2818 replies to this topic

[rockwill]

I will sum up my reaction to this chapter with just this now excuse me while I do Captain Ginyu's dance of happiness

[Chatte]

Yeah I reread it and she says it after she saw Sasuke's face of amazement that she joined them. Hell yeah, Sakura telling Sasuke to screw himself?

[shadow_Uzumaki]

@shadow uzumaki
yes i agree with you, but we still have obirin/narusaku parallel who is vocal point for obito redemption.

I really don't want to use the ObitoxRin parallel...considering how THAT ends up.
They may have similarities, but they went separate paths.

And I'm not saying it's an insignificant moment, but as James said, it's development, not necessarily canon confirmation

[ramenanmitsu]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

[rocci]

@phantom 999
well i didn't mean that post to be pro naruhina, but more like sarcasm to it.
it's because my poor at gramatical skill.

[StriderC]

Yeah I reread it and she says it after she saw Sasuke's face of amazement that she joined them. Hell yeah, Sakura telling Sasuke to screw himself?

I really don't think she's talking to Sasuke... Why would she say that to Sasuke when he's not the one who told her to sit down...

[James S Cassidy]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

BOO to the YEAH!!!

[六道仙人]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

high five!

[Moon_Girl]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

This makes me feel much better! Thanks!

[rocci]

I really don't want to use the ObitoxRin parallel...considering how THAT ends up.
They may have similarities, but they went separate paths.

And I'm not saying it's an insignificant moment, but as James said, it's development, not necessarily canon confirmation

to tnj someone naruto need a similiarities with them, and that's where obirin/narusaku parallel come.
for obito who reject reallity because the dead of rin, nothing else for naruto to tnj him with his similiar situation with obito.

beside all badguy become a badguy because someone dear to them dead in front of them, be it haku, sasuke, garaa, neji, and nagato.

[lupina]

Well ...






1. Epic Win!
2. Just every theorie we had in our minds came true ...
3.
4. I'm going and watch swayer and VJ - It will be fun ...

Edited by lupina, 22 May 2013 - 02:04 PM.

[shadow_Uzumaki]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

Honestly, I don't know how to read Japanese, I'm just going by common storytelling patterns. Sometimes, an "Idiot Hero" type character thinks literally, especially with someone as socially awkward as Naruto. For moments like these, it really messes up my own interpretations; especially since, in some ways, this moment's also a comedic one.

I know Minato, being a dad, would ask Naruto if the cute chick putting her hands on his back would ask if said chick would be his girlfriend. And I'm not really doubting Naruto meant what we want him to mean, but I always take such things cautiously.

Edited by shadow_Uzumaki, 22 May 2013 - 02:05 PM.

[redragon88]

Yeah I reread it and she says it after she saw Sasuke's face of amazement that she joined them. Hell yeah, Sakura telling Sasuke to screw himself?

Sakura was talking to Naruto. Don't overthink it. The following panels of Naruto saying "Sakura-chan" and them crossing eyes also confirms it.

[Sakamaki Izayoi]

Yeah I reread it and she says it after she saw Sasuke's face of amazement that she joined them. Hell yeah, Sakura telling Sasuke to screw himself?

Sauske didnt make any kind of face of amazement, his face was like " i dont care", and he was still the same, she was talking to Naruto because she knew he didnt trust on her power and she wants to prove to him that she's not a weak girl.

Aslo Sakura screamed "Sasuke-kun" to call everyone, because on the same panel there's "Why?".

Edited by Dαrkrєrsŧ, 22 May 2013 - 02:06 PM.

[Shadow1275]

Great chapter overall except for a few parts. I'd say that NH took a hit depending on the raws for the chapter, but as usual the pairings are still a toss up. Finally going to see Sakura back in action[Took you long enough Kishi] Finally, Minato's took a class in bad ass with the tailed beast mode and the Team 7 power ranger pose for the win.

