4310 replies to this topic

[TouKen4Life3g]

Natsu is not stronger than erza but he will be.

Erza is the sasuke to Natsu's naruto

Except much less sufferable.

[alexander]

Laxus has more reason and has earned it more than Erza has. He already redeemed himself, and has proven he can be a leader. Natsu has been stronger than Erza for a long time coming, and Mira knows way more about being a guild master than Erza. Erza is the worst choice possible. Desperately hoping that she is just a stand in, because her as the guild master is awful.

 

That's just like your opinion man. Right now there is no way to tell who is stronger. But Natsu could never lead. All the others are too imature or incompetent to be leaders. Mira knows how the wheel get's spin, but she doesn't have the grip to keep order and put the guild member in their place when she needs to. Erza has experience, she has the respect of the others, she is an veteran fighter, and has proven she can lead others when she needs to. I think she is an better choice then Laxus.

[harry4e]

Laxus has more reason and has earned it more than Erza has. He already redeemed himself, and has proven he can be a leader. Natsu has been stronger than Erza for a long time coming, and Mira knows way more about being a guild master than Erza. Erza is the worst choice possible. Desperately hoping that she is just a stand in, because her as the guild master is awful.

 

More than Erza? Are you high? He failed to protect the guild when it was attacked the first time and got destroyed, second time he was the one who tried to destroy the guild, he was taken out of commision before everyone else, and didn't do anything to protect the guild the last time. He's not earned anything, just because he's the strongest and the grandson of Makarov does not make him qualified. Erza was the one who took responsibility when the Master was taken out of commision during the war with the other guild, she was the one with the calm head that knew they had to retrieve when it happened dispite her own feelings, She put her life on the line to to protect everyone in the guild when they attacked with the beam. She has shown her faith in others...she is the better leader. Yeah she has her quirks, and has her faults but compared the rest she is the better choice.

 

Even after he was recalled, he spends more time with his Lightning tribe, notice how he was the one who didn't answer the call to bring everyone back?  Why do you think that is? Because he doesn't socialize with the rest, so they were not able to contact him. A Guild leader needs to treat everyone the same, Erza does that, she keeps everyone in line, she understands how the Council politics works, as she knew that when she was arreasted it was all just for show, yet every other member apart from Makarov were panicking. Mira would be a good choice but this part highlighted her biggest fault, she doesn't keep the guild inline, infact she seems to enjoy seeing them cause chaos, as we've seen her tease charactors in the past that has led to them in a fight.

Edited by harry4e, 01 June 2015 - 03:42 PM.

[NarutoUzumaki01]

 

That's just like your opinion man. Right now there is no way to tell who is stronger. But Natsu could never lead. All the others are too imature or incompetent to be leaders. Mira knows how the wheel get's spin, but she doesn't have the grip to keep order and put the guild member in their place when she needs to. Erza has experience, she has the respect of the others, she is an veteran fighter, and has proven she can lead others when she needs to. I think she is an better choice then Laxus.

Not only his, Laxus was more suitable as leader, he always had his team in hands and he was shown as good leader, when was Erza good leader? She only was good fighter, let alone that she's same age as Natsu and etc, she has no more expirience than any of those. What last thing Erza showed? Just with power of friendship win. Natsu as ridiculous as he is just one-shoted War God, he is definetly stronger right now.

[rocci]

Natsu is stronger than erza. He may not be a leader, but he's the strongest warrior fairy tail ever have.

@harry
Jellal is good enough for erza. And they're practically canon along with the other not so canon pairings.

Edited by rocci, 02 June 2015 - 01:40 AM.

[harry4e]

Natsu is stronger than erza. He may not be a leader, but he's the strongest warrior fairy tail ever have.

@harry
Jellal is good enough for erza. And they're practically canon along with the other not so canon pairings.

 

I don't think he's the strongest just yet, or atleast he's not been proven to be the strongest, once he beats Erza, Laxus and Gildhart in battle it will be confirmed.

 

I know Jellal is Canon, I knew it would be canon when he came back from the dead, before that I thought Jellal would have the same fate as his counterpart in Rave Master, but Mashima has become soft and doesn't kill off any charactor easily, not even Ultear died, heck even her mother still lived as part of the ocean. It's why I like FT: Zero more, he's knows he can kill off charactors there as they are already dead in the current timeline.

[rocci]

 
I don't think he's the strongest just yet, or atleast he's not been proven to be the strongest, once he beats Erza, Laxus and Gildhart in battle it will be confirmed.
 
