H&E's NaruSaku Debate Thread!
#3281
Posted 11 August 2012 - 01:46 AM

"This hat means a lot to me. Promise me you'll give it back someday...
when you've become a great pirate." -Shanks
#3282
Posted 11 August 2012 - 01:54 AM
Glad you want to patch things up with ciardha because you should know not that I like pointing fingers your argument with her is the reason why the mods closed the RTN thread.
#3283
Posted 11 August 2012 - 02:09 AM
I'd give you some, it's looooooong to read
Well, I know some of you dont like SK. It's a note from my friend. She tagged me on Fb and, well, She left me awe
I'm not a big shipper for this pair, but I kinda like it. Well, I always imagine if in the end, the battle of Sasuke and Naruto, Sakura would be in Naruto's side while Karin on Sasuke's.
they medic nin, ne?
Did Karin know about her clan?
I hope, in the end, she stab Sasuke from behind before she forgive him. I hope she'll do it, for herself, for Sasuke's sake, and of course for Naruto too. IF, Sasuke ends up alive, I hope he lost his sight, so Karin would be join him, go around the world. Sasuke would never back to Konoha afterall.
So, SasuKarin and of course NaruSaku XD
#3284
Posted 11 August 2012 - 02:19 AM
Hmm, thinking subjects only the most tangently related to the title character is best, kind of like what you said anything closely related to him and pairings have been argued to death.
Have a couple-
Do you think Land of Waves is the same place as the former Whirlpool country? Why or Why not?
What other characters do you think will be revealed to be of the Uzumaki clan before the manga ends? What is the reason why you think they are an Uzumaki?
When you go to war, both sides lose totally- Yoko Ono
Remember, our hearts are one. Even when we are at war with each other, our hearts are always beating in unison- Yoko Ono 2009
#3285
Posted 11 August 2012 - 02:29 AM
Have a couple-
Do you think Land of Waves is the same place as the former Whirlpool country? Why or Why not?
What other characters do you think will be revealed to be of the Uzumaki clan before the manga ends? What is the reason why you think they are an Uzumaki?
If that's true, then Mei may as well be an Uzumaki.
I don't think that Gaara is, but how the heck did he get so much chakra that he could control sand ? (without any sort of handsigns or help from the Shukaku)
But it sure would've been fun with three Uzumaki kage's one day!! XD
ナルサク
#3286
Posted 11 August 2012 - 03:08 AM
It's always good to try to patch things up. No matter how the other party feels. Just get yourself right. Good on you, halfstar.
#3287
Posted 11 August 2012 - 05:10 AM
hmm, I'm not going to say that he never cared for Karin after what I've read, but I will say that he certainly discarded all feelings when he betrayed her. I'm curious to see how people think Karin will forgive Sasuke for that, and how Sasuke can trust that she's forgiven him.

