I have that fear too, but could you imagine Shikamaru who was supposed to be Naruto's right hand man join the fight too?
Logically, it would be highly beneficial to have Shikamaru involved in such a fight, but considering the intimacy of the Sasuke and Team 7 relationship any outside parties assisting beyond providing moral support would feel inappropriate. I do not even believe that Sai or Yamato having involvement in the fight would appear befitting since this is related to the original Team 7. Sai and Yamato were merely replacements when Sasuke and Kakashi were unavailable to assume their roles. Granted, they have developed their own unique positions on the team but that does not negate the reality of the Sasuke dynamic having little relevance to them as they were assigned after he had already defected.
QUOTE
The problem I have is Sakura has to get involved some how, she just can't stand there especially not after what she said. I know Naruto wishes one thing, but come on Sakura has made a point that Naruto doesn't understand the truth of things quite yet and that he needs a wake up call.
That is why I created a few particular hypothetical situations where she may be able to contribute in some capacity. Sakura could assist with providing the occasional unsuspecting offensive attack that would damage Sasuke's Susanoo which would allow Naruto to strike at Sasuke directly or should Naruto be rendered temporarily unable to fight Sakura could intervene at some point when both sides have exhausted all of their resources beyond their fundamental capabilities.
Sakura can be as dedicated and emotionally objective as need be but what physical benefit does it have if you are only going to burst forth and perish because of lack of an actual battle strategy or the skills necessary to counteract any and all of Sasuke's techniques? Beyond the aforementioned prospect of Sakura acquiring an unforeseen power enhancement such as Slug Sage Mode, she would only act as more of a detriment than an asset in a combat situation.
QUOTE
I think the bigger question you really should be asking is if Sasuke shifted sides already, then why would Naruto and Sasuke fight at all? Since the final battle proposed by Kishimoto is naruto vs Sasuke, it would be terribly bad to not have the fight happen.
A sudden shift in loyalties due to Madara's influence is one potential reason? Remember that one critical aspect of Sasuke's personality is that his mind and emotions are considered to be a "blank canvas", he can be influenced by anyone should they provide the necessary motivations or words to make him alter his perspective yet again. Then there's ideological divergences when aspiring to defend Konoha that could be another reason as others have hypothesized. Then of course there is the possible development of Sasuke wishing to acquire the position of Hokage which may compel the two rivals to fight in a battle that determines who becomes the 6th (or the 7th if you consider Danzo to be the 6th)
QUOTE
I know that Juugo would follow Sasuke without question. I got that ever since they first met. You know what I mean?
Yes, but I will not completely deny the potentiality of him defecting. Anything is possible.
QUOTE
Let me ask, when has Hinata done anything in a "physically practical manner?" I'll explain down below.
Acted as a scout during the Itachi Pursuit Arc, assisted in protecting Naruto from the Mokuton stakes, and put his shoulder back into place. They're relatively minor accomplishments but I also consider the emotional ones as well since we tend to do the same with Sakura. I would rather not appear as a hypocrite to others for failing to acknowledge those sorts of contributions.
QUOTE
And this is the problem Naruto has. See Sasuke is not Naruto's problem...Sasuke is Team 7's problem. Given that Naruto is so determined to die for Sasuke, I half expecting Sakura to knock some sense into him. As we know Sasuke is a different subject than fighting the juubi.
You are accurate in this statement but think to yourself, what physical benefit could she possibly provide now? Her supplications to Sasuke for him to relent in his murderous pursuits have continually fallen upon deaf ears. If she is unable to verbally influence him and if she cannot physically assist due to her comparatively inefficient combat skills for such a destructive battle then what role could she possibly act in? Any reinforcement she can offer will likely come in the form of encouragement to Naruto or as a restorative supplement to her teammate; if that even occurs at all. Remember that Kishimoto has greatly disappointed all fandoms during the course of the manga.
QUOTE
Then you wonder why people question Sakura's heroism. It's not that she doesn't do heroic things, it is that people neglect what she does do and pays more attention to what she doesn't.
This is true. No matter what her intentions may be or or if she in fact effectuates any significant contributions to the characters or the plot they will continue to demean her; hence my previous assertion it appears to be a proclivity for them to berate her character.
QUOTE
Meanwhile, I am judging Hinata based on both. The list you have made, which I cut out to save space, but read anyway, just shows that even with all her actions many still say she is not a heroine. Even to Kishi this is surprising as he even wondering why nobody sees her as being heroic. Is it because she isn't full on fangirling Naruto? I am not sure.
