT OF BATTLES. Sasuke on the other hand is EAGER to show his strength and eradicate everyone.
Maybe she only thinks of him as a past love in 540.
It's true there is no obvious proof of it, because it's not litteraly said or else, but come on, how can it be more obvious that she still loves Sasuke ?
I want to see Naruto and her together as much as you, but we can't be fooled here. Someone declared to her, and told her the man she loves must be awesome. And then, she thinks about Sasuke with as terribly sad face. It's telling us that she still loves him, and that she's ashamed of it, and that it makes her terribly sad.
To me, it can be two things :
1/ she will always love him no matter what, and wait until he returns to Konoha (it will happen in a way, he will be redeemed in a way i'm sure of it)
2/ she will realise Sasuke was never the one she wanted (I don't know when, maybe soon), and realise it's Naruto her soulmate. (I truly still thinks it's what Kishimoto is telling us)
Sakura's situation now, makes me think that she's actually through more character evolution.
By the way I just joined the forums for the first time after being an avid reader and fellow individual interested in Narusaku.
Welcome. I kind of agree with you ^^ it seems she's still growing. It's just, i thought she wasn't in love with Sasuke anymore. That's what disappointing me. Naruto was right, she was lying to herself, indeed about Sasuke. About Naruto, i think everything she told him is the truth, we all saw she was feeling that way around Naruto. But maybe... maybe what she told him was what she wanted to feel, and not really the truth. But it's not a lie either. It's something else. I've always though she's a big mess. It's like that since the very beginning. She would have stayed alone without Ino.
Just like Otaru wrote in the 'What if we lose?' thread: 'lol i think if narusaku actually doesn't happen, i think i would go back to school to learn again how to analyse a text or a story LOL' <<<I totally agree, I'm also confident in my skills and if it doesn't turn out as I expect, then I should reconsider my decision to study a language or two after graduating. The pages mentioned below are my absolutely favorite ones. If the quality of the irony Kishimoto created there SLUMPS DOWN (due to NaruHina

Now compare panel 1+3(!!!) on this page>>>>
http://www.mangafox....52/c484/16.html
with panel 1+3(!!!) on this page>>>>
http://www.mangafox....53/c501/13.html
AND adjust the picture SO THAT Minato's and Naruto's figures practically OVERLAP. Open two tabs and switch from one to the other as fast as you can


Watch carefully and tell my what you see. I see a bright future for NaruSaku. Naruto and Sakura are drawn bigger than Minato/Kushina, they have practically GROWN INTO THEIR FATE.
This overlapping issue is something that reminds me of !!!Resonance/Mesomerism!!!, which exists mostly in organic chemistry and is based on 'delocalized electrons'.
You also try to imagine an overlapping of two or more mesomeric 'lewis structures' to get a better understanding of REALITY (or you use more complicated scientific models...I absolutely HATE chemistry).
The saying 'The chemistry is right.' fits well in this context.
My point should be clear by now, just keep an eye on Minato's and Naruto's/Kushina's and Sakura's postures and Sakura's and Kushina's facial expressions and you are gonna see REALITY and NOT NaruHina