"This hat means a lot to me. Promise me you'll give it back someday...
when you've become a great pirate." -Shanks
#3288
Posted 11 August 2012 - 05:22 AM
Don't feel it's appropriate to discuss this on the live forum. Send me a PM and we'll talk about it.
When you go to war, both sides lose totally- Yoko Ono
Remember, our hearts are one. Even when we are at war with each other, our hearts are always beating in unison- Yoko Ono 2009
#3289
Posted 11 August 2012 - 05:42 AM
The debate thread about the pairings, however..............just ticked me off. It ticked me off, because I still find it hard to believe that there are still so many people against us. Not only that, but some of the arguments were frustrating to read. It is those reasons why I don't no longer read debate threads about Naruto pairings anymore, because after awhile, BOTH sides will start saying STUPID arguments. They get stupid, because both sides become to stubborn to admit when the other may have a point, and instead throw out dumb arguments that will lead to nowhere. In the end, no one will be convinced, and it will just end up with two sides arguing with each other just for the sake of arguing.
But that wasn't the case in that thread, what bother me is that we are still having this same old arguments use against us and we are still using the same counter arguments against them (and vice-versa). After all these years, and especially with the stuff that has happen in/with the latest movie, you assume that at this point that some may have realized that we MAY have point, or AT LEAST have come up with new (and better) arguments. I guess you can say the same thing for the opposite fandom, but to me not really. Like someone posted here not to long ago, we have A LOT more 'ammo' to use against them, we should be the ones that are 'winning', yet there still many who argue against us.
In fact, of what I've checked on that specific site, it still seems like Naruhina is still very popular. Of course that just one site, but still, on the Anti-Narusaku thread there was about 1800 people who voted on their own reasons why they don't like Narusaku. That's kind of a lot of people. I just don't understand people's reasoning at time, and, if you really knew me in real life, means something coming from my mouth (or technical hands, because I'm typing this). Everything in my head points to Narusaku being the end game, but a lot of people don't think so. Is there something wrong with how I see things (which matches with most of the other people on this site), or that people online are just..............either dumb, weird, stubborn, or just trolls.
...........
You know what, I think I just answer my own question.
#3290
Posted 11 August 2012 - 06:00 AM
So you're saying that Don-kun arguments are silly?
Brenden you're gating the wrong Message I only want T's opinion of my post on the debate thread.
Edited by NS means logic, 11 August 2012 - 06:13 AM.
#3291
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:02 AM
So you're saying that Don-kun arguments are silly?
Brenden you're gating the wrong Message I only want T's opinion of my post on the debate thread.
No, I said that wasn't the case in that thread. I was mostly talking about how I'm very frustrating about the whole pairing debate thing, and how, at this point, their shouldn't be much of a debate. If there should be debate, we should be 'winning' that debate, because we have a lot more manga proof. But no, the other won't back down, and we (Narusaku fan base) are still smaller than the Naruhina fan base. I only mention the fact that I hate the debates, because I wanted to mention why I don't read debate threads anymore when other pairing fandoms are involved. I probably worded it wrong, and you probably thought I was talking about all the arguments that were presented there, when in reality I'm just tired of those whole 'pairing wars' thing, because I believe there shouldn't be much of a debate at this point.
Also, I'm assuming you're Don-Kun (if not, then this would be silly), so I just I wanted to say you made some great arguments. In fact, I thought the Narusaku arguments were pretty solid at that debate thread. What was frustrating to me was seeing people counter arguing against those arguments. It wasn't the fact that they were being mean or rude, they weren't (or, at least, of what I read), it was the fact they were arguing against some manga facts, and they were same arguments I've seen being made in countless other websites. Like we never seen Naruto stop loving Sakura, yet they still debate that he doesn't any more. There are panels that show Sakura blushing at Naruto and it has been hinted her feelings for him may go beyond friendship, yet they still debate that is not true.
To me, at this point, I honestly don't think some pairing fans are blinded by their preference. I honestly believe they just don't see it going that direction, which makes me doubt my own judgment, because I don't see the series going to the Naruhina direction. Maybe it just me(us) that don't see it going to end Naruhina, and they are the ones that are right. But then again I have a lot more manga support, anime support (all those OPs and EDs, and other little things (like their 'dates')), parallels, and, oh, the recent Naruto movie that KISHI was in charged with. So my mind is at ease with that evidence, though that makes me beg the question again of why they are so many Naruhina fans and why they honestly believe it will end Naruhina.
#3292
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:11 AM
No, there's nothing wrong with how you see things. And while we don't agree with earnest anti-NS shippers, there's nothing "wrong" with how they see things either. Not everyone who dislikes or argues against NS is "dumb, weird, stubborn, or just trolls." For some it's simply an honest matter of perspective and they argue what they see.
For example:

Do you see a duck or a rabbit?
Some people will rightly argue that they see a duck, and others will rightly argue that they see a rabbit. The people who see a duck aren't saying it to be stubborn or trollish, they say it because it's what they see. Unless there is acceptance that the drawing can be seen differently, the argument of what it is will go on indefinitely.
Fandom arguments, especially pairing arguments, boil down to how we as individuals perceive what's in front of us. It's based on our life experiences, our feelings, even down to the wiring of our brains. Traditional relationship constructs, values, culture, tropes, idioms, etc. -- they all have an influence on our perspective and how we process what we see.
Pairings appeal to people for different reasons. Let's say NS fans all see a rabbit. There still comes a point where we have to agree to let others shippers see the duck.
Kishimoto will eventually make it clear whether he's drawn a rabbit or a duck. But even if he says it's a rabbit, some people will never see it, and will still insist it's a duck. Because that's what they see.
#3293
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:17 AM