I believe that the reasoning for this perspective of thinking is related to Sakura's lack of any enormous conflicts that she participated in as a combatant. Keep in mind that these people surmise the worth of a character by their general battle efficiency. However, that does present the peculiarity of why they value Hinata's existence so much when she has remained almost non-existent throughout the totality of the manga until recently; even with the battle against the Jubi her role as a participant in the battle has been comparatively inconsequential.
QUOTE
Simple. She interferes with their love pairing of choice. If they didn't see her as a threat, they probably wouldn't even bother. I don't know if this is a good thing or a bad thing.
Oh, I have little uncertainty that they would berate Sakura for her emotions when related to Sasuke or her "incompetence" as a heroine (in a manga where the author is a self-proclaimed ignoramus on the matter of creating female heroes or female characters in general). Even without her symbolism as the impediment to everything that these people dedicate themselves to in regards to pairings they would persist in criticizing as it has become a "humourous normality" to them.
QUOTE
Exactly. This is why I blame them. I know Kishimoto has a hard time depicting at times and even gives these weird outcomes, and I do hold him accountable for them, but still when Kishimoto does want to depict a character heroically we the fans need to accept that. If he says she is being a hero, then there is no question and if people do it is because they are biased.
Well no one is perfect in opinion or action, Kishimoto is no different. If he defines a heroine as an individual who has been generally inefficient with maintaining an equal amount of focus to that of her male teammates or someone who's status as a main character is being constantly centred upon as a contentious issue of debate then I'm afraid our opinions diverge from here. Kishi's handling of Sakura's character is of a very questionable quality, I believe I speak not just for myself when stating that many of us were hoping for so much more from her than what we received.
QUOTE
I'm sorry, but I have to strongly disagree. Hinata's actions have little to no merit from them. The Pein Arc confession is just one good example how NOT to do it.
The confession segment of her efforts is not my concern, it's her actions of attempting to protect Naruto and presumably being killed which inadvertently resulted in Naruto being released from Pain's grasp. Yes, it could very well have resulted in the destruction of not just Konoha but the Land of Fire entirely but it did not thanks to Minato's efforts. Her actions did yield an unintentional positive effect. That, I cannot deny because had she not intervened... Well, I believe I already provided my thoughts as to what would occur if Naruto did not transform into 6TK.
QUOTE
There are so many things she could have done. So many ways she could have helped, but instead she just runs out, confesses, and then "dies." I have seen heroes do stupid things, but at least they try to fix the problem or attempt to fix something despite failing. Hinata just seemed to not care what would happen. She didn't try to remove the stakes or create a distraction and she blindly jumped into battle not knowing anything.
This, I am in agreement with. There were a myriad of alternative approaches that she could have taken which may have actually proved to be directly beneficial in helping Naruto. She could have attempted to remove the rods, but then you have to consider what practical benefit there would be to Naruto being released in the condition that he was in. Remember that Fukasaku had just been murdered and Shima was incapacitated. If Naruto was freed then he would be without SM or any practical means of stopping Pain; barring of course the reproduction of following events where Naruto was able to endure God Realm's ST using a multitude of clones and then be propelled at him with a Rasengan in hand. But then you have the issue of how and why Naruto would produce those clones when considering the different circumstances such as the availability of reacquiring SM if he is able to reach the summoning scroll in time, the relatively flat terrain which would hinder the concealment of mass amounts of clone, and Nagato's larger amount of stamina due to not having utilized Chibaku Tensei prior. Who is to claim that Naruto would not endeavour to try and make an effort for the scroll whilst Hinata preoccupies Pain? If she is injured then the same result with 6TK being unleashed would be realized and events would play out as they did.
There are so many factors that you have to take into consideration when hypothesizing about these alternative outcomes that it becomes an almost impossible endeavour.
QUOTE
Unlike Sakura who was willing to risk everything, not just her life, so Naruto could be free and live a happy life. That is true heroism.
Sakura does have her ignorant moments as well. Despite her benevolent intentions when attempting to reason with Naruto when he was in 4TK mode it was very impracticable when considering that the beast before her was immensely more powerful than she was and that Naruto had lost all mentality and consciousness when he surpassed the 3TK state. Please do not mistake my implications. I do believe that she is a very meaningful hero in regards to emotional relations with others. However, there is a fine line between dedication and stupidity. Her actions with the 4TK were of an intermixed quality but there have been other instances where she has committed actions of both qualities.
QUOTE
If Minato didn't think ahead and implanted those fail-safes then Naruto would have died indefinitely and taken out everyone. So not only did she put her life in danger, she put her love's life in danger and every villager just to say "I love you."