There's yet to be found a comparably EPIC scene with NaruHina hahaha
Well thank you for quoting me lol ^^ you remembered well ! And yeah about this, its really too BIG for a resonance !
It funny cause it seems like all the SS fans and NH fans are together vs us. Its like they just want to see us lose, it's shameful that would rather see us lose the, them actually win. Whatever I like those odds haha.
Although someone did mention that this is shonen, so their might not be any pairings or just illusions to pairings.
I don't think so. It's true it's a shônen, but Kishi wrote about romance before. And it seems he wants to talk about generations, parents, children... it's obvious there will be couples, at least Naruto will get a girl.
dont lower you tail and go away sulking, and if you know she is worth of your love stick to her and show her how much you are a good guy to be with, no nicy nicy but strong firm guy that has his opinions and goals in his life. I think naruto has that and has shown that to sakura many times, she must come to terms of that. This also shows that Kishimoto will not let go of her love for Sasuke without milking ss pairing to the end to keep ratings up, on the other hand if she would to stop loving him emidiately than everyone would be saying oh she is really ficle as the autumn sky she transfered so easily to Naruto, she is a b****. And really in my inner thoughts it wouldev bugged me all the time, was she really in love with Naruto, or she just transfered from sasuke to naruto when there was no hope left for her and sasuke, cause naruto was a nice guy, bringing her safety etc.
If we look in real life when we see onesided crush where one side that was hurted and rejected goes to other party that is safe, and marries that guy, but always fantasys about that cool guy, and wondering what could be if she was with him. We would not want that Sakura to be with Naruto, cause the Naruto would always be her second choice, that is so wrong. It is nice that Kishi is showing how sakura is little by little growing out of love for sasuke, only to fully accept narutos love, and naruto as a person, who is so much better than sasuke. If sakura were to end with sasuke, i wouldnt think that she is great and smart and strong character that i think now of her, the best manga heroin in my opinion, than she would be just shallow and stereotypical.
On the other hand we see on that panel that she is realising bit by bit how this Sasuke is not the old sasuke, but she still loves him, but she knows it is wrong to be in love with that kind of guy, she strugles, and as many people said she tranfered from girl who is defending sasuke to a girl who understands he is a bad guy, that is great for narusaku development. She still isnt fully aware about her love for naruto. You cant judge her, cause many women who are beaten by their boyfriends of even they have been tried to be murdered, they still think they can help that guy, many sad marriages end up like that, where girl is thinking she can save the guy, and in the end that all ends up in tragedy.
Only when others around are hurt (children) than that person understands that she must move and grow out of that (i think naruto in lifethreatning situation will bring her to those terms)and go away from that guy, to finally realise, is her love really love or infatuation, or attachment to what person was once or completely brainwashed by the guy so she thinks he is all there is, and she must love him until they both die, like faraon would carry his young wifes in tomb to die with him. But as we all remember kishi depicting sakura as strong and determined girl so that also means she is strong in her decisions,strong in thinking who she loves otherwise she would be weak if she should sudennly transfer to naruto without SHE HERSELF realising that she really loves naruto. If her love for Sasuke was this strong and ongoing over nothing, than you could imagine how stronger her love will be for naruto when she realises it. Than nothing could happen that could shatter that kind of strong love, that is based on real situation and friendship, selfsacrificing etc.
So i think this is a buildup that Kishi is making, so called "great love" from sakura to sasuke only to be replaced by stronger love,real love for Naruto. And the moment when sakura will realise how much she loves naruto will be the moment he is about to die,(something similar to ova) or she will think he is dead, then she will realise in full how much she loves him, and who was with her all the time, not just saying those words like she said in conffesion but fully realising and understanding them in her heart cause she realised it in her mind already like shown in conffesion but not in heart yet, you dont know what you have until you loose it, maybe that will be a point where she will be more heroin like and do something about her real love naruto and really help him and save him. Problem she doesnt realises it yet is her overconfidence in naruto, she will have to see naruto is wonruble, and needs her, heck that was what drawn her so fanatically to sasuke.
If she would to transfer from sasuke to naruto so suddenly then she would be weak character but she is not, Kishi is simply trying his best to show her growth from sasukes love to naruto. Cause sakura has a curse of being heroin and main character and she must live up to that, and that is not giving up on her love for sasuke, (she would be like those women that make peace with second best choice and when first obstacle appears quits) only greater love can replace that old love, and i think sakura will realise that greater love and friendship is and always has been between her and naruto. She is happy with naruto, she is herself around him, around sasuke she is fake and artificiall fangirling. If sasuke were to come home and she was with him, she would not be free person she is around naruto, she would be in the shadow of the strong person, not allowing her to develop as a person in full.
It is funny we debated not long ago how it is cliche in american movies but it may come to that, when main characters have a quarrel , or one end up being nearly dead, the other character finds out in his/her heart how much he/she cares for that person, and how he/she was stupid to be in love with cool person how much that love was shallow and how now she realises true love and her fellings. Remember how Sakura, when naruto was fighting never was afraid for his safety she had full confidence in his abilities, what if that confidence was taken away, and she was brought up to real circumstances where naruto cant save her or everybody now, and that everything will not be fine,(you came back and saved eveyone, you always come when most needed = that is her thinking of naruto) i thing that kind of her image of naruto has to be shattered, for the sake of her growth. I remember myself when i was dumped by girl, i wanted her back so badly, i knew she was no good for me, i would repeat that sentence to myself over and over again "im better without her, shes no good for me", but i didnt really belived that, it was what i told everyone else, and my thoughts were just for me. I was in pain, only when i snapped out of it, i realised how lucky i was that i didnt end up with that girl cause we had nothing incommon, and only had pain in that relationship. You can see similarity with sakura and sasuke, my experience tells me it will be NaruSaku.
So i am still giving time to sakura to realise the fact she truly loves naruto, not only in mind. I didnt think it would come to this, but it makes sense, cause you cant beat novel type of romances with realism or how it is done in real life (you grow out of love when you see your shallow reasons for being in love, or shallownes of that person or how that person is bad for you) you must beat it with bigger type of story and bigger type of romantic plot, that makes sense.
NaruSaku was buried so many times before, but when Kishimoto smashes SS they will not know what hit them. Kishimoto knows he must put up ratings, he gets the money from the manga he will not abandon other fandoms because of us or his pairing that he is building. But in the end he will smash SS and he will smash them greatly, but it will be in the end of manga when ratings cant sink down, cause it doesnt matter. He is subtle with narusaku, and he is building it from inside slowly how real love and friendship should look like, so in the end ss will wonder how the heck narusaku happened cause "there were no clues" and they will say he is bad writter, but we will know all the fondness and growth naruto and sakura had for each other throughout the series.
About Sakura, i still think "her body says yes before her brain". It's just like Kushina, but it's more complicated. She need to notice Naruto is her soulmate, but she also need to forget Sasuke. She thought he was the one for so long... it's sad for her, i understand her i've been through this too... loving a guy that made me suffer. He cheated on me, and he just wanted to use me but never loved me.
I wasn't happy, but i was devastated thinking he could abandon me. When i think about it know, it weird, i would never do it again. But i was 17. Sakura is still young. It's hard to know, to be really wise at this age. She's really sharp and smart, but sentimental things are different to deal with.
when he was writing Kushina and Minato he said was influenced by his family and dedicated chapter to his wife.
its in one of the manga volumes when Naruto meets his mother.
i fail to see how Hinata has this automatic bonus when shes, doubtful, timid, and the shy personailty its considered a character flaw. plus her confession was selfish. she never saved him just made Narutos situation worse. he could have died.
while Sakura is strong-willed, courageous and determined girl.
I read that his wife helped him to write the romance plot between Minato and Kushina.
I find Hinata more and more courageous. Naruto changed her. She's not like Sakura at all, but she's growing too.
And come on... it's true she said her confession was selfish, and i think too it made the situation worse, but it was great of her, and it wasn't selfish in a way because she risked her life for Naruto.
And hasn't Sakura been compared to Kishi's wife?
If he's drawing inspiration from his family and friends, well...