The family that couldn't be.
[post='http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EItApJttbY']An Underrated Song Worth Listening[/post]
#3294
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:22 AM
LOL. Why does it feel trollish? I don't get why you'd think that.
#3295
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:33 AM
For example:

Do you see a duck or a rabbit?
Some people will rightly argue that they see a duck, and others will rightly argue that they see a rabbit. The people who see a duck aren't saying it to be stubborn or trollish, they say it because it's what they see. Unless there is acceptance that the drawing can be seen differently, the argument of what it is will go on indefinitely.
Fandom arguments, especially pairing arguments, boil down to how we as individuals perceive what's in front of us. It's based on our life experiences, our feelings, even down to the wiring of our brains. Traditional relationship constructs, values, culture, tropes, idioms, etc. -- they all have an influence on our perspective and how we process what we see.
Pairings appeal to people for different reasons. Let's say NS fans all see a rabbit. There still comes a point where we have to agree to let others shippers see the duck.
Kishimoto will eventually make it clear whether he's drawn a rabbit or a duck. But even if he says it's a rabbit, some people will never see it, and will still insist it's a duck. Because that's what they see.
I agree with you, it all comes down to perspective. But that's also why it so hard to debate with others about pairings, because if they haven't seen the 'rabbit' at this point then they would probably will never see it. It also hard to debate with someone if you don't understand their perspective, and even harder to win a argument because you really can't say someone's perspective of certain events in the manga are wrong. I tried SOO HARD to understand Naruhina fan's perspective, like seeing Naruto and Sakura's relationship as more of sibling relationship, and that Hinata may have more of a role in the series then I believe. But I simply can't, if Naruto and Sakura really do have a brother-sister relationship, then why does Naruto often flirt with Sakura and why has their been moments that imply Sakura may have stronger feelings for Naruto (she blushes, the hug at the end of the Pain arc, Yamato's speech, etc...). Also, Hinata, no way I looks at it, still doesn't seem all so important to me because WE HARDLY SEE HER.
Admittedly, perspective is also about an individuals belief, and I don't know every fans personal beliefs, values or morals. But, the things I've mention about Sakura's feelings about Naruto, I don't know how in their minds they don't see any romantic implication. To me, that's the hardest part of how to identify with other fandoms.
#3296
Posted 11 August 2012 - 07:42 AM
Also, I'm assuming you're Don-Kun (if not, then this would be silly), so I just I wanted to say you made some great arguments. In fact, I thought the Narusaku arguments were pretty solid at that debate thread. What was frustrating to me was seeing people counter arguing against those arguments. It wasn't the fact that they were being mean or rude, they weren't (or, at least, of what I read), it was the fact they were arguing against some manga facts, and they were same arguments I've seen being made in countless other websites. Like we never seen Naruto stop loving Sakura, yet they still debate that he doesn't any more. There are panels that show Sakura blushing at Naruto and it has been hinted her feelings for him may go beyond friendship, yet they still debate that is not true.
To me, at this point, I honestly don't think some pairing fans are blinded by their preference. I honestly believe they just don't see it going that direction, which makes me doubt my own judgment, because I don't see the series going to the Naruhina direction. Maybe it just me(us) that don't see it going to end Naruhina, and they are the ones that are right. But then again I have a lot more manga support, anime support (all those OPs and EDs, and other little things (like their 'dates')), parallels, and, oh, the recent Naruto movie that KISHI was in charged with. So my mind is at ease with that evidence, though that makes me beg the question again of why they are so many Naruhina fans and why they honestly believe it will end Naruhina.
Reply
NaruHina has the biggest fandom in the west and most Americans I'm an American too, like girls will big B. Also the Fandon in America does not like Sakura so they will side with NaruHina and SS is hoping for NH so Sakura can be available and NH is hoping for SS for Sakura to be out of the way, I you go with the neutral fans you will notice that No one challenge the NS view they just don't like the pairing but also don't have a problem with the argument.
