Even after all that has happened, many people still consider NS impossible and never actually capable of happening. If anything is important to remember about the Naruto series, its that there is a slight romance subplot but its far behind a lot of other stuff, the action, adventure, comedy, and drama. Yet even with events as recent as 631 and even 635, many just outright refuse NS and say its done or that the NS crowd has been a zombie crowd since 2009. Yet again, theroy after theory, we still see stuff that counters these claims and just plain gives more reason that NS is not dead, rather its NH and SS that are the ones with the issues because its not the ordeal of proving a pairing, as it is now, just the way the story is written, for NS to not happen and NH and SS to happen, there are many obstacles for the other two. How should I explain? Its not a matter of dialogue or action, its also the way the story has played out to even have some things enabled for specific pairings, in this case as its written right now, NH and SS have many obstacles. Yet many still go on saying NS is dead, not going to happen, or just plain stinks. Hey in the pairing fandom apparently shipping NS always makes you acceptable to hate and be made fun of, and that we should kitten up and accept NH or SS. Yet these claims always tend to just leave more holes then answers.
A while back I made this LAP about fanbases and their demands and how in most cases, anything they say or merit really means nothing, if you want to look at it, here it is: http://www.narusaku....showtopic=12946
Anyways what does this have to do with this current post? Well its about the theory fanbases put forward and at this point, its just become hard to imagine that even with all the claims they put on NS being never real or just humor while the other 2 just happen out of thin air, its these claims that many not only disagree with but when they use arguments asserted over bias, preference, opinion, and preception rather than actual manga evidence it just becomes harder to believe this stuff. We all know the only thing that matters is the events in the manga, what happens there is the key cold hard truth, but the evidence in the manga however is also a fluxuating gray area in which precption and opinion mix with evidence. This becomes quite a conundrum however, this is also able to be answered, how exactly? With a speculatory question, aka things that make you need to suppose or consider one event towards another or something like if event A works one way, how should it exactly work for event B which does the contrary? What do I mean by this in the Naruto verse for example? Look at it like this:
Lets focus on how some people considered Hinata the heroine over Sakura. Because in the invasion of pain, conflicts (for pairings) and confusion over the actions and aftermath of the land of iron, and now the 4th war and ten tails revival, one thing is true, Hinata has gotten a bit more screentime then in the past, first larger role for her since the chunin exams, because of events like her protecting Naruto, Kishi's interview of her making a better heroine, and 615, people assumed Sakura was no longer the heroine, well we know this is not true. Sakura is still the heroine, her importance has been stated basically in the string of chapters 630-635 itself which in this short string, it gave her a good chunk of screentime since the land of iron, all that was there for her between this was busting the white zetsu and discovering their ability. However, suppose Hinata was the heroine now, but things still occurred the same way, the same events still played out as we see them, nothing changes from what happened in the past up to chapter 637 right now. What do people expect a heroine to do? Fight and help support the hero right? Well if Hinata was the heroine now, there would be a lot of issues, and I mean A LOT OF ISSUES, given as it is, Hinata would still be very very undermatched to Sakura, espcially considering chapter 632 and 633, 632 we see Sakura reflect on herself and how far she came and got basically a kage level boost to help Naruto and Sasuke, 633 Hinata finally gets a technique Neji knew the whole time, barely taking down 1 jubbi clone to the hundreds Sakura took down in one arieal kick, is this how you treat a heroine? Again, the past few chapters, nothing important on her, so if Hinata is the great heroine the story needs, where exactly is both the power she needs as many have always said she had and could use or the constant support for Naruto in non-combat situations like Sakura has? The deal is, Hinata limited in the past and becoming the heroine now, to have a higher role and still do less then even Neji barely taking out one clone, thats not heroine treatment, what would be happening to Hinata now is exactly what the fans who ripped on Sakura all these years about being a bad heroine and who could be better. Basically, this results in an ironic turn of events towards Hinata due to a long lived double standard. Yet we all know Sakura is the heroine, heroines are not all needed to fight, mental development does its own merits to physical, sakura is mental first, physical second but its the mental development of her that gives her the heroine aspects of her own growth and interaction to those around her.
See what I mean? this was a speculatory question to make you think, if Hinata was the heroine now, something much better could come around for her now, yet she is getting the short end, 616 didn't really continue the high mark, she was not special and alone for the power boost of kurama's chakra, not much has advanced on her since 615. It really hurts Hinata in this sense that she still has no aspect or importance in the ordeals with Sasuke, never even speaking to him or having any corrleation, if HInata was the heroine now, there would be a lot of crap she would have to get up to speed with along with helping in the fight against the ten tails.
