Umm... you didn't read very carefully did you??
Yes I did read it, but you forgot something....
QUOTE
The poster said that Tobi just might bring back (ET) Madara to life with his last breath somehow by using the Rinnegan that he has now.
2 reasons why this won't work.
1. What would be the reason to do it? It won't accomplish his goals and it doesn't serve purpose to the story other than a deus ex machina to lengthen the story. Really what purpose would it serve other than another battle to fight? Even if there is some sort of purpose it probably can be done with a simpler and cleaner method. Kabuto brought him back because it served as a war asset and a trump card.
2. Can it even be done? As Nagato showed he couldn't bring back everyone like Jiraiya. It specifically mentions that there is kind of a time limit to how long it takes to bring someone back to life. Madara died a long time ago. If Nagato can't bring back Jiraiya, how is Tobi, who basically cheated to get his Rinnegan, able to do it?
QUOTE
So the possibility is very much open there. With the added catch that since he's no longer ET, he's killable since he becomes human again. Plus, he has to be just as hard to kill when he's human. As for the bolded, it's exactly why he's final villain material. The impossibility of defeating him and that no one can possibly do so other than Hashirama, is exactly why he's the final villain. Who better than the HERO himself defeating him??
Let's a draw a line here. Everything is a possibility especially in a fictional world. The writer can do whatever he feels like. He can make it rain cheese if he wished. The real brain tease is why and how? Why would they do it and how does it contribute to the story? If you just write everything in there, it gets to be a mess. So instead of looking at what is impossible or possible, let's look at practicality. So...here we go.
I was always assuming that when ET gets dispelled they just fade and dissolve. They don't return to being human. Otherwise Itachi would stay on the field as well and clearly in this chapter Itachi assure this as he said he will be gone when this is done. So, no, once it gets dispelled, ET Madara goes bye-bye.
I don't want mindless battles just so we can see the hero or whoever fight. That's not how Kishimoto writes. Everything has a purpose. Bringing Madara back to life serves no purpose at all other than a new villain. Then we have to create another back story where Madara had a troubled past and we need to feel sympathetic cause he grew up around war time and fighting is all he knew. Then we have some other crap where he is not really a villain he is just misunderstood and Naruto just talks his way out of battle.....am I joking?
And for that matter, what's wrong with Tobi? He is a fine villain so far. No back story, bent on world domination, hates everyone. That's good enough for me.
Why would Tobi, if he even can perform the jutsu, bring back Madara? I also doubt he would do it with his dying breath. If he could do it, why not just do it now? Bring back Madara back to life right now and then make a deal with him or something. Does the ET interfere with that or would the ET just be cancelled out? See smart villains don't just do stuff without thinking. Even with back up plans, they are set in motion and rarely do stuff on the fly. Tobi is a smart villain and he probably is not the type of guy to do something without cause or reason.
Edited by James S Cassidy, 30 May 2012 - 04:39 PM.