About SS and the reason why it's popular, well ask yourself why Justin Bieber, is the same thing Sakura female Fans was Sakura to end with a cute guy plus they are also Sasuke fan they love him like a real live person.
ANS, well those fans spend almost 24 hours a day hating NS, a question. Does NH and SS bother you to a point where you want to express your hatred toward the pairing? Ok to make it easier, remember when the 1st trailer and the posters for the movie were out, some of the members including myself panic about the possibility of NH and SS been presented by Kishi as Author's intent. Well the ANS are in that status every single day they are also member saying that If NS happens they will stop reading the Manga other that they will hate Kishi for the rest of their life, another call Naruto a jerk for the NH stuff, angry when Naruto ask Sakura for a date and some even say that the had nightmares thinking NaruSaku did happen, and another girl almost crash her car because she was freaking out about the possibility of NS happening, some of the post in the ANS are genuinely panicking whwhile hating the Anime team for giving NS so much fanservise.
#3297
Posted 11 August 2012 - 09:03 AM
Well, I know some of you dont like SK. It's a note from my friend. She tagged me on Fb and, well, She left me awe
I'm not a big shipper for this pair, but I kinda like it. Well, I always imagine if in the end, the battle of Sasuke and Naruto, Sakura would be in Naruto's side while Karin on Sasuke's.
they medic nin, ne?
Did Karin know about her clan?
I hope, in the end, she stab Sasuke from behind before she forgive him. I hope she'll do it, for herself, for Sasuke's sake, and of course for Naruto too. IF, Sasuke ends up alive, I hope he lost his sight, so Karin would be join him, go around the world. Sasuke would never back to Konoha afterall.
So, SasuKarin and of course NaruSaku XD
This post explains quite succinctly what Ive stated about SasuKarin nicely especialy in regards to the devleopment theyve shared throughout the series.
My thoughts on this have always been that I think she will not forgive him right off the bat at least not openly.
the way I think things are going given the current plot and development. Is that Sasuke will be reduced to what Naruto was at the beginning of the manga, ie the Pariah, the guy who has nothing, the guy who wants or has to seek the villages and his friends acknowledgement and most importantly he has to rebuild the trust with the girl he loves like Naruto did with Sakura.
Naruto on the other hand will take the place Sasuke had, as the cool guy with the fangirls, and the hero etc who has all the acknowledgemnt.
its basically a full circle ending where the two characters cycle through life and walk amile in the others shoes so to speak.
Karins forgiveness wont be done ""on Screen"' so to speak. instead itll be more like shesll agree to follow him or hell agree to follow her, or shell say i just happen to be going the same way as you ((like what she said when Suigetsu first asked her whay she was coming)) secretly shell smile or give some hint that shes glad to be with him, but hes got a ways to go to earn her trust back.
Outwardly though shell act cool and distant like she does normally around him, which will make the chase for Sasuke that much more exiting and intriguing.
..(^)> PENGUIN!!!!
C(...)D
..m.m
Training with a sannin 2 1/2 years
new pair of gloves 20 ryou
the look on your best friend, and former sensei's face's when you cause a small earth quake. Princeless
Catsis Fan Fiction
#3298
Posted 11 August 2012 - 09:18 AM
Well, like you pointed, everyone has different perspectives, I just don't know why, but I feel that way

The family that couldn't be.
[post='http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EItApJttbY']An Underrated Song Worth Listening[/post]
#3299
Posted 11 August 2012 - 09:20 AM
What if Sasuke turns out he has feelings for Karin? It was shown during the time he learnt that Karin is an Uzumaki, and he hesitated to finish her off at the Iron Country.

"My name is Sung Ji-woo. Some called me the Assassin of Death. A Necromancer Deity... My journey has been nothing but walking over a mountain of corpses. My legion of the dead reigns supreme. None shall block my way or... face the wrath of my blades!" --Solo Leveling.
#3300
Posted 11 August 2012 - 09:30 AM
when he was shocked that karin was an uzumaki, it doesn't necessarily mean he has feelings for her although my thoughts on sasukarin for me is to wait till at least karin is reunited with sasuke to see if she still has feelings for him and if there is potential to this pairing .
Edited by T XD, 11 August 2012 - 09:30 AM.
3 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 3 guests, 0 anonymous users


This topic is locked