So what does this all fall back too? Simple, the theories and arguments just saying NS is dead or is never going to happen. Sorry but this is far from the truth, Note this is not bashing other fandoms nor noted central proof of NS happening, only that there is plenty to counter against certain commonly presented arguments against NS and how there are many issues for NH and SS themselves. You are free to enjoy any pairings you want, no one should change that, but there are times when things are just too far out there, it does not help a case.
Common arguments against NS: There have been many arguments against NS both rational and unrational, but many of these all have a few things in common, they either miss a few key points or just don't have enough to back up what they say. Lets look at a few:
NS is dead as of 469, 540, or 615: Okay as a NS fan I can honestly admit this, we were hit HARD, we were nailed 3 times over these past few years and for a time, it really seemed like NS died, but at each of these moments, there was one key piece of info we needed to be sure: Confirmation. We needed more information for each of these events, we needed to know exactly what happened by dialouge and events towards the claims of NS being dead. It was events like these 3 chapters that had many take the "open road" theory, that NS was out of the way and just not going to come back, the deal with all these moments however, NS had many loose ends and not everything was just done and over right there. Look at 469 first, because Naruto said, "I hate people who lie to themselves" to Sakura, does this instantly mean he is over her? Is Naruto just going to give up on Sakura now? Words are words, but later on things should make you think if this really did end NS there, for instance, we get Sai inputting his own speech on Naruto and how the real purpose of the fake confession was to try and free Naruto from the promise of a lifetime. Sakura was hurt and desperate over what Sai revealed to her all because of Sasuke's actions and how he could have put the leaf at war with the cloud. So how did arguments for this come up? Some said Naruto was over Sakura, that he realized she was lying and that she would always love Sasuke, that he finally knew she was a bunch of negative words, etc. These claims, they are not even fully realizing what they are saying, for years its been proven we found Naruto loves Sakura, even just in 457, 12 chapters before, we find a major reason Naruto loves Sakura but cannot confess to her, its because of the promise. Same way he feels he cannot become hokage, saving Sasuke, these tie into each other. So here are a few things to make you think, 457 we see a major reason Naruto loves Sakura so why would it just end there, no questions asked? If Naruto gave up on Sakura, did people not realize how inconsistent this would be? He could forgive Nagato and Itachi for a lot of junk they pulled, he will even forgive Sasuke, but he is not going to forgive Sakura for a lie intended to protect him? Is this seriously the argument NS has to swallow no questions asked? No just no. In fact this claim in itself destroys the main philosophy of NH, the fact that Hinata loves Naruto because she idolizes him, well if Naruto "gave up" on Sakura, this breaks NH both ways, if NH occurred it would be out of pity as many have claimed or settling for second choice because at this point, Naruto knows hinata loves him but did he do anything about it yet? No. the second way this argument in itself breaks NH, if Naruto could not fulfill his promise to Sakura, how could be feel good about any other girl? Hinata simply because she loves him? Not to mention, how would Hinata feel if Naruto actually gave up and gave into defeat? His nindo is never give up, so for the idol Naruto to give up, how would Hinata treat it? Maybe Naruto is not as amazing as we all thought and he is just still another human who fails. 615 he was close to giving up but Hinata and Kurama pulled him out, yes but the difference between say him wanting to save Sasuke and neji's death was, this, Naruto learned that there are things beyond his control and in the end for Neji, neji chose death, he chose to sacrifice himself to protect the lives of Naruto and Hinata. The difference was Naruto learned that there were things he could strive to do on his own but also those which he cannot control. Maybe its part luck on Naruto's side that he is left to deal with Sasuke but situations aside, Naruto learned how to deal with Sasuke and not deal with the sudden loss of Neji. Its only later after he says his "not having any friends is the worst thing to me" to Obito in 628, well guess who built on this speech with her own words (Sakura yes the one who he should hate if logic is correct).
Events like 540 and 615, again they made many say, "Well NS is out, SS and NH are going to be canon." Again like 469, these suffered the same main problem, not enough time has passed to get the full answers. Unlike 469 though these 2 were much shorter in length, Sakura in 540 got a negative view of Sasuke and 615 was a hand holding moment many NH fans jumped the gun with. The main deal was, 540 was left as a speculatory answer, many didn't consider that perhaps Sakura could have been reaffirming her feelings for Sasuke, but rather most said it will be SS in the end, that somehow we were just supposed to end SS without even getting a Sasuke deal on his own feelings. Many felt 615 made NH canon yet it did not. When it came to 540 and 615, the main deal with NS was, not all the loose ends were tied up, they still are not. Sasuke still needs to be dealt with and the story of team 7 and the interaction even between Naruto and Sakura is far from done, the main issue here is that people jumped the shark and just said lockout all the NS stuff, don't pay attention to it, let it go under the rug. This stuff is not going to "disappear under a rug." It needs resolution, it needs closure, if Naruto really was done with Sakura, he would need closure and acceptance of her feelings, even then he already does the second yet still loves her. Isn't it funny for NH to be cannon yet Kushina is said to be like Sakura due to Minato? See what I mean by these questions, if its so true then just why do things like these pop up?
