4310 replies to this topic

[rocci]

Both were based from one shot of Mashima, but I personaly consider Sieg Hart much better character in RM than Jellar in FT.

Rm is much more serious than ft. Just a different tone of story.

What's wrong with jellal?

[NarutoUzumaki01]

Rm is much more serious than ft. Just a different tone of story.

What's wrong with jellal?

Mashima's descision of taking desings and names from RM itself was bad idea.

Jellal was avenger as we-know-who, lost and now is trying to re-deem himself, but basicly all he's doing is same as Sasuke after end of the manga, he walks out of screen in wandering somewhers, shows up in random arcs to enforce Jellal x Erza shippers to buy more volumes and walks away again. With this much of "work" having a face of one of the best characters with great storylens doesn't do good to Jellal too.

[nikki1314]

oooooh, so thats why I dont like him. that Sasuke Vibe, Thanks for pointing it out XD

 

I did like Mystogan tho. So cool XD

Edited by nikki1314, 22 November 2015 - 01:29 AM.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Yeah, what you said, NU01.

[NarutoUzumaki01]

Yeah, what you said, NU01.

Lol, but redhead went better than blonde 

[TouKen4Life3g]

Lol, but redhead went better than blonde 

Lol. Still, it is a rebound. Yes, people move on but from writing standpoint we are discussing.

[NarutoUzumaki01]

Lol. Still, it is a rebound. Yes, people move on but from writing standpoint we are discussing.

It made story much better, now people remember Gwen as one death by GG, and MJ as Spidy's wife.

[TouKen4Life3g]

It made story much better, now people remember Gwen as one death by GG, and MJ as Spidy's wife.

You mean Spider-Man. Oh yeah, conspiracy begins anew!

[NarutoUzumaki01]

You mean Spider-Man. Oh yeah, conspiracy begins anew!

Wait, what? 

[TouKen4Life3g]

Wait, what? 

GG didn't kill her. It was Spider-Man!

[NarutoUzumaki01]

GG didn't kill her. It was Spider-Man!

Well, by web, but GG caused it.

[TouKen4Life3g]

Well, by web, but GG caused it.

But who ended it? Exactly. Shounen, it's GG. Seinen, it's Spider-Man.

Edited by TouKen4Life3g, 22 November 2015 - 03:49 AM.

[Phantom_999]

Well I'm not saying Jellal is a favourite of mine but I don't think he's as bad a Sasuke. that's my opinion at least. His is a different case in a lot of ways

[nikki1314]

I just wish that if they ever get married, that he wont leave Erza alone to raise their kid lol

Edited by nikki1314, 22 November 2015 - 04:21 AM.

[TouKen4Life3g]

I just wish that if they ever get married, that he wont leave Erza alone to raise their kid lol

If anything he will visit his child 5 additional times from Sasuke (which is none) per week.

[rocci]

Lol. Still, it is a rebound. Yes, people move on but from writing standpoint we are discussing.

There's nothing wrong with rebound.

[Codus N]

Think of how ridiculous that is. Jellal was one of the ten great wizard saints, he was leagues stronger than Ultear, and at no time could break from her control? He hasn't atoned for anything, he does nothing but hide behind Erza, who doesn't have the right to defend him, in essence running from his responsibilities.
Jerza isn't that far behind Gruvia for me. The only real good pairing is NaLu. GaJevy and Miralax are ok, and the jury is still out on Zervis, but Jerza and Gruvia are trash.

And are we forgetting the fact that Hades was her boss, who by the way, was in fact taught by Zeref himself? Even though Ultear says that she was the one controlling him, it was Hades who taught her how. Mavis outright called him a genius wizard and I would dare say that even without his 'heart', he could match up to August evenly.

Just because you're a wizard saint doesn't mean you're all-powerful. Also, Brain was the one who taught Jellal everything he knew and was working with Hades at that. I wouldn't be surprised that with both their knowledge, they could easily set up a mental block preventing Jellal from catching on.

Also, to add to my previous sentence about being a wizard saint, that title doesn't extend to acknowledgement of your mental skills. Hades and Ultear had him right where they wanted him at his most psychologically vulnerable. And you say being a "Wizard Saint" should have had him breaking free of Ultear's control? It was a psychological problem, not a matter of magical strength.

I'm one of the few willing to cut him some slack, but even I do agree his plotline is shaky. If you don't like that, fine carry on people.

[TouKen4Life3g]

There's nothing wrong with rebound.

There isn't. Just this kind of story is too late.

[Phantom_999]

How so?

[AHK]

I just wish that if they ever get married, that he wont leave Erza alone to raise their kid lol

  
I hope they don't get married period. Jellal is a waste of space, hope he snuffs it.

And are we forgetting the fact that Hades was her boss, who by the way, was in fact taught by Zeref himself? Even though Ultear says that she was the one controlling him, it was Hades who taught her how. Mavis outright called him a genius wizard and I would dare say that even without his 'heart', he could match up to August evenly.
Just because you're a wizard saint doesn't mean you're all-powerful. Also, Brain was the one who taught Jellal everything he knew and was working with Hades at that. I wouldn't be surprised that with both their knowledge, they could easily set up a mental block preventing Jellal from catching on.
Also, to add to my previous sentence about being a wizard saint, that title doesn't extend to acknowledgement of your mental skills. Hades and Ultear had him right where they wanted him at his most psychologically vulnerable. And you say being a "Wizard Saint" should have had him breaking free of Ultear's control? It was a psychological problem, not a matter of magical strength.
I'm one of the few willing to cut him some slack, but even I do agree his plotline is shaky. If you don't like that, fine carry on people.

And? Since when does it matter who you're trained by? Ultear was trained by Hades but got beat by Gray. Hades was "trained by Zeref himself" but got his ass kicked by Natsu after he ate Laxus' lightning. If you're not stronger than somebody, you're not stronger. End of story. Him not being able to break it makes absolute zero sense. Everything about Jellal is terrible, including his weak plot line.

Edited by AHK, 23 November 2015 - 02:07 AM.