I know Jellal is Canon, I knew it would be canon when he came back from the dead, before that I thought Jellal would have the same fate as his counterpart in Rave Master, but Mashima has become soft and doesn't kill off any charactor easily, not even Ultear died, heck even her mother still lived as part of the ocean. It's why I like FT: Zero more, he's knows he can kill off charactors there as they are already dead in the current timeline.

For natsu to fight them, mashima need to make another tournament arc with fairy tail against each other or force natsu to fight them or training arc to fight them.
So it would be better to use character feat.

Onepiece infuence I think. There's no dead in op until plot demand so or flashback.
In rave mashima kill character in the last arc.

[Nar123]

Not only his, Laxus was more suitable as leader, he always had his team in hands and he was shown as good leader, when was Erza good leader? She only was good fighter, let alone that she's same age as Natsu and etc, she has no more expirience than any of those. What last thing Erza showed? Just with power of friendship win. Natsu as ridiculous as he is just one-shoted War God, he is definetly stronger right now.

 

Erza's fights might've been utter boring and asspull-ish nowadays but she has shown a leader capabilities before, we can't deny this

 

I just hope this new position helps to fix her character

Edited by Nar123, 02 June 2015 - 02:26 AM.

[Codus N]

More than Erza? Are you high? He failed to protect the guild when it was attacked the first time and got destroyed, second time he was the one who tried to destroy the guild, he was taken out of commision before everyone else, and didn't do anything to protect the guild the last time. He's not earned anything, just because he's the strongest and the grandson of Makarov does not make him qualified. Erza was the one who took responsibility when the Master was taken out of commision during the war with the other guild, she was the one with the calm head that knew they had to retrieve when it happened dispite her own feelings, She put her life on the line to to protect everyone in the guild when they attacked with the beam. She has shown her faith in others...she is the better leader. Yeah she has her quirks, and has her faults but compared the rest she is the better choice.
 
Even after he was recalled, he spends more time with his Lightning tribe, notice how he was the one who didn't answer the call to bring everyone back?  Why do you think that is? Because he doesn't socialize with the rest, so they were not able to contact him. A Guild leader needs to treat everyone the same, Erza does that, she keeps everyone in line, she understands how the Council politics works, as she knew that when she was arreasted it was all just for show, yet every other member apart from Makarov were panicking. Mira would be a good choice but this part highlighted her biggest fault, she doesn't keep the guild inline, infact she seems to enjoy seeing them cause chaos, as we've seen her tease charactors in the past that has led to them in a fight.

I think Laxus became part of the Wizard Saints and is currently on the council. That's why he didn't respond to the gathering. The Raijinshuu likewise are probably on the council as his bodyguards. It's been mentioned in Jura's updated guild card that there's talks about making Laxus a WS but decided not to, because of his personality. I think that considering the dead council, they probably decided to appoint him since they really needed to fill the seats. I do think he's matured enough to take an important position.

If it's not the above, then it's likely Yuri is part of the 4 Gods (and the strongest) and Laxus seeked him out to train under his great-grandfather. You guys can check the 4 Gods' silhouette and one of them definitely looks like he could be Yuri.

EDIT: I figured out why Erza's the 7th master. If Mashima does intend on putting her in the backseat from here on, then the only possible member to fill in her position would be Gajeel. Considering the approaching endgame with Zeref, this would be a good time to develop Gajeel some more. Consider this: there would be 3 Dragon Slayers in the group, and a Demon Slayer. All 4 have a close connection with Zeref and Lucy is heavily hinted to have a connection to Zeref himself too.

Edited by Codus N, 02 June 2015 - 05:02 AM.

[AHK]

Just read the chapter again, yeah Gruvia makes me sick, and honestly, Juvia is starting to make me feel that way too. I just can't. I tried to like them together, but her blatant desire to make him nothing more than property sickens me. They've had maybe one or two meaningful moments where Juvia actually thinks about gray, but the rest is her desire to possess him like some trophy. It's gross and I can't handle it anymore.

[Princess Iris]

.

https://mangahelpers...ID10,4600081749

S P O I L E R
Just is case you are curious

Just read the chapter again, yeah Gruvia makes me sick, and honestly, Juvia is starting to make me feel that way too. I just can't. I tried to like them together, but her blatant desire to make him nothing more than property sickens me. They've had maybe one or two meaningful moments where Juvia actually thinks about gray, but the rest is her desire to possess him like some trophy. It's gross and I can't handle it anymore.

To be very honest, I feel that too
I don't know why but I hate it when girls chase for guys this way.
I couldn't like them this way



@CodusN
Lucy connected to Zeref???
Can you explain??please ...

Edited by Princess Iris, 07 June 2015 - 06:24 AM.