Sakura will never stop loving Sasuke, its going to be SS in the end: The counter argument to this? Character development, pure simple character development over several small character arcs. All I can say to this is simple, what proof, what god given proof says Sakura cannot change? This answer would be true if she NEVER EVEN CHANGED HER OPINION OF NARUTO AND STILL HATED HIM. Yet we know Sakura has close feelings for Naruto, so this blows the argument out of the water along with basic character development. A character changes over the course of a story having an initial outlook and ending in another. Even now, look at 635, as her opinion of Naruto changed for the better, it may finally have hit Sakura where it hurts on how she views Sasuke. Sai asked her how she felt about him being back, while the words were genuine, the smile was fake, know what this means? Sakura is viewing Sasuke's return and actions in a negative light, fake means unreal, the words were convincing but any smart fan would know something bad is going to happen. Sakura views Sasuke negatively because of this. If Sakura loved Sasuke no questions, the smile would have been real but remember this, Sakura is smart, she is no fool, she learned from her mistakes in the land of iron, it was her 630 speech and experience of relying on Naruto that gave her the right stuff to tell everyone to do what they could to help win.
Kushina is nothing like Sakura: All I can say about this is, look at the early interaction between Naruto and Sakura and Kushina's flashback about how she met Minato and viewed him. Hell look at chapter 631. This story is made for middle schoolers to understand, to make these insane twists theories we constantly listened too, no its purely there. Its not hard to figure this stuff out. This falls towards the parallel aspects of the series, this is just to Sakura and Kushina though, stuff like this has occurred 3 or so times, once is nothing but 3 times or more? We know how Sakura and Kushina both had an aspect they hated about themselves that the blondes they hated actually liked about them. Well Naruto loved Sakura's forehead, Sakura has a symbol on it now, any takers that this will come up again? Hmm 
NS is a ship tease/red herring, its all for the sake of comedy: God this is one of my favorite arguments, its again just the fact that if NH and SS were to go canon, where the heck would the development have come from? We know NS is the most present and has its moments, but for how rare we see the other two, how is it just going to end in comedic humor? Kishi had plenty of chances to develop NH in the past, SS was halted for obvious reasons (Sasuke ran away to join orochipedo). So in a sense, at the start of part 2, NS and NH were on even ground, but more and more, he chose NS interaction, during combat and during downtime. NH has had 2 big moments, but thats just it, moments. Moments pass. Naruto still has not done anything about her pain confession and 615 ended faster than Atlantis was sunk. Event then, do this, think for a moment about Hinata, between defeating neji and defending Naruto from pain, what real development has Hinata had, what importance? Oh you say when she was with Naruto and Yamato during the Itachi hunt? ANNNT wrong, that arc had no real development on anyone save Sasuke, Obito, Taka and Itachi. It had nothing even for Naruto. Now just think of this, supposed NH and SS are going to be canon, well it would sure look weaker as a result. Why all this time for a joke rather than a gradually built relation over the events and conflicts of the story/ I'd rather have a relation over the good and bad events rather than just a sudden one. Even then, if NS was just friendship, that frienship makes more sense then a sudden love.
Sakura cares nothing for Naruto: Nice try but no, events early on like the chunin exams where Sakura would forfit to protect Naruto's dream, being suprised at him saving her from gaara, promising to get stronger for him, freaking concerned about him dying if Kurama was extracted, these are only a few things, Sakura cares about Naruto a lot, this is just plain proof, its not love (yet anyways) but Sakura cares about Naruto in ways she has not been able to show yet. She has her own way of showing she cares but hell just remember what yamato said himself, "Its not what you do for him thats important, what matters is how much you care about Naruto."
This is a lot, but if anything is assured, NS has a lot of stuff backing it up. I'm just one NS fan with LAPs, Just search and read other written statements about some of these that are more well known should include stuff like "Why we compare Kushina and Sakura" or NaruSaku: The build up. This is not BS either, though a NS fan, there are many things out there that still need to be done, but as it is right now, NS may start to take care of those. Naruto practically confirmed he still loves Sakura, Sakura is said to be like Kushina according to Minato, Sakura is unsure of Sasuke, and we have no idea about what Hinata is going to do or what her relevance to the major plot is, especially when it comes to Sasuke. The story goes on but as it is, NS has the advantage.
For those who read this, feel free to share it, I'm off to enjoy Independence day here in America (USA!
MERICA! sorry just had to do that,), AKA my nations birthday, for those outside the US, have a nice weekend.
Edited by Inferno180, 04 July 2013 - 06:08 PM.