Yes, and if Hinata had not intervened Pain would have likely successfully returned to the Akatsuki lair with Naruto in tow. I already provided my personal interpretation as to how events would transpire if Naruto did not become the 6TK. The intended ambiance of my hypothetical timeline was that, to be frank, the situation would be much worse than it became with Hinata's interference. Konoha would remain in the ravaged state that it was with much of its population forever gone, its infrastructure completely crippled, and one of their most powerful shinobi permanently killed. Never mind the adverse effects that Naruto being captured would entail such as Pain still being an active Akatsuki member, the White Zetsu army continuing their guerilla strategy to slowly cripple the alliance forces, and the reality that Itachi, one of the most powerful shinobi in the manga, would remain under Kabuto's control without Naruto's encounter providing the necessary means for him to escape.
There are two sides to any particular situation. In this one, whilst there may have been potential repercussions to Hinata unintentionally releasing the 6TK form, in comparison to the alternative which would undoubtedly result in the apocalypse that we are seeing now but with no Naruto available to rescue everyone, it is definitely the more preferable outcome.
QUOTE
It is also not like she saved the entire village because Tsunade did that already. Then you would have had Pein take the Nine-tails anyway.
Tsunade's efforts may have been in vain had Pain succeeded in capturing Naruto and then decided to kill anyone that survived as he characteristically would if we are abiding by the depiction of Pain given that he is an indiscriminate, "almighty" godlike figure who destroys any and all connections to those whom someone he was in opposition with may have had. Then of course there's the personal vendetta which Nagato appeared to have with Tsunade over the matter of foreign policy that would likely have compelled him to hunt down Tsunade once Naruto had been securely removed from the area.
QUOTE
My biggest issue with this is that people are giving her way too much credit than she deserves and it could have very well gone from bad to worse because of her. Hinata is not exactly known for her feats of strength or endurance and even at times has little faith in Naruto's abilities to the point of babying him. That's pretty sad when you don;t even have faith in your love.
It is as others have hypothesized about her, her primary function is to act as encouragement when Naruto is in despair. She displayed that role during the Chunin Exams and recently in chapter 615. Beyond that, however, I have to agree that her character is relatively inessential apart from acting as a rivaling force in the heated pairing debates and the few instances where her actions brought about a more significant effect through others.
QUOTE
As for the indirectly, again I could say anything. Naruto indirectly created the alliance. Is it true? I am sure I can make it true somewhere starting with the sand village. So it is hard to take it credible.
Naruto's only relation to the alliance's original making is the fact that he was a jinchuuriki that Akatsuki was attempting to capture whom all of the nations' leaders were creating policy against due to their actions as a terrorist organization which resulted in the five great nations' military capabilities being weakened considerably (Konoha and Suna being the most significantly impacted). Ironically, the initial reasoning for the world coming together is in fact related to Tobi's actions and his proclamation of war.
QUOTE
One last problem I see is that whenever Hinata faces a problem, it is always someone else that bails her out.
Let's examine all of the instances where Hinata was in a pinch, shall we?
1. Gaara's blood lusted desires and Team 8 who were concealed within some vegetation appeared that they may be the ones to die in order to satiate Gaara's impulses - Her usage of the Byakugan in locating Gaara's team is partially responsible for this situation but the group was unaware of just how powerful and demented Gaara was. Furthermore, it was Kiba's insistence that they attempt to acquire more scrolls that acted as the primary cause for them being placed into that situation. Temari and Kankuro's insistence that Gaara relent is what ultimately spared Team 8, specifically Hinata, their lives. So yes, you are technically correct in this instance albeit Hinata was only a part of the reason for their situation becoming as detrimental as it was.
2. Her battle against Neji - Hinata was originally going to quit but due to Naruto's incessant advocating for her to continue in a fight that she could not possibly win she chose to continue. I credit her, as most people should, for her character development here but ultimately her decision was physically impractical as she required hospitalization for the damage caused to her internal organs which afflicted her for a month following the battle. This situation was not just her own doing but Naruto's as well for his insistence that she continue fighting.
3. Intervention against Pain - A situation that was entirely of her own volition which required Hinata to be healed by Sakura. Yes, this is in accordance with all of the conditions that you stated with no ambiguity implied through others influencing the situation or her. I would persist in arguing that her involvement was better than the alternative transpiring however.
4. Protecting Naruto from the Mokuton spikes - It was the Hyuga family that was safeguarding Naruto as a group and considering the state that Naruto was in protection of him was essential. Yes, she was technically "bailed out" by Neji using his own body to absorb the impact of the spikes but considering the severity of the situation I cannot hold this against her. Everyone was defenceless against Madara and the Jubi at that point. All they could do was avoid the spikes as best they could.
So yes, your statement is technically accurate but there needs to be consideration of the factors involved which could potentially exonerate Hinata of any unjustified criticism that people may apply to her character.
QUOTE
Like I said with Minato. We know Naruto has bailed out Sakura in some problems, but some of them we know she could have done with her own strength. This is especially true in part 2.