[Codus N]

There was a rough draft in one of the GMG volumes that Mashima scrapped which had Zeref meeting Lucy. Which implies that Mashima has something planned for Zeref and Lucy in the future. Two other big hints are Layla's knowledge of the One Magic, and the CSK addressing Marde as if they were old enemies. That alone implies the spirits having a connection with Zeref as well.

[Princess Iris]

Yeah CSK Mard interaction implied their old enmity

Do u have that old draft???

[Phantom_999]

I just don't find characters with only a single person in their thought process interesting or amusing. I don't hate them but I won't ever say any thing above I kind of like their charactter if just a little bit. I thought it would be more interesting that Juvia does this from time to time but shows to actually think of or interact with other guild members such as Gajeel since she reccomended him. Plus do some with Meredy since they seem to be on way beter terms now.

Edited by Phantom_999, 07 June 2015 - 05:37 PM.

[harry4e]

Gotta say no impressed with the reveal in this weeks chapter, not so much the content but the fact that we are 439 chapters in and we are hearing about this now, and that we've not seen any conflict between the two nations at all, and i'm not even sure if it had been mentioned before, the war would have happened two years before the manga started, so it should be fresh in the minds of all the gang, he conflict between the guilds itself sounds even more confusing now as it would have ment that the guilds would have been united against the threat of an outside force, and be less likely to squable against each other.

 

This is in many ways worst that the Kaguya reveal and the reveal of the twin brother of the sage, atleast that could be argued as being part of a forgotten era, this is all recent, and the nation still stands.

 

http://www.mangapand.../fairy-tail/439

[Phantom_999]

discuss

Uuh was it that they fought Arbaless Or was Arbaless stopped before the fighting actually started? If it's the latter
then I can see why it's classified info for only the ten saints and the council but if not then yeah no excuse really

[harry4e]

discuss

Uuh was it that they fought Arbaless Or was Arbaless stopped before the fighting actually started? If it's the latter
then I can see why it's classified info for only the ten saints and the council but if not then yeah no excuse really

 

Yeah but they still attempted, that would be enough to make the people weary, but there has been no mention of it at all, and even the previous arc with the face there was no mention of it, the other country still carries a threat of war. Yet for some reason the guild members seem to be unaware of that threat, the guild masters of Foire, dispite knowing that there is a massive threat close by for the vast majority don't seem to promote inter-guild relationships, instead seem to be at conflict with each other.

 

This part was too similar to the war declaration of Obito and then him turning up with an army of 100k Zetsu's, only worst, infact one thing Naruto did well was make the ninjas aware of the possible outside threat of the neibouring countries, dispite them living in relative peace for over a decade, the nations were still weary of they threat of each other invading. In Fairy Tail they all seem to be unaware of it.

[Codus N]

Not really disagreeing with you, but the difference between Nardo and this arc is that unlike Nardo, you always got the feeling that Earthland is actually much bigger than we thought. So this was a welcome surprise. But like you, I agree that the set-up is definitely shaky, at best. The only bit of foreshadowing we got was back during the Sun Village arc when Warrod mentioned another continent beyond Ishval.

[TouKen4Life3g]

I give them credit to explain why the other continent didn't happen until now, because it does make sense. However, while small hints here and there, I wish it was more build towards it. For those who said Kaguya, remember, she was revealed within the same arc and literally replace the main villain within. This one is an arc that really only adds, not replace. It has been said in the past, so it doesn't feel that out of place. It's expansion, not replacing.

That said I can only for all out war with two continent. Since this series is like RPG, I want world vs world or server vs server.

Edited by NaruSaku4Life3g, 08 June 2015 - 02:44 PM.

[harry4e]

Not really disagreeing with you, but the difference between Nardo and this arc is that unlike Nardo, you always got the feeling that Earthland is actually much bigger than we thought. So this was a welcome surprise. But like you, I agree that the set-up is definitely shaky, at best. The only bit of foreshadowing we got was back during the Sun Village arc when Warrod mentioned another continent beyond Ishval.

 

Yeah Earthland has always been bigger than the area that the FT group covered, I think the first chapter covered it well, I always got the feeling Fiore was based on the United Kingdom which itself was part of a Continent, and there was a bigger world. however the lack of any info has always bugged me, and because the manga made no mention of it, I'd concluded that maybe the rest of the world is not filled with Magic folk, and for some reason the continent where FT is based is rich with the elements required for magicians. That was why we had the other world attack them, or why Jellal was carrying out his plans here, or why the followers of Zeref seem to be based here.  The rest of the world was not involved in it, which is strange when you consider all the enemies actions would have affected the entire world.