4036 replies to this topic

[elmas]

I'm here and HOLY kitten!I said a big airing moment will happen and I was right.SS is officially dead.100% dead.Definetly dead!

[FullmetalNinja25]

This is further proof that Kishimoto doesn't know jack about developing Female Characters.

[TheFirstEvil100]

I am. Grammar isn't something that's messed up too bad these days. It's usually the wording that's messed up in these translations. The scene wasn't an ambiguous one where it's left to the reader to decide, this is clear as day. Like I said, this was Sakura's last attempt to bring Sasuke to his senses/back to team 7. She's desperate. Why? Let's see....

1. Says he's going to start a revolution (for the worse, because of his methods, nature and overall character)
2. Kill all the kages
3. Kill all the bijuu's
4. Kill Naruto
5. Rule over everything she knows. That includes the people, the villages, etc. Everything. Whether or not gets far doesn't matter. A revolution requires drastic measures in order to achieve it.

It wasn't for her gain/purpose. What are you saying? She wanted to profess her love to him because she saw it as the chance to? This isn't Hinata's confession. I saw this as someone who cared about him deeply to try their best to bring her teammate back. Letting someone know that there are friends/comrades/teammates (whatever you want to call it) that care for them somewhere is welcoming. I really really don't see how this is a romantic/positive SS moment. You don't really understand the situation here and what's happening to them.

 

""If I still have a place in that heart of yours, even if it's just a little... Please, don't go"" 

 

This quote is iffy because it can go both ways, but because of what the other panels tell us it isn't. She's trying to appeal to him personally, hoping that he hasn't fallen fully into the darkness. I don't know if she was slightly convinced that Sasuke was beginning to be "good" again when they fought Kaguya, but I think that might be the case. The first farewell was flashbacked because it's playing out like it again. That Sasuke is different from the current one. Sakura obviously tried to convince him one more time because of the reason above and what he's planning to do. 

 

Love isn't only romantic you know. Love can come in different forms. Like friendship love, teammate love etc. Her speech was different, because she said "LOVED". 

 

 

 

Ahh yes! Because loves is the same as loved. 

 

Oh please. If you're going to argue with something, at least let it be reasonable. Go ahead and ignore the text if you want.

Well from what I'm seeing many people here think that love just means one thing and only one thing just from what I have been reading, but as you said there are many forms of love Sakura no longer loves Sasuke, yet everyone wants her to hate Sasuke and be someone who she is not which is something that I well and truly hate

[LadyGT]

Fanfic no jutsu

[Kster95]

Do you see how degrading Sskura's words in MS are?

It's as if she hasn't changed at all. This is exactly what I was afraid of, Sakura reverting back to part 1 Sakura. And it happened.

[ButterBean]

OMG. Mangastream is in present tense! RAW PLEASE!

[elmas]

Fanfic no jutsu

Oh god!I can imagine SS fans thank MS right now .But We're doomed.

[luffyq1]

This is further proof that Kishimoto doesn't know jack about developing Female Characters.

Yup.

[Nefertieh]

Bringing back by force is Naruto's attempt, obviously it's going to be coupled with tnj. But of course it wouldn't work since like you said, he's been given many power-ups and so has Naruto. Meanwhile Sakura finally activated Byakugou this last in the series. Not only was her claims degressed, the character itself was neglected to the point where she couldn't even contribute in bringing back Sasuke with Naruto. This of course was made into her own little subplot of standing on equal footing with both Naruto and Sasuke. How's that turned out?

 

It's an obvious degression. Calling it out isn't mockery or bashing.

 

You said "lol sure thing sakura". Please explain to me how that laugh, coupled with sarcasm, qualifies as not bashing.

 

All the pictures you posted in your Sakura bashing post happened in the very early chapters of Part II. As strange as it may seem, things in the story actually change! You cannot simply fish a caption to justify your gleeful hate.

 

It has been made abundantly clear that the only way to save Sasuke is not to tie him down and scream at him. Remember, Naruto himself said ninja truly understand each other when they fight when they clashed at the Land of Iron. The Sasuke/ Naruto fight is a deeply personal one. Sakura has no role in it, no matter how strong or useful she has become.

[Swagkura]

mangapanda uses the past tense
mangastream uses the present tense

LOOOL

Really? MS actually said love instead of loved? I guess I can see why SS fans are happy now...

[FullmetalNinja25]

I'm done with Sakura, she used to be one of my Favorite Characters.

[rocci]

Yup.

Wow writing female must be hard.

[LadyGT]

Same chapter with Kakashi commenting on Sakura's feelings was translated from mangastream with the present tense when it clearly had the past tense in the script.

Edited by LadyGT, 25 September 2014 - 12:35 PM.

[elmas]

Lol.I pity SS fans.Firstly they got a heart attack but after seeing MS vers they gone nuts.Their mentality...

[Nefertieh]

I am not bashing Sakura but Kishi has really written get terribly at this point.

And agaim amswer my question. How can NS become something without an asspull?

 

Yeah, not like there's development in the series or anything.

[Geninja]

Yes.The past tense argument isnt that convincing.From a normal reading persspective it still sounds she loves him

No because most people in the world understand basic grammar. The past tense is VERY convincing because it's what he chose to write when he could have easily wrote it in the present tense. How can you honestly say that tense does not matter, didn't you learn anything in grade school?

 

The past tense writing choice changes everything.

[DarkRadeon]

MS isnt using Past tense.Oh man what the hell does the RAW say damn it

[Swagkura]

"She loves you so much its breaking her heart"

[FreakySandra1995]

Same chapter with Kakashi commenting on Sakura feeling was translated from mangastream with the present tense when it clearly had the part tense in the script.

Also, the way Mangastream was letting her say "still love" contradicts Kakashi's words. Mangapanda (usually) has the right translation. But WHY would they do such a stupid thing?!

[Geninja]

Same chapter with Kakashi commenting on Sakura's feelings was translated from mangastream with the present tense when it clearly had the past tense in the script.

 

I'm not concerned, it's clearly in the past tense and even so Sasuke still doesn't give a damn about her so SS still will not be canon, no matter what.

Edited by Geninja, 25 September 2014 - 12:37 PM.