Now for the cons

Ino goes back to instant fan-girl, and the whole alliance completely ignores Sasuke's crimes including Naruto like there is nothing wrong. It's like Sasuke is never accountable for anything. As for SS and NH, they're not sunk yet. Sakura's reaction to Sasuke is really up for debate, and Naruto's respones to his father depends on the Raws. Also, no Kakashi or Lightning Blade this chapter, but that's more personal preference than anything.

Overall, good chapter. I'm still expecting a swing on Sasuke's part especially since he wants to become hokage. It's like he's following Madara's path.

[ramenanmitsu]

But since Minato was saying, "（初めまして。僕は波風ミナト）Nice to meet you. My name is Minato Namikaze" to Sakura, and THEN he was asking the question, so the more precise translation will be, "Are you Naruto's girlfriend(lover)?" instead of "Could it be...Naruto's girlfriend?"

My previous post was just a direct translation.
Sorry I should have said that before

Edited by ramenanmitsu, 22 May 2013 - 02:10 PM.

[Inferno180]

@shadow_Uzumaki

Since I can't quote you for some reason, I'll answer to this.
"He may also misunderstand what a 'girlfriend' is, if he was thinking literally, as in a "friend who's a girl" type deal, or he meant it the way we want it to mean."
In Japanese we don't have a word that can be used for both "girlfriend" AND a "friend who's a girl".

Besides I read the raw. Minato said 『もしかして...ナルトの彼女かな？』
This cannot be translated anything other than girlfriend or lover.

彼女can be translated to girlfriend, lover, or she.

But when it's translated to she, it is used the same way as the english "she".
She has a cat. She is training.
彼女は猫を持っている。彼女は修行をしている。

There is no way 「彼女」 could be translated to "she" with the way Minato's speaking.

Minato asked 『もしかして....ナルトの彼女かな？』
もしかして....Could it be....
ナルトの Naruto's
彼女かな？Girlfriend(Lover)?

This makes me want to shout boo yah like cyborg from teen titans.

[SkiesEagle]

Guys, i just read this forum and went up to read a chapter. Needless to say, my face keeps widely grin when Minato mention Sakura remind of Kushina.
As much I want to keep dancing and scream but I have to remember this isn't canon...yet (I will see it if that conform canon)

My questions is that how Minato get a Kuubi's yellow coat thing out of nowhere?
Why Sasuke want to become Hokage?

[Rocket]

Well after months of taking a break from the story and the fandom, I finally caught up... I'm not feeling well right now, so I have to say this made me feel a lot better. I'm really glad that after all that's happened NS is still going strong.

Oh and as much as I'm really happy to see the old Team 7 again, I still hope Sasuke gets hit by a big yellow bus. Just wanted to get that out.

[shadow_Uzumaki]

Great chapter overall except for a few parts. I'd say that NH took a hit depending on the raws for the chapter, but as usual the pairings are still a toss up. Finally going to see Sakura back in action[Took you long enough Kishi] Finally, Minato's took a class in bad ass with the tailed beast mode and the Team 7 power ranger pose for the win.

Now for the cons

Ino goes back to instant fan-girl, and the whole alliance completely ignores Sasuke's crimes including Naruto like there is nothing wrong. It's like Sasuke is never accountable for anything. As for SS and NH, they're not sunk yet. Sakura's reaction to Sasuke is really up for debate, and Naruto's respones to his father depends on the Raws. Also, no Kakashi or Lightning Blade this chapter, but that's more personal preference than anything.

Overall, good chapter. I'm still expecting a swing on Sasuke's part especially since he wants to become hokage. It's like he's following Madara's path.

I wouldn't put it that way, we only saw the Rookie 9's reaction to Sasuke, not the entire Alliance's. Their reaction was pretty much the same as if The Joker came up to Batman and Family and say, "I'll become the President of the United States!" Which is complete "WTF?"

Well, not the same, Batman'd probably beat up The Joker, but you get my meaning.

Edited by shadow_Uzumaki, 22 May 2013 - 02:10 PM.