Also consider the fact that his wife helped him with Kushina's story a lot, so we know the kind of romance that she supports.
Not only that, but look at all of the other canon relationships so far in the series -> MinaKushi, DanTsu, JiraTsu (don't know if you can actually count this one, but it was definitely heavily implied), AsumaKurenai, Shikaku and Yoshino (is that her name??).
He definitely seems to like romantic relationships where the woman is strong and feisty, not submissive, and where the guy is completely devoted to the woman in turn.
The only exception was AsumaKurenai, and that's only because we never even really got to see them together as a couple.
Just some food for thought.
I totally agree with that !
Some of you guys are being really pessimistic about this whole thing. It's best to just relax and stay calm about it and to just watch and wait to see where the manga is heading from now on. There's bound to be more moments in the future.
That's my two cents, even though most of it has already been mentioned.
Agree too ^^ I mean, since the manga isn't over, Sakura still can change her mind !

That would be interesting to know... we already know that his wife help him in the process, but we don't know if his wife is just like Kushina. It's not the same ^^
Where did you see that Kishi made Naruto like himself ? I've never saw that. Thank you =)
PS : About Sakura smiling at the love letter guy : Come on guys, let's face it, she's not smiling here. She just answered and she didn't change her facial expression. I thought she was on Naruto here. I was wrong.
About me... meh... I don't understand Kishi anymore.
If Sakura really still love Sasuke, and love Naruto as a friend, then what was the purpose of Yamato's sentence with the big emphasis on it ?
Just to keep fandom alive ?
The truth is, Kishi is actually placing everything so that every couple could match. Naruto like Hinata a lot, and he obviously have been deeply touched by what she's done for him. It's pretty possible he fall for her in the future.
Sakura still loves Sasuke. Sasuke will obviously be saved by Naruto, and he will be redeemed in a way, so maybe he and Sakura could be together after that with a secret Kishi twist plot.
Sakura seems to love Naruto, but she's not so sure. She's lost in her feelings. She could one day realise that Naruto is her soulmate.
Hinata still loves Naruto. Maybe she will realise that it's more admiration than love. Or maybe she will realise Naruto loves Sakura and let them be.
Everything is still very plausible...
Kishi is playing.
Edited by Otaru, 28 May 2011 - 12:23 AM.