Some of them yes, but others, sadly, I do not believe she would have been able to avoid using what strength and the mentality that Kishi was currently assigning to her. Once again, let us go down the list.
1. The Demon Brothers assault against Tazuna - This was Sakura's first experience with actual combat. Considering the stress of the situation and her unsuitable capabilities at the time to properly defend Tazuna she would in aliklihood have been killed had Kakashi and Sasuke not intervened.
2. Zabuza appearing before her twice in both battles - As with the Demon Brothers, she was incapable of fighting such a dangerous opponent and required Kakashi's assistance to prevent being killed.
3. Orochimaru's petrifying stare - Sakura had collapsed onto the ground and was in emotional turmoil. Even Sasuke, who is general composed and capable in battle, was having a difficult time moving and required the alternative sensation of pain to compel his body to maneuver so that he could rescue Sakura and himself
4. Team Dosu - The skirmish was inconclusive technically but she would have likely perished had Team 10 not intervened. She was bloodied and beaten whilst Team Dosu remained in comparatively fine battle condition. Sakura would have been killed without outside assistance.
5. Entrapment by Gaara - There was nothing Sakura could have done with her abilities at the time which had remained almost completely unchanged excluding "genjutsu training" by Kakashi off-screen and the tree climbing exercises. Without Naruto's assistance she would have been compressed to death by the pressure of the sand
6. Battle against Sasori - Ah yes, Sakura's most profound physical achievement was her victory over Sasori. Well initially she required Chiyo's assistance just to prevent herself from being killed but over time as she began to comprehend Sasori's attack patterns she was able to do battle on her own. In the end, however, she required Chiyo's assistance to succeed.
7. Attempt to persuade Naruto whilst he was in 4TK mode - Naruto had lost all consciousness by this point and Sakura was severely outmatched. There was nothing she have done on her own.
8. Rush against Sasuke - We do not know precisely what would have occurred if Yamato had not intervened. It's possible that Sakura could have avoided Sasuke's attacks but for how long? Of course she could not defeat Sasuke at that instant, none of them could, including Naruto.
9. First attempt to kill Sasuke - Sasuke still had enough strength remaining to produce numerous Chidoris and activate MS. Even if Sakura were of a bloodlusted mindset she could have done nothing to successfully kill Sasuke with him fully aware of her actions.
10. Second attempt to kill Sasuke - Sasuke was exhausted, partially blind, and fixated on Kakashi. Sakura had the ideal opportunity to kill Sasuke here but chose not to due to the memories she had of him when they were still together as companions on Team 7. This is one situation which she could have overcome using her own strength, yes.
11. White Zetsu assault - The two disguised White Zetsu clones were lunging at Sakura but before she could do anything Naruto's clone had intervened and rescued her. It's uncertain precisely how events would have transpired without interference but I have little doubt that Sakura could defeat two clones on her own
12. Mokuton Stakes - Apparently Sakura was unable to avoid the stakes, much to my personal displeasure, and from what information we can gather of her reaction as well as Kakashi needing to assist her the most accurate assertion may be that she would not have been able to dodge the Mokuton on her own.
Out of all of these situations, I would claim that only two of them were within Sakura's capability to handle on her own. That is a ratio of 2:10 for Sakura's previous attempts of assessing a situation. As I much as I dislike that prospect I will not deny these facts.
QUOTE
It just goes to show that even though both Sakura and Hinata started out useless, Sakura changed to be more useless while Hinata stayed being useless for a while longer.
It was also a speech many have said and also Naruto has said himself. What she said wasn't new nor was it the only thing that swayed Naruto.
Even Kurama had to say something and this is the beast that originally wanted to kill him. So, the speech itself while appears grand, is not something new or what as new element Hinata added. I still believe it was hyped beyond it's original capacity.
Well this is quite the unforeseen shift in sentiments. I believed that I have already provided evidence that Sakura and Hinata have both made contributions to the store, directly or indirectly. So I do not feel the need to respond fully yet again to this disputing point.
Really? Naruto attributed credit for his revitalized mindset to Hinata. Yes, Kurama played a very significant role as well in persuading him not to relent, but to try and repudiate Hinata's efforts which Naruto himself provided credit to is, in my honest opinion, unreasonable and insensate. Though I may not be particularly fond of her character, I will personally not deny credit to her when it is due.
I believe it was hyped as well. Her fanbase was ecstatic by the event because they presumed that it would allow the prospect of Hinata fighting alongside Naruto against the Jubi to come to pass. As we are now aware, that didn't happen, at least not in the manner which her fans were hoping for. The motivational speech did have its place however, and Hinata does warrant some credit for her efforts.